The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Welcome to 'The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann' forum 🌹

Please log in, or register to view all the forums as some of them are 'members only', then settle in and help us get to the truth about what really happened to Madeleine Beth McCann.

When you register please do NOT use your email address for a username because everyone will be able to see it!

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Mm11

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Regist10

Bearing False Witness

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 29.09.18 21:55

I've moved your post ^^^ here from the  'EXCLUSIVE: Gerry McCann to open up about his mental health struggles in 'honest, personal and sometimes painful' Radio 4 interview' thread.

As can be seen up-page, Susan Moyes was interviewed on BBC radio where she had this to say..

SM: Sure. We went out for a meal about 7 o'clock, down in the town, we walked back about 9 o'clock, round past, errm... the... the church, round past the supermarket, back to the apartment, went out on the balcony about quarter past nine - everywhere was peaceful, everywhere was lovely - we then went to bed.

No indication as to who went out on the balcony, why and for how long.  In various press reports there were different versions of who, why and when.  There is no proof of any of this.  My only question is why Susan Moyes agreed to an interview with BBC RADIO - it served no purpose.  It was however only a matter of days before Pamela Fenn gave her only formal witness statement to the police.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 21.12.18 23:35

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 News-graphics-2007-_646273a

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 26.12.18 12:02

Commencing November 2007, building momentum into December 2007 and gradually the impact diminishing through to January 2008 - it was certainly a very eventful period for Team McCann and it would appear a very important period of time for their long-term strategy, their campaign, their wider agenda.

I'd like to have been a fly on the wall of the Rothley Court Hotel meeting as this was clearly the hub of the imminent hivernal discontent.  Without knowing the detail, one thing appears to be true - Brian Kennedy, the double glazing tycoon, was the ring leader.  At least he was the one with the money to finance the team's escapades and I'd imagine, the influence.

The period of time was used constructively, to rally around willing participants (greasy palm variety) to provide false evidence of useful sightings to take the pressure off poor old Jane Tanner and her phantom abductor, so conveniently dismissed by the former DCI Andy Redwood during the Crimewatch 2013 Madeleine McCann Special.  What better than a variety of sightings, similar in appearance and location, to throw the scent off the Morpheus created by Ms Tanner and friends.

Events from the past, a combination of truth and fabrication, were used to advantage - not only to confuse an already umbrageous investigation but also to fool the public, the spectator into believing the unevidenced claim of stranger abduction.  Morpheus had multiple facets thanks to the greasy palmed curious witnesses who sprang forth to assist the floundering investigation - some might say to pervert the course of justice, nonetheless a very productive exercise still doing the rounds to this very day.

The blueprint..

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 9k=
Mythman

Twas indeed the winter of discontent.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 04.01.19 0:08

Door-to-door inquiries appeared to have been delayed and haphazard. If nobody was at home, too bad: as far as I could tell they didn’t get a second visit. Many of the witness statements looked extremely vague and brief, crying out for what seemed blindingly obvious and essential questions to be asked and answered. Those made by the Ocean Club staff in particular were very sketchy, even allowing for the fact that almost 130 employees were interviewed in the space of just a few days. We have discovered since that there were staff who were not interviewed at all.

Night after night, I read of depraved individuals, British paedophiles, Portuguese paedophiles, Spanish, Dutch and German paedophiles, and of the horrific crimes they’d committed. The police went to visit some of them, looked around their apartments and recorded merely, ‘No sign of the minor.’ Was that enough to eliminate these vile characters from the inquiry? If more had been done, there was certainly nothing in the files about it. No description, no photograph, no alibi, no DNA. Just ‘No sign of the minor.’

27 August
A late night. Depressing reading. So many child molesters! Dear God, please don’t let this have been what’s happened to Madeleine. Please, God.

madeleine by KATE MCCANN

[Book extract for research and study purposes only]
....................


No wonder Team McCann was masterminded to produce new witnesses and sightings after the McCanns speedy departure from Portugal in September 2007.  Brian Kennedy the financier - who called on him to sell his soul to the devil, Clarence Mitchell perhaps who purposely and willingly resigned from a lucrative position with the British government to work for Team McCann full-time? 

Dastardly deeds call for desperate measures.

After the initial mayhem, when witnesses were routinely interviewed by PJ officers, suddenly new information springs forth - alternative witness statements and previously unknown or embellished sightings are reported.  Not from official sources, like the Portuguese investigative team but by the alternative unofficial tour de force - Team McCann.

Makes you think doesn't it?

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Apartment No.5, Pennington Way

Post by Verdi on 08.01.19 0:44

Charlotte Pennington stands out from all the other Ocean Club child care workers for a number of reasons.  To start, she was a late arrival, said to have been on the same flight from the UK as some of the McCann friends - she was not initially listed amongst the child care workers for the summer season, instead later after her arrival at the same time as the McCann group.  The reason for this has never been explained.

Following the alleged disappearance of Madeleine McCann, Charlotte Pennington was not backward in coming forward as regards media interviews and television appearances - indeed she featured quite prominently in the 'Dispatches' documentary on 18th October 2007 (that month again)..

Charlotte Pennington is shown in three separate clips talking about the events of 03 May 2007:
 
Transcription 1:
 
'They were a very social group and they seemed all to be really respectful, nice, loving parents. Madeleine, I found out to be quite bright... errm, quite shy... errm, very sweet, very beautiful girl.
 
On May the third, it was just Madeleine I was reading a story to. I later saw them around lunchtime. That's the last time I saw them together as a family.'
 
Transcription 2:
 
'I was working that night at something called 'Drop-in Creche'. We had one child left and... errm, the mother came in, picked up the child and just mentioned 'Hang on a minute, I've just seen a guy who's run past me, who seemed really distressed and I recognised him as being a guest at Mark Warner, but he was shouting out something like 'Maddie' or 'Abbey' or 'Gabby'.'
 
Transcription 3:
 
'I went straight to the apartment. I sort of walked in, did a quick scan around and been told 'No, no. She's not here, she's not here'.
 
Kate McCann was outside and she was very distressed. She was saying things like 'They've taken her' and 'She's gone' and, you know, 'Where is she? Where is she?'
 
She was crying and there were tears down her face and it was absolutely heartbreaking to see.'
....................

Ocean Club nanny Charlotte Pennington claimed to be a key witness in the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

Nigel Moore of the now defunct mccannfiles.com but kindly hosted by pamalam at gerrymccannsblog, published this excellent exposé of Charlotte Pennington..

Where was Charlotte Pennington?

 
Nigel Moore
Monday 30 June 2008
 
The question: 'Where was Charlotte Pennington when Madeleine was reported missing?' would appear to be one of the few questions surrounding the case that can boast a straightforward answer.
 
In a case that has become characterised by the frustratingly unsatisfactory quotes of unnamed friends and sources, Ms Pennington has afforded us the rare luxury of being able to listen to her own words from her own mouth - at least until the Dispatches documentary 'Searching for Madeleine' was removed from YouTube and Channel 4's own 4oD service.
 
On that documentary, Ms Pennington recounted the following story: "I was working that night at something called 'Drop-in Creche'. We had one child left and... errm, the mother came in, picked up the child and just mentioned 'Hang on a minute, I've just seen a guy who's run past me, who seemed really distressed and I recognised him as being a guest at Mark Warner, but he was shouting out something like 'Maddie' or 'Abbey' or 'Gabby'."
 
She then continues: "I went straight to the apartment. I sort of walked in, did a quick scan around and been told 'No, no. She's not here, she's not here'.
 
"Kate McCann was outside and she was very distressed. She was saying things like 'They've taken her' and 'She's gone' and, you know, 'Where is she? Where is she?'
 
"She was crying and there were tears down her face and it was absolutely heartbreaking to see."
 
So, in Ms Pennington's own words, her movements would appear to be crystal clear and unequicocal. End of story.
 
Yet, in Danny Collins recently released book 'Vanished' a completely different picture is painted. We are used to reading slight variations of stories connected to the case, to the point where double-vision is a regular occurence, but we are less used to somebodies movements being directly and confidently contradicted in print.
 
So what does Mr Collins say about Ms Pennington's movements and what is the significance of them, if true?
 
Mr Collins states that rather than being in the communal 'Drop-in creche', Ms Pennington was actually babysitting in a 'nearby apartment' and was brought to the McCanns' apartment by the sound of Kate McCanns' screams from the balcony of apartment 5A.
 
He claims that Ms Pennington was the first person at the scene and that she told police that Kate 'clutched at her' and 'sobbed in panic as she tried to answer the young childminder's questions'.
 
Whilst Ms Pennington does indeed describe the frenzied state of Kate McCann, she does not mention the undoubted importance and significance of being the first person to arrive at the scene.
 
However, if Ms Pennington's own account is true then it would have been impossible for her to have been the first person at the scene as the incident she describes clearly indicates that the alarm had been raised some time before she was made aware of it.
 
She does state in the Daily Mail article of 25 September 2007 that "I was in the apartment less than five minutes after they found that Madeleine had gone".
 
However, that would seem unlikely given the fact that after Kate had reportedly discovered Madeleine missing she would have had to inform the rest of the group by returning to the Tapas bar; allowed time for a further search of the apartment by Gerry and their friends; allowed time to consider what to do; allowed time for Gerry to decide to go out onto the streets and then do it; allowed time for the woman to hear him and later report what she had heard to Pennington and then time for Pennington to ascertain which apartment was involved, gather herself and then actually reach the apartment. It would seem unlikely that that whole process would have taken 'less than five minutes'.
 
In the same article, Ms Pennington further describes how: "We knew that one of the other nanny's charges was called Maddie. We told the head of department what had happened and she took us straight to the apartment.
 
"There were no children in the room. The twins had been taken out already, I think by one of the McCanns' friends."
 
Leaving aside discussion around the distrubing suggestion that the twins were not in the apartment at that time (Where were they and why and how did they return by the time the GNR arrived?), Ms Pennington states that she attended the McCanns apartment with her head of department - yet again clearly suggesting that she wasn't the first person on the scene.
 
So, who to believe? Ms Pennington herself or the words of a Spanish-based veteran investigative journalist? Faced with such a choice the natural inclination would surely be to side with the individual who was actually there and witnessed it. Yet, the level of detail in Collins text suggests his knowledge extends beyond that of a blindfold, a stick and a piñata.
 
Mr Collins also has something very significant to say about the occupation of the apartments by the McCanns and the Tapas Seven.
 
Mr Collins states that the McCanns were in apartment 5A, as we all know, but that Jane Tanner and Russell O'Brien were next door in apartment 5B. This appears to directly contradict Clarence Mitchell's statement that Rachael Oldfield was next door on the evening that Madeleine is alleged to have been left crying, unattended.
 
What Mr Mitchell actually said was: "Equally, one of the friends, Rachael Oldfield, was in the apartment next door in a bedroom adjacent to the wall where Madeleine was in her bedroom and she heard no crying at all all night."
 
The natural assumption from Mr Mitchell's statement is that Rachael Oldfield was 'in the apartment next door' because that was her apartment. After all, what would she be doing in somebody elses bedroom, on her own, whilst all the other members of the holidaying party were out enjoying themselves? All night.
 
Of course, making assumptions is a dangerous thing to do. But it does seem peculiar that Mr Mitchell has specifically identified Rachael Oldfield - why not simply say that the Oldfield's were next door and heard nothing? If she heard nothing all night, then she must have been there all night. If so, where was her husband?
 
If Mrs Oldfield was alone, it would suggest she was alone for a reason. After all, we have been told, first hand by Kate, that they were operating a system. She said: "We all knew what we had to do, what we would do and.. you know, it worked as a system we had going and it just seemed totally right somehow".
 
Could it be that Mrs Oldfield was babysitting? That the 'system' involved one member of the group babysitting all the children? There is, it must be stated, no evidence to suggest this is the case but, at one point, there were curious reports of all the children sharing the McCanns' apartment on the night of 3rd May. But was this true or just another flight of fancy?
 
Mr Collins states that Mark Warner only rented out the ground floor apartments and that the holidaying group were all based on that floor, contradicting previous reports that the Payne's were located on the floor above. Collins says that the Payne's were 'further down the walkway' and that the Oldfield's were based the furthest away from the McCanns' apartment.
 
So what significance does this have to the whereabouts of Charlotte Pennington on that evening? Possibly, a great deal.
 
Mr Collins tells us that Ms Pennington was babysitting in a 'nearby apartment' when she heard the screams of Kate McCann. He tells us that Mark Warner only rented the ground floor apartments and so, therefore, we are compelled to ask: Was Ms Pennington babysitting for one of the Tapas group and, if so, which one?
 
If we are to believe reports, the Payne's were the only couple to own and use a working baby-monitoring device, so would therefore have had no need of a babysitter. The Oldfield's were the furthest away from the McCanns apartment and it would therefore seem very unlikely that Ms Pennington could have heard the screams of Kate, if she was babysitting inside the Oldfield's apartment.
 
So, that just leaves the apartment of Tanner and O'Brien, next door to the McCanns, where Kate's screams would have been easily heard.
 
Yet, if Collins is correct in the statements he has committed to print, then two questions immediately spring to mind: Why was Pennington employed as a babysitter, when the group had a communal checking 'system' that supposedly 'worked'? And if Pennington was babysitting the children of Tanner and O'Brien, then why was Russell O'Brien reportedly absent from the group until just before 10:00pm?
 
Of course, the possibility that there was another family occupying an apartment in the middle of the Tapas groups apartments must be considered. However, it is very curious that if there were such an apartment, and such a family, then why have they never been identified, mentioned or even remotely hinted at?
 
The fog that surrounds the mystery continues to show no signs of lifting.
...................

There can be no doubt that Charlotte Pennington is a fantasist but is that good enough reason to bear false witness - to pervert the course of justice, to capitalize in the name of a missing three year old child? 

I don't think so!

Charlotte Pennington is a chronicle in it's own right - a story line from a soap opera that only she can lay claim to in this miserable affair.  I hope she sleeps well at night.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 12.01.19 15:12

Carole Tranmer witness statement - 22nd April 2008   [excerpt]

DC1485'Okay. And did you see anyone else; you know what day it was; the day you were there, on Thursday. Do you know if there were more tourists in that block of apartments'

CT' No, that is to say, there were more people in the pool zone. There were more people around. I believe that it may be possible some were swimming, or even playing tennis. I cannot remember.

DC1485'Was there anyone who called your attention' Think, think well about the location and where you were on this day.

CT' On that day'

DC1485'Besides the individual, obviously.

CT' Besides him...

DC1485'Yes.

CT' No one comes to mind. The one thing that I do remember is that some celebration was going on, but I don't know if it was the Sunday or the Thursday. There was some celebration, next to the pool. I do not know if it was the families, the guests of the complex, but there was something. The only thing I can say is that it could have been Sunday or Thursday. I cannot remember and for this reason I would like to leave out this detail.

DC1485'When you speak of a celebration' was it was a barbeque or a bunch of people in good moods'

CT' Well, it appeared to be a celebration, you know, with all the people in good moods and a lot of noise' not much noise but people were laughing and I do not know if this was on Sunday or Thursday.

DC1485'Yes.

CT' This detail I will not mention since I am not certain if it was Sunday or Thursday. Yes, and I don't want to confuse my recollection with this.

....................

thinking


April 2008 - that month again!

I don't recall anyone else mentioning a commotion that seemed to be a celebration.  I wonder shy Carole Tranmer, Pamela Fenn's niece, elected to mention it.  If it was indeed on Thursday, it doesn't seem to tie-in with the alleged last photograph scenario and unsuing afternoons activities.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 20.01.19 13:09

There could be any number of reasons why Gerry and Kate McCann would telephone family and friends back in the UK.  From my experience of this new age, folk can't function without that lump of plastic stuck to the ear - it's almost like an artificial life saving organ.  Even when out and about when there's so much to see, I hear passers by telling whoever's at the other end where they are at that particular moment roll .

The phone calls made immediately following Madeleine's alleged disappearance are of interest as they bear witness to the McCanns planned long term campaign strategy, the wider agenda.

Despite my customary negative view of the UK press, I believe there is some truth in the reportage of the blitz of phone calls made late Thursday 3rd and early Friday 4th May to family and friends.  If for no other reason but their consistency.  By way of example..

It was my younger brother Gerry distraught on the phone, breaking his heart... 'Madeleine is abducted, she's been abducted'. 'They kept going back to check the kids every half hour. The restaurant was only 40 yards away. He went back at 9 o’clock to check the children. They were all sound asleep, windows shut, shutters shut'.

Kate then went over to the two-bedroom ground-floor apartment and 'came out screaming'.  'The door was lying open, the window in the bedroom and the shutters had been jimmied open'. They think someone must have come in the window and gone out of the front door with Madeleine.

Trish Cameron

On the night of Thursday, May 3, 2007, Patricia received a telephone call from Gerry informing us of the disappearance of Madeleine. Gerry manifested all those emotions one expects from a father who has lost a child in the circumstances. He was distraught and spoke at the same time he cried. He seemed frustrated with the slowness of the searches in Portugal, with the fact that the borders had not been closed, and with the fact that sniffer dogs were not being used. Patricia and I contacted the British Embassy to try and help in this regard.

Sandy Cameron

I've got crying for help from my brother and I'm stuck couple of thousand miles away from him. I can't do anything concrete. And then eventually he just said, I don't know what to think. I think some paedophile or some other swine has taken Madeleine.

John McCann

So there we have it, within minutes/hours the abduction peadophile seed was sown, the McCanns at the same time telling their tale to the nearest and dearest to build a firewall to protect themselves from familial doubt - worse still, accusations.  I truly believe the family members quoted are innocent victims of the wider agenda - caught in the net never to break free, it fairness it put them in an untenable position but who cares, just as long as the drama is played out.

To this very day, or at least the last time she spoke in public, Kate McCann continues to mechanically speak of open windows and shutters with swooshing curtains.

Someone is telling porkies.  So early in the day, the nearest and dearest must have been only repeating what they were told.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by PeterMac on 20.01.19 14:36

Verdi:     Someone is telling porkies.  So early in the day, the nearest and dearest must have been only repeating what they were told.

It is fascinating that the Pros can only repeat their mantra that "The McCanns did not say this".
That is all they have.   It clearly Was said, and repeated almost verbatim.
But we will never know the exact words they BOTH used that night. 
We can only surmise, but rely on the quite extraordinary corroboration from the witnesses to draw our conclusions

____________________

PeterMac
PeterMac
Investigator

Posts : 10504
Join date : 2010-12-06

http://whatreallyhappenedtomadeleinemccann.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by sharonl on 20.01.19 20:50

Phillip Edmonds - Nephew (and co-director of Stemcor) of Margaret Hodge who just happened to be working alongside Lord Levy in his fund raising activities for Tony Blair when both Levy and Blair were being questioned in relation to the cash for honours scandal in 2006. 
Blair not only rapidly dispatched his own media manipulator to PDL to assist the suspects in this case, he was also involved in the PACT (now Action against Abduction) charity alongside Cherie Blair.

Edmonds claimed that he saw Madeleine playing his children and that he had taken photographs of them.  When requested, he was unable to produce the photographs, claiming that they had been sent to the PJ.  These pics appear no-where in the official files.  If this was genuine, Edmonds could have assisted the McCanns by producing those pics.  

We can assume that there were digital copies of these photographs but even if they were taken on a manual camera there would be negatives.

____________________
"WE ARE ALL IN THIS TOGETHER" - Rebekah Brooks to David Cameron
sharonl
sharonl


Posts : 6175
Join date : 2009-12-29

http://www.cold2012.org.uk

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 18.05.19 13:48

TRANSLATED BY INES
5 - 1 Apensos V, Vol  1 Page 3
Bearing False Witness - Page 2 George_robert_william_brooks_small
apenso5_vol_1_Page3
Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Apenso5_vol_1_Page3_small
Leicestershire Constabulary Continuation Witness Statement

Continuation Statement - 4th May

Continuation Statement: Information from the Family

There is a male who owns a pizza hut in the resort called George originally from Liverpool. He states that on Friday morning at 5.55 AM on Friday 4th May 2007 he saw a couple acting suspiciously carrying a child near to the marina.

He can be contacted on the following number: ***

The pizza hut is near to a place called Amy Dukes.

The police have not yet spoken to this male.


(In different handwriting)




Info from family to McCann.

Portuguese resident/business owner

Reporting couple with child

5.55 AM 4/5 near to the marina.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 18.05.19 13:54

Charlotte Pennington speaks on the Dispatches documentary -18th October 2007
     
Charlotte Pennington is shown in three separate clips talking about the events of 03 May 2007:
 
Transcription 1:
 
‘They were a very social group and they seemed all to be really respectful, nice, loving parents. Madeleine, I found out to be quite bright… errm, quite shy… errm, very sweet, very beautiful girl.
 
On May the third, it was just Madeleine I was reading a story to. I later saw them around lunchtime. That’s the last time I saw them together as a family.’
 
Transcription 2:
 
‘I was working that night at something called ‘Drop-in Creche’. We had one child left and… errm, the mother came in, picked up the child and just mentioned ‘Hang on a minute, I’ve just seen a guy who’s run past me, who seemed really distressed and I recognised him as being a guest at Mark Warner, but he was shouting out something like ‘Maddie’ or ‘Abbey’ or ‘Gabby’.’
 
Transcription 3:
 
‘I went straight to the apartment. I sort of walked in, did a quick scan around and been told ‘No, no. She’s not here, she’s not here’.
 
Kate McCann was outside and she was very distressed. She was saying things like ‘They’ve taken her’ and ‘She’s gone’ and, you know, ‘Where is she? Where is she?’
 
She was crying and there were tears down her face and it was absolutely heartbreaking to see.’

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 16.06.19 21:58

'Recruit paedophile hunters' says ex-CEOP boss Jim Gamble

21 September 2017

Police forces should vet and recruit paedophile hunters, the former head of the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre (CEOP) has said.

Jim Gamble called for the creation of a "citizens' army" which would work with police to identify and gather evidence.

He told BBC Radio Ulster the volunteers must be carefully vetted and trained.

But he added police could not ignore the fact that last year, vigilante evidence was used in 44% of court cases where a suspect groomed a child.
'Digital detectives'

The figure was obtained by the BBC earlier this week, and relates to prosecutions in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

The National Police Chiefs' Council warned vigilantes could "compromise" police investigations but admitted UK forces may have to work with paedophile hunters.

Mr Gamble, who is a former senior police officer from Northern Ireland, led CEOP from its formation in 2006 until his resignation in 2010.

He told the BBC's Talkback programme: "What I have been trying to encourage is that, police actually create the role of special constable in the online space and create digital detectives, so [paedophile hunters] could apply to the police."

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 _97963918_gamble
Jim Gamble called for the creation of a "citizens' army" to support police in tackling online abuse

He said the unpaid volunteers would not have the full powers of police officers, but said their skills should be harnessed to help officers protect children from abuse.

"What I'm saying is - capture the frustration that people feel; recruit public-spirited individuals, make sure they've got the right character.

"Then train them, equip them to carry out this job as digital detectives and we could create an army of over 1,000, if every force just recruited 25 volunteers."
'Risks'

Mr Gamble added that he recognised that "if you just let any Tom, Dick or Harry become involved, that you many have the wrong sort of people".

He said proper police vetting would "get rid of the risks".

Paedophile hunters frequently expose child abusers by posing as children online and arranging or agreeing to face-to-face meetings.

The abuser, who has been tricked into thinking they are meeting a child, is then confronted by the vigilantes and sometimes placed under citizen's arrest until police arrive.

Police have previously expressed concern that such confrontations can lead to violence and can interfere with criminal investigations.

Last month, a man from Northern Ireland took his own life after he was confronted at his home by a vigilante group calling itself Silent Justice.

The confrontation was streamed live on the internet, in a move that was strongly criticised by the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI).

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 _97330780_silentjusticevideo
A group calling itself Silent Justice has posted online videos of its confrontations

Mr Gamble acknowledged that some self-appointed paedophile hunters are "just not suited" to track down abusers, and said police vetting was essential.

"There is a model of policing across England and Wales called special constables and no matter where you are - whether it's in Birmingham or Brighton - at night time some of the police officers you will see in uniform are special constables.

"They have applied for that job, and here's the key - they've been vetted, so you know they've got the right character."

He added: "These are volunteers, these are publicly-minded, good citizens who want to make a difference."

The programme also spoke to a man called Scott, who is part of a two-man team behind the English vigilante group, Dark Justice.
'120 arrests'

Scott described how he often spends up to 17 hours a day online, posing as a child and talking to potential paedophiles.

He previously ran a media business, but now no longer works for a living and is financially supported by his family while carrying out his full-time vocation.

"We have mounted up some debt... it's not a free thing to do," Scott said, but added he felt obliged to continue because of the government's failure to protect children.

"To date, we have successfully helped with the arrest of 120 people," he claimed.

"So far, 54 of them have been convicted, the rest are on bail, pending court dates, and so on."

Scott said Dark Justice kept records of their online conversations with suspects, and then handed them to police to support prosecutions.

He added that his group did not live-stream its confrontations and did not expose paedophiles online until they had been convicted.
'Police arrogance'

"We can't rely on everyone being a Scott and being calm and considered when engaging with other people," Mr Gamble told the programme.

"We need to bring it within a regulated framework, capitalise on the opportunity for people volunteering and doing it for free, give them the right training, but make sure they are vetted and make sure the information goes as early as possible to the police."

Mr Gamble quit CEOP in 2010 after a row with the then Home Secretary - the current Prime Minister Theresa May - over the assimilation of CEOP into the National Crime Agency.

He said he viewed it as a "dilution" of government resources aimed at protecting children from sex abusers, and still believes children are being failed.

"The lack of investment by government is putting the lives of children at risk - that's a fact," he told Talkback.

"If this was terrorism, they'd be throwing resources at it."

The former officer claimed there was "an arrogance within policing, especially at the most senior level" that tackling paedophilia was only "a job for police".
'Tsunami'

He said recruiting paedophile hunters should be seen as just "another form of community engagement".

Mr Gamble added that he believed only a tiny fraction of online child abuse was being detected as there were not enough police officers working undercover on the internet.

"There's a tsunami, and we are trying to fix it by standing there with our bucket on the beach and that is not working."

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-41350389


Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Gatekeepers


____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 16.06.19 22:00

From : Mark Pettigrew Paris Consular - UBS
Sent : 20th June 2007 16.41
To : Glyn Cartmell * RABAT -UBS
Cc : Gail Sidnell ; Jeffrey Thomas * Paris Consular - UBS ; Lee Theisinger ; Sharon Boyle
Subject : FW : Madeleine McCann

We received an E-mail on our Consular E-mail regarding Madeleine McCann.
The sender, Gabrielle Texier, claims friends of hers know where Madeleine is.


Page 1067 (Page 2 of 2)

Mark called her. She did not sound incoherent, but was upset. When she answered, the first thing she said was that our response had been very quick, as she had only just received an E-mail from Morocco confirming that her friends knew where Madeleine was. Mark asked her which friends and why she was in Morocco. She explained she works for an American Fruit-Juice Company and spends several months a year there.

She claims her friends saw Madeleine on the 19th of May, with a man who was holding her hand very tightly. Mark asked if they had been in contact with the Police or the British Embassy there. She said she had tried to send an E-mail to the McCann's, but to no avail. Her friends had then lost trace of Madeleine, but apparently have located her in a mansion in the Massira area. They called her late last night to inform her of this.

Mark asked who her friends are exactly. She said they work in an Estate Agents in the Menara area of Marrakesh (00212620xxxxx but did not seem to be working). Mark asked if she could forward the E-mail. She was having some problems with her computer therefore Mark offered to call her back.

Ten minutes later, he called her back. Mrs Texier gave us another contact number : Aziz : 00212624xxxxx. She said Aziz had been watching the house for the last few days and is convinced he has seen Madeleine there, but is scared to go to the POlice as the Director of the Estate Agency (who lives in Casablanca) had already tried to alert the Authorities, in vain. He is expecting a call from the Embassy.

Danielle DUCOS

mccannpjfiles.co.uk

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 16.06.19 22:10

From : david.glasgow@psni.pnn.police.uk
Sent : 20th September 2007 17.04
To : dic.portimao@pj.pt
Cc : task@leicestershire.pnn.police.uk
Subject : FW : 1.UNCLASSIFIED-All Networks : OP TASK - Potential sightings of Madeleine McCann

The attached letter was handed to Coleraine Police on this date, reporting a potential sighting of Madeleine Mccann on the P&O Troon to Larne Ferry, 1005hrs on 7th May 2007.

Witness is Mrs Rita HUGHES, dob 16th January 1945, housewife of xx, POxxxxxx ROxx, Portstewart, Co. Londonderry, Northern Ireland. Tel 028708xxxxx.

Mrs HUGHES previously reported her potential sighting to CEOP Website but failed to receive any acknowledgement of her communication, therefore is now reporting the same sighting via her local Police. Mrs HUGHES appears of sound mind and has no criminal record.

I have confirmed that CCTV cameras operate on the Ferry, however is no longer available on the date in question as cameras record to harddrive which is overwritten on a continuous cycle of approximately 6 weeks.

David Glasgow
Sgt 14636 Coleraine PSNI
Tel : 08456008000 Ext 830098


Page 353 (Page 2 of 3)

Thank you for your co-operation.
Leicestershire Constabulary



Page 354 (Page 3 of 3)

Statement of Mrs Rita HUGHES.
Address : xx, POxxxxxx ROxx, Portstewart, N. Ireland. BTxx 7xx, Tel 0287083xxxxx.
Date : 17th September 2007

To : Leicester Police Authority

Sometime ago I sent a letter to the CEOP Website regarding the sighting of a child who resembled Madeleine Mccann, on the Troon/Larne Ferry on 7th May 2007 - the Ferry left Troon at approximately 10.05 a.m. on what was quite a busy Bank Holiday weekend.

I do not know whether or not they received my submission so I am now re-sending it.

I watched a child for several minutes at a distance of about 25 feet who facially resembled Madeleine McCann in some of her photos - the ones which show her with an angular shaped jaw-line. This child had dark eyelashes, a pale skin and the little puffs under her eyes which Madeleine has in some of her photos. Her hair was of similar length and style to that of Madeleine's - I earlier said it was shorter but at that stage I was thinking of the one taken in the football shirt and not the one of her taken on the day of her disappearance. It was not as shiny - but it wouldn't be if she hadn't had it washed in a few days - as in her photos and appeared to be dirty fair colour with a fringe falling to the right and the rest behind her ears falling to about shoulder length. She was wearing blue bib-fronted trousers and a little blue denim jacket.

I was aware of the news about a child being missing in Portugal but as I had been at a wedding over the weekend had little time to absorb the details of when exactly she disappeared and therefore was sort of in shock at seeing this child and somewhat incredulous that it could be her so I watched her thinking, "It couldn't possibly be her. She couldn't possibly be here in this space of time and why would she be in Troon of all places ?"
I also wondered if she was a bit small for Madeleine as it is difficult to tell her height from her photos but I'm still not sure whether she was or not.

I was seated on the deck where the "Poet's Bar" and the shop are, in the first booth in the seating area, separated by a partition from the stairs leading up from the shop. When I saw the child she was on her own on a little corridor that runs across from the "Ladies" and is backed by a wall and moving along it away from the top of the stairs laughing impishly back at someone in the stairs area. Then she stopped, seeing that the corridor went no further as it sort of doubled back on itself, and stood hesitantly for a moment looking back towards the stairs.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Empty Re: Bearing False Witness

Post by Verdi on 16.06.19 22:21

How many Madeleine McCann sightings?

Bearing False Witness - Page 2 Graphic-maddie-map-plain

No doubt many of the alleged sightings across the globe emanated from good hearted people trying to help .... others who were just looking for their five minutes of fame .... and others?

It seems rather a coincidence that so many more detailed sightings were revealed in September 2007 - the same month that the McCanns returned to Blighty, having vowed and declared they would remain in Portugal until their 'abducted' daughter was found.  The same month (or thereabouts) that saw the naming of the McCanns wealthy benefactor, Brian Kennedy and the resignation of Clarence Mitchell from the government position of Media Monitoring director.

The precise date that the first private detective organisation, Metodo3, was hired is unknown but it is clear that they were very active on Portuguese soil (illegal) and across Europe, through to North Africa, with fistfulls of dollars to lure the greedy and gullible.

Clearly they were unaware of the possibility of public exposure some months/years later.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 13386
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum