Re: Smithman theory

by Silentscope 08.06.24 19:55

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] wrote: Then this complex reasoning might not be the right one.
Smithman didn't wander around, he was probably going to put the body in the water, so the next tide would bring it back to the beach and a funeral could take place. The S family forced him to come up with a plan B, no doubt improvised.

A. If Madeleine had been internally injured as described in Kate’s book then any chance of a Benevolent force like the Ocean returning her for a Post Mortem and proper Burial can be ruled out.
The body would talk. Therefore it should never be found.

by AnneCGuedes 08.06.24 19:59

Peter didn't notice anything in particular, too worried about his wife who wasn't feeling well. Martin noticed that the man was not carrying the child comfortably and Mary that he lacked courtesy (no greeting). Aoife has an eagle eye, but she had the advantage of still being on the steps leading to 25 April Street and of seeing Smithman from a low angle, which widened her perspective.

by AnneCGuedes 08.06.24 20:16

Silentscope wrote:
A. If Madeleine had been internally injured as described in Kate’s book

As described in Kate's book ?

Of course, in such a scenario, M would have been the victim of a predator who had finally dumped her into the ocean to remove all traces of his DNA. With a bit of luck crabs would have already started cleaning the body. The autopsy could only have confirmed that the child had not drowned.

by crusader 09.06.24 9:14

Goncalo Amaral said Madeleine was stored in a freezer, this video talks about the Smith sighting and access to a freezer.

It wont post here so just click on Watch on You Tube

by AnneCGuedes 09.06.24 17:15

Sometimes newborn babies, not 4-year-olds, are kept in freezers, but belonging to the progenitor. Lambs, if not industrially, are frozen in pieces, not whole, in special packaging and for no longer than 6/8 months to avoid decay. GA tried but couldn't bury his tiny dog, the ground was too hard, so he found another solution, but not the freezer one !

by crusader 09.06.24 17:27

Do you believe Madeleine was kept in a fridge before being moved and put in the hire car Anne?

by AnneCGuedes 09.06.24 17:51

No, Crusader, I don't believe Madeleine was kept in a fridge nor elsewhere. Two points struck me as decisive in the group's statements about the night of the disappearance before the arrival of the GNR : G was roaring like a bull and K let out a scream that Salcedas would never forget.

by crusader 09.06.24 18:00

I don't believe Madeleine was kept in a freezer either.

by **Jill Havern** 09.06.24 18:16

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

by Cake Lover 09.06.24 18:19

Wouldn't a body be in something such as a waterproof, heavy duty refuse sack? That way, if thawing took place, there would be no leakage.

by AnneCGuedes 09.06.24 18:29

Can you have the cake (the body) and eat it (the abduction) ?

by Cake Lover 09.06.24 18:41

I don't think anybody would put an unwrapped corpse in the back of a car. The risk would be too great, and I'm surprised that Goncalo Amaral believes this happened, unless my theory is wrong.

by Silentscope 09.06.24 18:47

Of course if there were nothing to hide, cover up or mask the smell of, there would be no need to put smelly rubbish in the Boot area?
Or leave the Boot flap open to Air all night long.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Source: https://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/59-DA-27.htm

by crusader 09.06.24 19:03

Perhaps they were telling the truth about dirty nappies and fish.

by Cake Lover 09.06.24 19:05

Perhaps they were - all rattling around in the boot with groceries. Lovely.

by sandancer 09.06.24 21:02

Dirty nappies and fish , maybe it was Sean and his apparent liking for seabass , according to daddy Gerry anyway !

I wonder when the twins were toilet trained ? They made a big deal of them going into their own beds not cots ! But they made a big deal of many things - look over there not over here !

by AnneCGuedes 09.06.24 23:02

Can you have the cake (Madeleine's tomb, to grieve) and eat it (Madeleine's abduction, to save reputation) ?

by Silentscope 11.06.24 10:18

Someone removed the Cake in order to keep the Lie alive that it was Stolen.

Gerrys comment 'the Night WE found her' denotes a Night time Death when (they) Kate and Gerry found her together. https://youtu.be/z_YfUehsac0?feature=shared

They were not together on Thursday Night when they raised the Alarm.

Kate was alone in the Apartment during the crying incident on Tuesday.

by AnneCGuedes 11.06.24 17:25

It seems it is K leaving the flat after talking furiously on the phone to her friend/nanny who had woken her kids making some cry.

by sandancer 11.06.24 17:59

I always come back to Kate saying -

" I know what happened wasn't due to us leaving them sleeping , I know it happened under other circumstances "

First - " I know what happened ... "

Second - " it wasn't due to us leaving them sleeping ... "

Third - " it happened under other circumstances ... "

So she knows what happened , nothing to do with the kids being ( allegedly ) left sleeping
It , whatever " it " was , involved something else she's not prepared to say !

by crusader 11.06.24 18:09

And she want's to shout the truth that they know and God knows, from the rooftops.

by AnneCGuedes 11.06.24 18:13

It's very irritating to hear people imagining a narrative and attributing to you a role which is not yours. But it's very irritating for the public to hear people telling tall tales and it's no surprise that the public tries to find a plausible solution. The only thing K knows better is that M died, just because she saw her body. The rest (when, how exactly, with fear or anxiety, etc.) she has to guess.

by Honesty 11.06.24 19:37

May I ask you, Anne, how you think M died? I'm sorry if you've given your opinion about this previously.

by AnneCGuedes 11.06.24 21:02

Honesty, as M was probably dizzy (benzodiazepines ?), she might have fallen head first behind the sofa and been trapped without the strength to free herself. This type of suffocation accident is not uncommon.

by Honesty 11.06.24 21:27

Thank you, Anne. May I say I applaud you for all the hardwork and dedication you have put in with regard to this case.

by AnneCGuedes 11.06.24 22:28

Latest topics