Re: Could Maddie be in the garden of Casa Liliana?

by Flashford Thomas 16.10.12 20:51

Amaral is a civilian now so surely he has no authority to ask for anything?

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 20:53

Roy, that I will reveal after the body is exhumed, please respect the fact that this investigation only commences once the body is exhumed.

by Guest 16.10.12 20:54

Excuse me, but where the heck would they have gotten Madeleine's [resembling] DNA ... ????!!!
Planting cadaver scent is one thing [and surely not road-kill, thank you JATYK2], but DNA?
And now it's the PJ with knowledge of Dr. Amaral, instead of him planting it himself.
And the murderess in incest with her own brother has to be pitied, because - instead of 3 big unidentified policemen - a policewoman beat the truth out of her.
Jeez. Get yourself a life [no offense meant, just a recommendation].
***
ETA I posted before reading up to all comments before ...
Didn't change my mind, though.

by **Nina** 16.10.12 20:55

Have Robert Murat and his mother asked for the area to be searched?

by Lady-Heather 16.10.12 20:59

An excellent question sami. Why wouldn't they..? And to the other claim that the police allegedly lied, is that entirely implausible?

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:01

Mr Amaral and his attorney were contacted telephonically Friday by the largest newspaper in Portugal, Correio da Manha. Both Mr Amaral and his attorney made no effort to call for the excavation of the Murat driveway in the telephonic interview--

The Forum must realise that I speak to Portuguese journalists from various newspapers,magazines and TV stations at least 6 times a day.

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:03

The attorney for Robert Murat, Mr Franscio Pagarette was contacted via email - entry into the property for the purpose of excavating the driveway was denied.

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:07

The case of Amaral's involvement in the beating of a missing childs mother for 9 hours, to ellicit a confession is well documented in Portugal, and is known by most Portuguese citizens.The case received national press coverage, some years back.I am not familiar with the exact facts surrounding the case myself.

by sami 16.10.12 21:08

Have you contacted Ms Healy or Dr McCann ?

by Guest 16.10.12 21:11

Stephen Birch wrote:The case of Amaral's involvement in the beating of a missing childs mother for 9 hours, to ellicit a confession is well documented in Portugal, and is known by most Portuguese citizens.The case received national press coverage, some years back.I am not familiar with the exact facts surrounding the case myself.

***
You should, IMO, before speaking out.

by Guest 16.10.12 21:12

sami wrote:Have you contacted Ms Healy or Dr McCann ?

***
Also referred to as DRS McCann ...
I guess, he didn't.

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:15

If you watch the video link below you will see the reaction of Kate Mc Cann to my investigation - watch her left eye as my name is mentioned, watch it over and over !!!

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Kate Mc Cann continued to suspect Mr Robert Murat of having something to do with the abduction of Madeleine, 5 months after Mr Murat's arguido status was lifted !!!

by Guest 16.10.12 21:15

Stephen Birch wrote:The case of Amaral's involvement in the beating of a missing childs mother for 9 hours, to ellicit a confession is well documented in Portugal, and is known by most Portuguese citizens.The case received national press coverage, some years back.I am not familiar with the exact facts surrounding the case myself.

I suggest you do a bit of reading, these may help

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:16

I have had no contact with the Mc Cann's.

Regards

Stephen D. Birch

by sami 16.10.12 21:16

Stephen Birch wrote:The case of Amaral's involvement in the beating of a missing childs mother for 9 hours, to ellicit a confession is well documented in Portugal, and is known by most Portuguese citizens.The case received national press coverage, some years back.I am not familiar with the exact facts surrounding the case myself.

This reads as if it is some sort of revelation. The exact facts are well known to many on this forum. Even I, not a long standing member here, am familar with the facts. It would be advisable for you to read about the case and make yourself aware of the facts if you are using it as a benchmark on which to discredit Snr Amaral.

by sami 16.10.12 21:18

Sorry Candyfloss, our posts crossed, I did not see your link before posting.

by bristow 16.10.12 21:19

Stephen Birch, why don't you dig the Murat garden in the darkness of the night?
It would save all is this bother of posting on forums and writing to people in Portugal, you did it before albeit scanning with your machine so surely you can do it again?
If you get arrested then so be it but it would be worth the hassle if you found what you were looking for?

by Guest 16.10.12 21:19

sami wrote:
Stephen Birch wrote:The case of Amaral's involvement in the beating of a missing childs mother for 9 hours, to ellicit a confession is well documented in Portugal, and is known by most Portuguese citizens.The case received national press coverage, some years back.I am not familiar with the exact facts surrounding the case myself.

This reads as if it is some sort of revelation. The exact facts are well known to many on this forum. Even I, not a long standing member here, am familar with the facts. It would be advisable for you to read about the case and make yourself aware of the facts if you are using it as a benchmark on which to discredit Snr Amaral.

Yes, just posted some links above. From what SB is saying re the torture and beating, it sounds to me like he is rather talking to the wrong people . You haven't been talking to a certain lawyer have you, the one who just had a libel trial by any chance.

by sami 16.10.12 21:20

Stephen Birch wrote:I have had no contact with the Mc Cann's.

Regards

Stephen D. Birch

Why ?

by Guest 16.10.12 21:22

Stephen Birch wrote:If you watch the video link below you will see the reaction of Kate Mc Cann to my investigation - watch her left eye as my name is mentioned, watch it over and over !!!

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Kate Mc Cann continued to suspect Mr Robert Murat of having something to do with the abduction of Madeleine, 5 months after Mr Murat's arguido status was lifted !!!

***
Stephen, with all due respect, as I have for anyone whom I don't know and cannot proof wrong ...
Whatever Mrs [sorry Dr] McCan -Healy says about Mr. Murat doesn't mean anything to me.
However, whatever Mrs [sorry Dr] McCann-Healy says about herself [and not her missing daughter] means a lot to me and my thinking.

When you mention her left eye or whatever part of her physics: again it means nothing to me, apart from her superior feeling : catch me if you can ... IMO big grin

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:23

I speak directly to people who interviewed the Portuguese missing girls mother. My information is first hand. I do not rely on tabloids.

Do not for one minute think, that because I suspect Portuguese Police of wrongfully planting DNA evidence, I do not know who buried Madeleine Mc Cann in the Murat garden. We are talking about two issues here, and both these wrongful actions have resulted in this case being closed prematurely by Mr Jose Socrates and Mr Gordon Brown, 15 months after it was opened...........

Regards

Stephen D. Birch

by Guest 16.10.12 21:27

How have you got hold of this information Mr Birch. You say MI5 found out, how do you know this.

Okay, let's go with this for a minute, and play devils advocate, let's say what you say is true, I always like to look at things from every possible angle, yes, there are cases where police detectives are so frustrated and they know who comitted the crime but need that one bit of damning evidence, and yes, sometimes evidence may be planted. So for example, just a scenario, as I say playing devils advocate, It might also explain the sudden turnaround to the 100 per cent match, Martin Brunt talked about, to the DNA suddenly not being conclusive. It might also explain why it was a case of not wanting to let the public know, the Portuguese being embarrased at being found out such a huge worldwide case, and causing almighty problems for them so it was hushed up. We also know Socrates and Brown had meetings. We know they the Government say it is a case of National Security?? No evidence case shelved.

But the question has to be............ where did he get the DNA from Mr Birch? There really was none, apart from the blood underneath the tiles, which again was not a 100 per cent match. The only real thing in this case is the dogs, which are never wrong. They signalled at Apartment 5a, and we know no-one died there previously, and they also searched Murats garden thoroghly and didn't signal there. You say the machine couldn't go over rubble, but dogs can, and detect cadaver scent deep underground. So how do you explain that, and that is what I can't get past I'm afraid.

by uppatoffee 16.10.12 21:27

Stephen Birch wrote:I have had no contact with the Mc Cann's.

Regards

Stephen D. Birch

How about Carter Ruck?

Your story seems to have changed considerably since it first appeared in the press. I also agree that before you make libellous statements about the cipriano case that you make yourself aware of the facts.

Pleading the fifth amendment does nothing to help you gain support and convince people you are right!

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:27

If my theory is right, and MADELEINE is buried under the Murat rear gravel driveway - then can this Forum please indulge me , and tell me how the DNA got into a vehicle hired 25 days after Madeleine went missing -

by uppatoffee 16.10.12 21:31

Stephen Birch wrote:If my theory is right, and MADELEINE is buried under the Murat rear gravel driveway - then can this Forum please indulge me , and tell me how the DNA got into a vehicle hired 25 days after Madeleine went missing -

Well you are the one saying she died and was buried on the night of 3rd May. Not sure how many people on this forum actually believe that to be the case. I would definitely believe the evidence of the dogs over the unsubstantiated theory you are suggesting. big grin

by Stephen Birch 16.10.12 21:32

If you read this article, read what Carter Ruck says to crime correspondent David Lohr--- I have the email in my possession.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

I AM GOING TO ASK MEMBERS OF THE FORUM ONCE MORE -WHY WOULD AMARAL NOT CALL FOR THE DIG ????

by Guest 16.10.12 21:32

Stephen Birch wrote:If my theory is right, and MADELEINE is buried under the Murat rear gravel driveway - then can this Forum please indulge me , and tell me how the DNA got into a vehicle hired 25 days after Madeleine went missing -

If a body, any body, was wrapped in something, a carpet, blanket, put in a bag, then DNA and cadaver scent,would be on those items. They may not have been put with the body at the time, but got rid of at a later time. Applies to any case.

by uppatoffee 16.10.12 21:35

Stephen Birch wrote:If you read this article, read what Carter Ruck says to crime correspondent David Lohr--- I have the email in my possession.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

I AM GOING TO ASK MEMBERS OF THE FORUM ONCE MORE -WHY WOULD AMARAL NOT CALL FOR THE DIG ????

That doesn't answer the question about whether you have had contact with Carter Ruck.

by sami 16.10.12 21:35

Stephen Birch wrote:If my theory is right, and MADELEINE is buried under the Murat rear gravel driveway - then can this Forum please indulge me , and tell me how the DNA got into a vehicle hired 25 days after Madeleine went missing -

My opinion is that the body was never transported in the boot, rather the materials that had been used to wrap/store the body, were carried in the boot so they could be dumped.

by sami 16.10.12 21:38

Stephen Birch wrote:If you read this article, read what Carter Ruck says to crime correspondent David Lohr--- I have the email in my possession.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

I AM GOING TO ASK MEMBERS OF THE FORUM ONCE MORE -WHY WOULD AMARAL NOT CALL FOR THE DIG ????

Why are you shouting ? I would ask again, why would he, why should he ? Perhaps he actually knows what happened, albeit never had a chance to prove it.

And again, why have you not contacted the missing childs parents.

Latest topics