Timeline questiom
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Debate Section - for purporting theories
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
Timeline questiom
You know the bits of scribbled timeline information that had been written on MM's clouring book, what does the forum think their original purpose was?
Were they written with the sole purpose of influencing the PJ or were they for the Tapas 9 eyes only to remind them of the timetable they were supposed to be following? I know the Pj got hold of them, but were they meant to?
Thanks in advance for your replies.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Timeline questiom
It is stressed in the statements that the Payne's and D Webster didn't arrive until 9pm and Matt Oldfield had to go and "hurry them along".
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: Timeline questiom
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Timeline questiom
They look to be, not about checking the children and the times they checked, more of what was found at each check ie windows doors and shutters, that seemed important.
At the the time the lists were written they probably thought the story of the abduction would be believed.
So in my opinion, the lists were probably made to be seen by the police, if they were not, they made no attempt to hide them as far as I know.
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: Timeline questiom
Maybe the first one wasn't working or that someone who doing want to be involved suddenly join in and so the second one was written up.
Nina likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Cake Lover- Posts : 2622
Activity : 2677
Likes received : 55
Join date : 2024-02-13
Nina likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
It was hastily made up and it didn't stand up to scrutiny.
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Nina, Jimtheblue and Bluebagthepirate like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Cake Lover wrote:How would they compile a time line, when they weren't wearing watches? Clarrie told us that, and he knows everything.
The timeline is not real, it was probably made so that they all said the same thing when questioned.
Cammerigal, Silentscope, Jimtheblue and Bluebagthepirate like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Timeline questiom
And of course there are 4 (FOUR) different timelinescrusader wrote:Petermac proved that the timeline was impossible.
It was hastily made up and it didn't stand up to scrutiny
Two slightly different ones on the back [and front ?] of the "Sticker Book"
A 4 page word processed one, handed in some days later with lots of explanatory notes and filing in of details
A fourth one, found in Kate's possession at a much later date
ALL ARE DIFFERENT.
sharonl, crusader and Silentscope like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
We know that their ridiculous timelines aren't true, my point was that they wrote them down at all.sharonl wrote:Cake Lover wrote:How would they compile a time line, when they weren't wearing watches? Clarrie told us that, and he knows everything.
Cake Lover- Posts : 2622
Activity : 2677
Likes received : 55
Join date : 2024-02-13
sharonl, Nina and crusader like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
That reason goes for all the other timelines as well.
It could have been to show the police or so they could all get their story straight, but that didn't work either.
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Nina likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Cake Lover wrote:We know that their ridiculous timelines aren't true, my point was that they wrote them down at all.sharonl wrote:Cake Lover wrote:How would they compile a time line, when they weren't wearing watches? Clarrie told us that, and he knows everything.
Either they were just clumsy and started making notes, forgetting to discard them later or they were done for the PJ to find. I don't think that they would have left 2 timelines with discrepancies laying around deliberately though.
AnneCGuedes likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Cake Lover- Posts : 2622
Activity : 2677
Likes received : 55
Join date : 2024-02-13
sharonl likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
It seems a very strange thing to think about considering a child was missing, why would they need the police to know where they were, it wasn't about them.
Madeleine was missing, and it was about finding her, not covering their arses.
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
sharonl, Nina, silly and Bluebagthepirate like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Cake Lover- Posts : 2622
Activity : 2677
Likes received : 55
Join date : 2024-02-13
crusader, Bluebagthepirate and Paddingtom like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Exactly it is like writing a shopping list, just net needed even though you are hungry.crusader wrote:Why would they need a timeline in the first place, at that point they had nothing to prove.
It seems a very strange thing to think about considering a child was missing, why would they need the police to know where they were, it wasn't about them.
Madeleine was missing, and it was about finding her, not covering their arses.
____________________
Not one more cent from me.
Nina- Posts : 3027
Activity : 3387
Likes received : 348
Join date : 2011-06-16
Age : 81
crusader and Bluebagthepirate like this post
Re: Timeline questiom
crusader wrote:Why would they need a timeline in the first place, at that point they had nothing to prove.
It seems a very strange thing to think about considering a child was missing, why would they need the police to know where they were, it wasn't about them.
Madeleine was missing, and it was about finding her, not covering their arses.
Good point
If Madeleine was genuinely missing they wouldn't need a timeline. The fact that they had two then, speaks volumes.
Bluebagthepirate likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Thankyou for that peter. I knew about the two sticker book ones and Kates one but I didnt know about the word processed one with lots of notes. Do you know where I can find it please?PeterMac wrote:
And of course there are 4 (FOUR) different timelines
Two slightly different ones on the back [and front ?] of the "Sticker Book"
A 4 page word processed one, handed in some days later with lots of explanatory notes and filing in of details
A fourth one, found in Kate's possession at a much later date
ALL ARE DIFFERENT.
Thankyou all for your contributions.
With extra info I have found, I am leaning towards the sticker book ones being entirely for the eyes of the police. They were telling the police what they wanted them to know, not necessarily the acurate picture of timelines. The timelines say alarm at 22.00. We know there is a lot of eveidence to say the alarm was actually raised at 9.30. Im still formulating my train of thought,,,it may come to nothing or it may highlight an problem...I will have to wait and find out.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Timeline questiom
8.35. pm rest. First to arrive
9.00.p.m G- conversation with Steve
9.30..p.m. Matt – Carolyn
10.00p.m. me
8.40.p.m. Jane next
8.45.p.m. Matt and Rachel
Russell?
Held
Evie moody
R is out for a long time
Jane went to replace him
Me: Dont ask me!!!.....I dont know.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
crusader likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 737
Activity : 762
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: Timeline questiom
Honesty- Posts : 117
Activity : 124
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-04-02
AnneCGuedes likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Bluebagthepirate wrote:^^^ where is that from?
It is in Goncalo's second book Maddie Basta de Mentiras!
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Bluebagthepirate likes this post
Re: Timeline questiom
Goncalo says it was drawn up days after the alleged disappearance.Honesty wrote:Shouldn't it be in chronological order? Perhaps it's not because it's a draft as at this stage she had not decided where to try and fit everything in.
we know this is true because it has an alarm time of 10p.m. there ia a lot of evidence, agreed by Goncalo, that the alarm was actually raised at 9.30.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Timeline questiom
Carpenter?
crusader- Posts : 6351
Activity : 6697
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Page 1 of 3 • 1, 2, 3
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Debate Section - for purporting theories