Re: CRIMEWATCH ON BBC ***Part 1 DISCUSSION****

by uppatoffee 14.10.13 21:35

"Why did you think it was ok to eat at the tapas restaurant?" Kate asks herself the question we all want to know the answer to.

by Guest 14.10.13 21:35

Right now, 1374 viewers on line!

Hip hip Hooray!

Kudos to our moderators, and to the guys who invented electricity, wiring, typewriters and laptops!

Well done!

by Newintown 14.10.13 21:35

GM saying that SY have done a great job? What? It's taken them 2 years to follow up what the PJ said. The PJ did a great job until your mates in high government managed to get him kicked off the case.

P.S. Gerry was it you walking towards the beach carrying a child cos a witness said he was 60-80% sure it was you!

by ShuBob 14.10.13 21:36

listener wrote:So much missed out - Must be a good reason!

That's my prayer pray2

by nobodythereeither 14.10.13 21:37

ShuBob wrote:
listener wrote:So much missed out - Must be a good reason!
That's my prayer

So what was the bloody point of it then?

by russiandoll 14.10.13 21:37

Wahrheit wrote:"SY have done a great job": Gerry

I think maybe they have. It aint over til the fat lady sings.

Did Redwood diss the PJ?

There is A LOT imo going on behind the scenes.

by russiandoll 14.10.13 21:38

Don't speak for me please. There is no evidence that the parents killed her.

by ShuBob 14.10.13 21:38

nobodythereeither wrote:
ShuBob wrote:
listener wrote:So much missed out - Must be a good reason!
That's my prayer
So what was the bloody point of it then?

Absolutely no idea! The whole thing seemed surreal $i don\'t know$

by ChuckieD 14.10.13 21:38

uppatoffee wrote:"Why did you think it was ok to eat at the tapas restaurant?" Kate asks herself the question we all want to know the answer to.

I had some vomit in my mouth when she started that. They know that this is the question people are asking so by 'admitting' they were in the wrong 6 years later when the donations are dwindling they may pull at the heart strings once again and top up that sweet, sweet fund.

by OpenMind 14.10.13 21:39

Utterly ridiculous

Only thing I wasn't aware of was the night creche, or have I not done my homework?

by tasprin 14.10.13 21:39

Wahrheit wrote:"SY have done a great job": Gerry

He would say that.

by JackieL 14.10.13 21:39

WHO are the family at the evening creche who say they were carrying back their child? WHY were they taking that route? Team McCann realises Bundleman sighting makes their story implausible, so suddenly Bundleman has NOTHING to do with Madeleine???????

by loopzdaloop 14.10.13 21:39

Somethings fishy.... Is it the seabass?
Please someone call and tell them about the photo of gerry with buttons on his trousers asmper the smith sighting.

Im sure they have never acknowledged thr IVF publicly before.

by ShuBob 14.10.13 21:39

russiandoll wrote:
Wahrheit wrote:"SY have done a great job": Gerry
I think maybe they have. It aint over til the fat lady sings.

Did Redwood diss the PJ?

There is A LOT imo going on behind the scenes.

Thanks russiandoll for still being optimistic as I am. It's not easy being optimistic in the circumstances.

by MoonGoddess 14.10.13 21:40

The only positive thing I took out of that was that for some reason they didn't name/or include the paynes..... the other Tapas crew were all named???

by MRNOODLES 14.10.13 21:40

It's all a stunt to trick them. :fingerscrossed

by tiredofthebs 14.10.13 21:40

russiandoll wrote:
Don't speak for me please. There is no evidence that the parents killed her.

Ah an abduction believer. I'll just pop you on ignore.

by Newintown 14.10.13 21:41

Portia wrote:Right now, 1374 viewers on line!

Hip hip Hooray!

Kudos to our moderators, and to the guys who invented electricity, wiring, typewriters and laptops!

Well done!

1603 now.

2 callers have already called in with a name for the man carrying a child - was it GERRY MCCANN, Deadwood?

by tiny 14.10.13 21:41

tasprin wrote:
Wahrheit wrote:"SY have done a great job": Gerry
He would say that.

Sounds like they have got away with it,deadwood,?correct

by MoonGoddess 14.10.13 21:42

JackieL wrote:WHO are the family at the evening creche who say they were carrying back their child? WHY were they taking that route? Team McCann realises Bundleman sighting makes their story implausible, so suddenly Bundleman has NOTHING to do with Madeleine???????

There is no way he would be travelling away from the back of 5a IF he was coming from the creche

by MaryB 14.10.13 21:42

What exactly is the new evidence. I've watched it but didn't see any new evidence being presented. What is the revelation. I read it was to be a long and detailed reconstruction lasting 25 minutes. That was nonsense for a start. It wasn't what I'd call a a reconstruction. Just the parents being interviewed most of the time.
I think somebody will come forward as the man the Smiths saw and he will be written of like the person Jane Tanner saw.

by Smokeandmirrors 14.10.13 21:42

MoonGoddess wrote:The only positive thing I took out of that was that for some reason they didn't name/or include the paynes..... the other Tapas crew were all named???

Jez Wilkins a.k.a. EFit man wasn't named either as being prominent at the time.

by russiandoll 14.10.13 21:43

tiredofthebs wrote:
russiandoll wrote:
Don't speak for me please. There is no evidence that the parents killed her.
Ah an abduction believer. I'll just pop you on ignore.

read my posts. I do not believe in an abduction. Is the only alternative that her parents killed her then? No chance of a covered= up accident as theorised by Goncalo Amaral?
Glad to be ignored by a mind like that.

btw how dare you use "WE" speaking for this forum when making such a claim. If it is your belief, say so.

by ChuckieD 14.10.13 21:43

russiandoll wrote:
Wahrheit wrote:"SY have done a great job": Gerry
I think maybe they have. It aint over til the fat lady sings.

Did Redwood diss the PJ?

There is A LOT imo going on behind the scenes.

I hope so, this all seems quite bizarre otherwise.

I found it interesting they didn't speak live to K&G until after the reconstruction. Body language analysis, maybe?

I'm glad Redwood is choosing his terms carefully. 'Disappeared' rather than 'taken' etc.

by MRNOODLES 14.10.13 21:44

JackieL wrote:WHO are the family at the evening creche who say they were carrying back their child? WHY were they taking that route? Team McCann realises Bundleman sighting makes their story implausible, so suddenly Bundleman has NOTHING to do with Madeleine???????

Seriously, I don't believe the night creche man. It's too convenient, it smells of BS.

by loopzdaloop 14.10.13 21:44

MoonGoddess wrote:The only positive thing I took out of that was that for some reason they didn't name/or include the paynes..... the other Tapas crew were all named???

Neither david payne or the gaspars were mentioned. Maybe there is an injunction!!

Redwood also said it was only ONE interpretation of the statements.

by Truthandjustice 14.10.13 21:45

They completely avoided discrepancies in the witness statements JT GM JW in the street at the same time, DPayne visit. The shutters business again presented as fact despite being disproved on the first night. The explanation of the Tanner sighting would have had him walking in the opposite direction. They WERE NOT FORMALLY CLEARED!! nearly threw something at the telly then. Also they made the apartment look much closer to the restaurant and they were sitting outside which was incorrect. It is a PR job.

by statsman 14.10.13 21:46

It seems the way to do a reconstruction is simply to ignore anything that gets in the way of what you want to get across..

As Mark Twain said, "Never let the truth get in the way of good story."

by tiredofthebs 14.10.13 21:46

MRNOODLES wrote:
JackieL wrote:WHO are the family at the evening creche who say they were carrying back their child? WHY were they taking that route? Team McCann realises Bundleman sighting makes their story implausible, so suddenly Bundleman has NOTHING to do with Madeleine???????
Seriously, I don't believe the night creche man. It's too convenient, it smells of BS.

Does anything in this case smell of anything else? In fact the only 2 smells other than bullshit in this case are cadaver and blood.