Questions you would like to ask Andy Redwood-a hypothetical exercise-

by worriedmum 04.07.13 22:04

My question is 'What do you think the British trained police dogs, Eddie and Keela, were alerting to?'

by stumo 04.07.13 22:12

What would happen if you don't tow the line and actually do some proper investigating?

by sheila.edwards 04.07.13 22:21

yes why did the police dogs positively signal to cadevine and blood ! are any of the 38 persons of interest from the so called dogy dectives files if using them to.! Is Fund safe for public to continue donate to !

by **PeterMac** 04.07.13 22:55

Can you explain- or even better demonstrate - how you can get into an apartment, sedate three children, pick one up, turn her round, exit and then walk across the top of the street without leaving any forensic trace, in total silence and in the dark, within one minute and twenty seconds,.

Because you are going to have to explain that to the Jury. Beyond a reasonable doubt.

Always remember there will be a defence QC who will be acting for your "Abductor"

by MikeyB 04.07.13 22:57

Maybe there'll never be a trial.

Question: How do you sleep at night? It might be ok to whitewash someone like David Kelly, but a 3 year old girl????

by Guest 04.07.13 22:59

I understand that various independent reports have been sent to you Mr R, like the new e-book and the accountant's review of the less than fragrant fund. Did you or anyone else take the time to read them or did you borrow the McCanns' box marked nutters for them?

SE, I don't think that the fund was ever safe for public donations!

by russiandoll 04.07.13 23:31

Will you question the couple who allegedly went to comfort a distressed Maddie?

by lj 05.07.13 0:06

I suspect Andy's only goal was/is to create reasonable doubt.

He might even think he has done that.

Somebody should explain to him the meaning of reasonable.

by Newintown 05.07.13 0:20

Did you actually investigate whether Kate McCann handled 6 dead bodies in the week before she went on holiday and apparenty wore the same clothes. Did you check her signature was on the death certificates of all 6 people, if not, why not, or did you just take her word for it?

by **tigger** 05.07.13 7:07

When are you due to retire from SY? How many of the detectives working on the case are due for retirement in the next year?

by ufercoffy 05.07.13 8:14

How many cases have you whitewashed?
Is this the first cover-up that has involved a child?

And the third question is contained in my signature below.

by Lostfridge 05.07.13 8:55

How do you sleep at night?

by Guest 05.07.13 9:34

Have you seen the files the Home Secretary is holding?

Why is this case a matter of National Security?

by nomendelta 05.07.13 9:39

Can you confirm or deny categorically whether the McCanns and all or some of the group known as the "Tapas 9" are considered by investigators as, at the very least being aware of what really happened to Maddie McCann? Given the massively suspicious behaviour of those involved regarding ever-changing statements and improbably timelines, if the answer is that they are NOT considered as being aware or involved in hiding the truth of the disappearance of the child what information has lead investigators to this conclusion?

by comperedna 06.07.13 15:42

How does it feel to stand up and say things to camera on British TV which you must know cannot be the case. You look utterly wooden doing it. Does it seem half comical and and half embarassing to you saying it as well as to us listening to it?

by russiandoll 06.07.13 18:24

there used to be a puppet named Andy Pandy.
who's pulling YOUR strings?

by tasprin 06.07.13 18:35

As you are travelling across the UK and Europe to question every man and his dog - though not the Tapas 9 apparently - will you be questioning Martin Grime, the ex-South Yorkshire police dog handler whose dogs detected the scent of death and blood on everything connected to the McCanns?

Do you believe that every one of those alerts - 11 in total - were false positives? If so why do you think the dogs only alerted to places and items connected to the missing girl? 11 coincidences? Surely not. Even Kate McCann would challenge that - in her book she says: "One coincidence, two coincidences – maybe they're still coincidences. Any more than that and it stops being coincidence."

by Vera 06.07.13 18:39

If you were about to get on a plane, and some bomb sniffer dogs alerted for explosives, would you ignore the dogs and get on the flight anyway?

by Praiaaa 06.07.13 18:51

Vera - excellent point!

by tasprin 06.07.13 20:12

The same cadaver dog, Eddie, was employed in the Adran Prout case. When the dog alerted behind a sofa in the Prout home a police officer working on the investigation is on record as saying the alert changed the course of the investigation. If the police trusted a single alert by Eddie in the Prout case why are numerous alerts by the same dog dismissed in the McCann case?

by **PeterMac** 06.07.13 20:16

tasprin wrote:The same cadaver dog, Eddie, was employed in the Adran Prout case. When the dog alerted behind a sofa in the Prout home a police officer working on the investigation is on record as saying the alert changed the course of the investigation. If the police trusted a single alert by Eddie in the Prout case why are numerous alerts by the same dog dismissed in the McCann case?

Prout did not use Carter-Ruck.

by Guest 06.07.13 20:20

PeterMac wrote:
tasprin wrote:The same cadaver dog, Eddie, was employed in the Adran Prout case. When the dog alerted behind a sofa in the Prout home a police officer working on the investigation is on record as saying the alert changed the course of the investigation. If the police trusted a single alert by Eddie in the Prout case why are numerous alerts by the same dog dismissed in the McCann case?

Prout did not use Carter-Ruck.

***
Love you, Peter. You're a cynic to the point ... big grin

by tasprin 06.07.13 20:25

Don't forget Clarence and the spin machine spin

by tasprin 06.07.13 20:44

If Madeleine was abducted it could only have happened if the Tapas 9 lied about their movements that night, because their timelines do not allow enough time for an abductor to carry out the crime. Do you believe that nine adults would give false statements and lie to the police (in order to cover up a lack of checking or something else) if a three year old girl was snatched by a paedophile and her life depended on her parents and friends cooperation?

by **PeterMac** 06.07.13 20:44

A Cynic is what an Idealist calls a Realist.

by Guest 06.07.13 20:54

PeterMac wrote:A Cynic is what an Idealist calls a Realist.

***
And a pessimist is an optimist with experience ... big grin

by **PeterMac** 06.07.13 23:47

Châtelaine wrote:
PeterMac wrote:A Cynic is what an Idealist calls a Realist.
And a pessimist is an optimist with experience ...

Optimists are very often disappointed. Pessimists are very often delighted to be proved right.

by Guest 07.07.13 0:41

Any comments on the Gaspar statements and also why held up by LP for six months before sending to Portugal?

by **PeterMac** 07.07.13 7:56

tasprin wrote:If Madeleine was abducted it could only have happened if the Tapas 9 lied about their movements that night, because their timelines do not allow enough time for an abductor to carry out the crime.
Do you believe that nine adults would give false statements and lie to the police (in order to cover up a lack of checking or something else) if a three year old girl was snatched by a paedophile and her life depended on her parents and friends cooperation?

Neatly put.
Answer - No.

by Woofer 07.07.13 16:01

This thread is similar to one I was thinking of starting along the lines of - OK Andy, let`s give you the benefit of the doubt and believe you when you say Maddie could be alive and the Tapas 9 are not suspects". We believe you Andy, ok, just a few queries though .......