Re: Jane Tanner Liar?

by Guest 07.03.17 22:24

It really does conjure up an odd scene. Her first impressions are very striking. I find it all odd. I was listening to a lady on the radio today who had experienced trauma and she sounded very monotone - as if she was unable to convey all the emotions she was dealing with because of the shock - something had shut down and yet this seems the opposite - hysterical?

by **Nina** 07.03.17 22:42

Snipped from the statement.................
She opened the wardrobes of that room in order to confirm that Madeleine wasn't eventually hiding there.
How did she open the wardrobes?
The cots were in front of them on the PJ photographs.

by Phoebe 07.08.17 0:52

Reading Jane Tanner's rogatory statement a section caught my attention -

Do you know a John, John CLAXMAN”?
Reply    “Ah yes, that’s erm, the reason that’s Christine is his wife and he, so I can show you her number, I haven’t actually got his number in, haven’t actually got his number in here but I’ve got Christine, I’ve actually called her PAXMAN because I thought her name was PAXMAN”.

4078    “That’s on there yes, yes”.
Reply    “Oh does that say, oh right okay yeah sorry”.

4078    “Ends in 510 yes”?
Reply    “Yeah it does yeah, you know it’s cos it’s under Christine”.

4078    “Do you remember why you were in touch with him that day”?
Reply    “Erm well I think it would be Christine, I think she’s obviously, erm she’s just a friend from Exeter again, what day was that”?

4078    “That was on the second”?
Reply    “Erm, can only think that she would have text me to say do you want to come somewhere with us, she’s got kids the same age as me, do you want to come somewhere with the kids and I would have text back saying no, sorry we’re on holiday, I can’t think, I can’t

4078    “Yes I know”.

Reply    “No, that’s the only thing I can think "

How realistic is it to have a friend you know so well that she rings you to ask if your children want a play-date together yet you don't know her correct surname? An internet search for any John or Christine Claxman, Exeter draws a blank but, interestingly, an alternative is offered - a Dr. Christine Flaxman, who is a research technician employed by the University Of Exeter Medical School - the very same university where Jane Tanner works- [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Jane Tanner

Profile
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

[size]
Jane Tanner
Email:
Extension: 5811
Telephone: 01392 725811

Web Marketing Officer (Web Team)

I maintain and develop the websites that represent the College.
My working hours are Mon-Thurs, 9am to 3pm
[/size]
Maybe Jane "mistook" Flaxman for Paxman when she spoke to her on May 2nd ?

by Phoebe 07.08.17 1:15

Oddly enough, the same Dr. Christine Flaxman , ( if it was she who was called) had the necessary experience and qualifications to have been useful to the Tapas 9

[size=30]Dr Christine Flaxman [/size]graduated from the University of Wales College of Cardiff with a degree in Microbiology with Genetics. She completed a PhD at the University of Warwick studying antibiotic biosynthesis in the soil bacterium Streptomyces coelicolor. She subsequently worked at the Forensic Science Service where she worked in the research department on DNA profiling techniques, before training as an expert witness to report results of casework to the police. After a career break, to look after her children when they were young, she started working for the Clinical Research Facility as an administrator working on research studies involved with the onset and progression of diabetes.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

forensicsciencenewseek.blogspot.in/2014/.../forensic-science-service-priory-house.ht...
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[list="margin-right: 0px; margin-left: 0px; padding-right: 0px; padding-left: 0px; border: 0px;"]
[*][You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[/list]
[size]
Forensic Science Service, 109 Lambeth Rd, London SEl 7Le United .... Forensic ScienceInternational 112 Jonathan Whitaker , Christine Flaxman , Nick Brown ...[/size]

by polyenne 07.08.17 7:53

But why did the interviewer ask her about John Claxman......where did he/she get that name from if JTs phones directory said Paxman ?

And why would she list her "friend" Christine under her husbands name ?

by Phoebe 07.08.17 12:07

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

" Do you know a John, John CLAXMAN”?
Reply “Ah yes, that’s erm, the reason that’s Christine is his wife and he, so I can show you her number, I haven’t actually got his number in, haven’t actually got his number in here but I’ve got Christine, I’ve actually called her PAXMAN because I thought her name was PAXMAN”

Since Jane replies that the number for John Claxman is NOT stored in her phone memory - "I haven't actually got his number in, haven't actually got his number in here" I wonder how the Leicestershire Police knew that the unnamed call came from "John Claxman"?

According to The McCann files ( Paulo Reiss report)

"However, there are potentially serious omissions:

* The most important records were not available when Mr and Mrs McCann attended their 'Arguido interviews' on 6th and 7th September 2007 and it is doubtful that they were ever reviewed by the very experienced analysts from the Leicestershire Police, whose team left the Algarve soon after the McCann's return to the UK in September 2007
* There are no detailed call records from the mobile operators for Kate McCann, Russell O'Brien, Matthew Oldfield and Jane Tanner"

Given that it was during the British rogatory interviews Jane claimed to have mistaken Claxman for Paxman, I don't believe the L.P. had done any further checking re. her phone messages of the previous May. I think they had been given the name John Claxman by someone. I also have no trust in the L.P.! I'm not claiming that this DNA crime specialist was called on May 2nd for advice, but I do believe that if there was contact with her for any reason it would have been hushed up, given her role at the same F.S.S. which had tested Madeleine's DNA with such a controversial result. I may be on the wrong track completely but find it hard to swallow that someone does not know a close friend's surname.

A search of the White Pages Exeter and Devon returns - "0 results for the name Claxman"

You Searched For First Name: JOHN Last Name: CLAXMAN With First Name: CHRISTINE With Last Name: CLAXMAN Town: EXETER Region: South West We Found 0 Records
Please refine your search and try again. Try a different spelling of a name or expand the area you’re searching.

UK Electoral Registers 1980-2017

by polyenne 07.08.17 15:15

Also from JTs rogatory:

4078 “Do you know a Maxine”?
Reply “Oh again, that’s a friend, that’s just a friend from Exeter erm yeah can’t remember what her second name is but yeah it’s just a friend that I (inaudible) next to, give you her address, she lives near the motorway”.

She's got all these friends that she doesn't know the name of !!

by Phoebe 07.08.17 17:09

From Jane Tanner rogatory -

4078    “And there are, there are just three more, this is mobile +, +44 7958 704510”?
Reply    “510”.

4078    “It’s just somebody that YOU texted at eight twenty one in the morning on the second of May and they texted you back at five past ten the same day in the morning”.
Reply    “Sorry, the last three numbers again I (inaudible)”.

4078    “510”........

Reply    “Ah yes, that’s erm, the reason that’s Christine is his wife and he, so I can show you her number, I haven’t actually got his number in, haven’t actually got his number in here but I’ve got Christine, I’ve actually called her PAXMAN because I thought her name was PAXMAN”.

4078    “That’s on there yes, yes”.
Reply    “Oh does that say, oh right okay yeah sorry”.

4078    “Ends in 510 yes”?
Reply    “Yeah it does yeah, you know it’s cos it’s under Christine

So "Christine's" number is the one ending in 510. According to the records JANE was the one who contacted this number first and later that day it contacted her back. Therefore Jane's explanation that Christine had contacted her to arrange a play-date, not knowing Jane was abroad on holiday, makes no sense.

by polyenne 07.08.17 17:18

And she even forgets to notify her child's pre-school that they're on holiday (as they were seemingly busy at the hospital (?)the week before they left).

Lucky she remembered her toothbrush

by Phoebe 12.08.17 15:48

I've received a p.m. from a member indicating that there was indeed contact via text messages between Jane Tanner and Dr. Christine Flaxman at 8:21:46 and 10:05:20 on May 2nd 2007. I haven't put the chart up as I can't separate it from the rest of the message (too techno challenged) but if I get the member's permission I will post it. Why then did Jane Tanner lie and designate the contact as either Claxman or Paxman, claiming to be unsure of her name? She works at the same university, Exeter, as Dr. Flaxman so it's most unlikely she didn't know her name! Was she trying to hide the fact that she had been in contact with Dr. Christine Flaxman, a published expert in the area of low copy DNA analysis, who also had worked at the F.S.S. Birmingham where the blood samples recovered from 5G were tested with such controversial results? Or, did she have another reason for hiding the contact made on May 2nd?

by Verdi 12.08.17 16:45

Phoebe wrote:I've received a p.m. from a member indicating that there was indeed contact via text messages between Jane Tanner and Dr. Christine Flaxman at 8:21:46 and 10:05:20 on May 2nd 2007.

Before this goes too far - can you at least clarify how it can be said with such certainty that Jane Tanner exchanged text message/s with 'Dr. Christine Flaxman' in particular and not a Claxman or a Paxman or a Taxman? I'm very sceptical about the minutiae/interpretation of phone calls and messaging, for example, if I telephone someone at this moment, it might well be possible to trace phone to phone contact but not who I speak to at the other end. Not wishing to over complicate the subject but many people these days use mobile phones in connection with their work, in preference to landlines, so effectively one phone encompasses both work and play. I have a number of contacts on my mobile identified by only forename, mostly because I don't know the surname.

Jane Tanner and her other half only moved to Exeter in January 2007, just four months before Madeleine's alleged disappearance. According to her rogatory interview, I quote .. "Err but now I’m working at the University in Exeter, sort of website, a web marketing role. Just two days a week.”

The trauma of moving home, kids to look after, searching for part-time work, making new friends - that's some going in only four months.

How can anyone but Jane Tanner know, without question, who she exchanged text message/s with on 2nd May 2007?

NB: If you use the electoral register search, there is no entry for a Christine or John Flaxman in Exeter.

by Phoebe 12.08.17 22:04

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]@ Verdi. This was the first message I received. Will post the next also.

by Phoebe 12.08.17 22:10

From April28th To Phoebe, Today at 18:25
Hey, no problem. This is her:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (scroll down)

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Linkedin is the most important as it confirms she worked at FSS!

Please feel free to share these links as I see verdi is being pedantic on the basis of not finding the name on 192 or some such. I don't post anymore myself so please don't worry about crediting me.

@ Verdi. Message received this eve. I believe the poster April28th has already done some extensive research into the whole area of the phone records in the Madeleine case other than this Flaxman contact. I can find no reference to the name Claxman through ANY internet search, even beyond Exeter.

by Phoebe 12.08.17 22:36

Phoebe wrote:From April28th To Phoebe, Today at 18:25
Hey, no problem. This is her:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (scroll down)

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Linkedin is the most important as it confirms she worked at FSS!

Please feel free to share these links as I see verdi is being pedantic on the basis of not finding the name on 192 or some such. I don't post anymore myself so please don't worry about crediting me.

@ Verdi. Message received this eve. I believe the poster April28th has already done some extensive research into the whole area of the phone records in the Madeleine case other than this Flaxman contact. I can find no reference to the name Claxman through ANY internet search, even beyond Exeter.

According to Peter Scharrenberg's book "The Impossible Abduction"

"Dr Russell O'Brien, partner of Jane Tanner. The couple have two children. Dr. O'Brien works at the Penninsula Medical School of the University of Plymouth which is located on the Exeter Campus"

Is it not likely that Dr. Russell O' Brien may have known Dr. Christine Flaxman, both being doctors working out of the Exeter Campus? We have only Jane's word that it was she who "knew" the caller (even though she didn't know her surname) Remember, Jane's excuse was that this person contacted her but the rogatory interview makes clear that SHE initiated this phone contact.

by Verdi 12.08.17 23:46

Phoebe wrote:@ Verdi. This was the first message I received. Will post the next also.

That's all very impressive I'm sure but it doesn't answer my question.

I repeat .. "how it can be said with such certainty that Jane Tanner exchanged text message/s with 'Dr. Christine Flaxman' in particular and not a Claxman or a Paxman or a Taxman?"

I could type my name or anybody else along side a telephone number - it doesn't amount to anything.

by Verdi 12.08.17 23:55

Phoebe wrote:From April28th To Phoebe, Today at 18:25
Hey, no problem. This is her:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (scroll down)

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Linkedin is the most important as it confirms she worked at FSS!

Please feel free to share these links as I see verdi is being pedantic on the basis of not finding the name on 192 or some such. I don't post anymore myself so please don't worry about crediting me.

@ Verdi. Message received this eve. I believe the poster April28th has already done some extensive research into the whole area of the phone records in the Madeleine case other than this Flaxman contact. I can find no reference to the name Claxman through ANY internet search, even beyond Exeter.

I haven't questioned the existence of a Dr Christine Flaxman - that's easily confirmed without reference to the electoral register or Linkedin. I want to know how it can be concluded that Jane Tanner exchanged test message/s with a Dr Christine Flaxman based only on a phone number as opposed to any other tom dick or harry.

ETA: Any past connection with the FSS doesn't signify - unless it's being suggested that Jane Tanner, on the night of 2nd May 2007, preempted the possible need for a UK forensic laboratory later in the year. If so then Dr Goncalo Amaral doesn't exist!

by Verdi 13.08.17 0:04

Phoebe wrote:
According to Peter Scharrenberg's book "The Impossible Abduction"

As regards the mystery of Madeleine McCann, Peter Scharrenberg is about as credible and the McCanns champion duo Anthony Summers and Robbyn Swan - even though he might take a different stance.

Forgive me but I will not continue to discuss the subject by proxy. If you wish to act as go-between that's your prerogative but you can count me out - at least until such times as someone can answer my question, then I'll be only too willing to reconsider my thoughts on the subject.

Thanks anyway for taking the time thumbsup

.

by Phoebe 13.08.17 0:52

Jane Tanner was questioned about the contact with Claxman/Paxman during the rogatory interviews by which stage the debacle of the testing of the blood samples from Portugal had already occurred. I wondered if Jane would have felt it imprudent to admit that she had been in contact with Dr. Flaxman (as the phone analysis of April28th claims) given Dr. Flaxman's connections to the F.S.S. lab and the home office. (see below) I have never suggested that Jane Tanner was preempting any work carried out by the F.S.S. rather that her caution may have been retrospective. It is also a fact that Dr. Russell O'Brien was employed by the Penninsula Medical School on the Exeter Campus. There is ample evidence of same other than Mr Sharrenberg's book. Citation does not necessarily imply endorsement.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Improvements in and relating to identification and analysis
WO 2002103357 A1

Publication number	WO2002103357 A1
Publication type	Application
Application number	PCT/GB2002/002595
Publication date	Dec 27, 2002
Filing date	Jun 18, 2002
Priority date	Jun 19, 2001
Inventors	[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Applicant	[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Export Citation	[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (3), [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (3), [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] (8)

External Links: [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

by Phoebe 13.08.17 3:39

The phone records I posted above re. Tanner/Flaxman were sent to me by Ben Salmon who has kindly permitted me to reveal this fact and, having done Trojan work in researching all phone records in the Madeleine case, seems to be highly respected. This post below from G.E.G.

"Ben's online here now so hopefully he'll post it up for us.

He did a fantastic Gif thingy too that he shared with me via pm last week. Come on Ben post it up."

Therefore I don't doubt his veracity when he says these contacts were indeed between Jane Tanner's phone and one registered to Dr. Christine Flaxman. Who was actually holding the phones and pressing the letters during texting we cannot know but I imagine it would be safe to assume that on one end it was Jane Tanner, her husband or someone with physical access to her phone and on the other either Dr. Flaxman or someone she knew well enough to give her phone to. For me, the very fact that Jane lied and sought to dissemble re. the name of the person her phone was in contact with is a red flag.

by Phoebe 13.08.17 3:54

Phoebe wrote:The phone records I posted above re. Tanner/Flaxman were sent to me by Ben Salmon who has kindly permitted me to reveal this fact and, having done Trojan work in researching all phone records in the Madeleine case, seems to be highly respected. This post below from G.E.G.

"Ben's online here now so hopefully he'll post it up for us.

He did a fantastic Gif thingy too that he shared with me via pm last week. Come on Ben post it up."

Therefore I don't doubt his veracity when he says these contacts were indeed between Jane Tanner's phone and one registered to Dr. Christine Flaxman. Who was actually holding the phones and pressing the letters during texting we cannot know but I imagine it would be safe to assume that on one end it was Jane Tanner, her husband or someone with physical access to her phone and on the other either Dr. Flaxman or someone she knew well enough to give her phone to. For me, the very fact that Jane lied and sought to dissemble re. the name of the person her phone was in contact with is a red flag.

P.S. Jane Tanner's rogatory interview took place on April 8th 2008 by which time she had been in her "new" job at Exeter for almost a year and a half. Surely ample time to have learned the correct surname of Dr. Flaxman!!

by Sinan19 02.09.17 20:21

Wow. All of this is just so... weird. It's a total clusterf***.

by willowthewisp 03.09.17 12:31

Sinan19 wrote:Wow. All of this is just so... weird. It's a total clusterf***.

Hi Sinan19,you could call it a Cluster *uck?
But should you also decide that a person who just so happens to have worked on"Patient Citations"(Flaxman)on DNA,trace evidence,who may have received phone calls,from a Witness to an Abduction from the vicinity of 5a Ocean Club Apartments 3 May 2007?
Jane Tanners Partner Russell O Brien worked at the same Medical Training Centre,there does seem to be a list of people with very close connections to the Exeter Area?
Robert Murat,Jane Tanner,Russell O'Brien,(Christine flaxman LCI,DNA)?