BRICK Reviews
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse
Page 19 of 21 • 1 ... 11 ... 18, 19, 20, 21
Re: BRICK Reviews
Also, if you have read his book, you can also raise specific points in it that you may disagree with. He will no doubt also answer these.
If you have not read his book (like me) it is not really fair to comment on why you think his theories may be wrong.
deepeepee- Posts : 125
Activity : 127
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-05-13
Jill Havern, CaKeLoveR, GreenTara, Jojo1, pinkgladioli and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Exactly.deepeepee wrote:If you have not read his book (like me) it is not really fair to comment on why you think his theories may be wrong.
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
MAGA MBGA
sandancer, Silentscope, GreenTara, Jojo1, pinkgladioli and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
But most of all I am hoping that Bernt’s Book has the desired effect, and the House of Cards will eventually fall.
Viel Glück / Best of Luck!
Silentscope- Investigator
- Posts : 3266
Activity : 3382
Likes received : 122
Join date : 2020-06-30
Jill Havern, CaKeLoveR, Jojo1, pinkgladioli and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Verity wrote:Is it possible Maddie had her fall on the Sunday but didn't die until the Tuesday?
Sorry to see Tony has such a closed mind. Even Peter is more open minded after having read Bernt's book, which clearly Tony hasn't.
I have wondered if Madeleine lived for a day or two, which makes the whole thing more horrible, doesn't it? It makes me think that she was given a lot of medication to keep her quiet.
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
Jojo1 likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR wrote:Verity wrote:Is it possible Maddie had her fall on the Sunday but didn't die until the Tuesday?
Sorry to see Tony has such a closed mind. Even Peter is more open minded after having read Bernt's book, which clearly Tony hasn't.
I have wondered if Madeleine lived for a day or two, which makes the whole thing more horrible, doesn't it? It makes me think that she was given a lot of medication to keep her quiet.
Yes, there is a possibility that she had an accident on Sunday and died later. We already discussed that.
Justice for Maddie- Posts : 372
Activity : 372
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-07-12
Jojo1 likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Surely, most people who are interested in this case will be aware of Bernt's theories. He explained them at length in his interview with JE and his theories have been analysed by the DD and PB.deepeepee wrote:Tony, I am sure Bernt will be happy to let you know what he thinks of the evidence for the earlier death and why if you present it here. That would be more useful to me and everyone else to be able to understand both your views and his views.
Also, if you have read his book, you can also raise specific points in it that you may disagree with. He will no doubt also answer these.
If you have not read his book (like me) it is not really fair to comment on why you think his theories may be wrong.
Honesty- Posts : 235
Activity : 245
Likes received : 6
Join date : 2024-04-02
crusader, CaKeLoveR and Jojo1 like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
None of whom actually read his book.Honesty wrote:Surely, most people who are interested in this case will be aware of Bernt's theories. He explained them at length in his interview with JE and his theories have been analysed by the DD and PB.deepeepee wrote:Tony, I am sure Bernt will be happy to let you know what he thinks of the evidence for the earlier death and why if you present it here. That would be more useful to me and everyone else to be able to understand both your views and his views.
Also, if you have read his book, you can also raise specific points in it that you may disagree with. He will no doubt also answer these.
If you have not read his book (like me) it is not really fair to comment on why you think his theories may be wrong.
It is 600+ pages long. From his interviews, I personally have a vague idea of some of what he thinks but not really any details or his reasoning.
deepeepee- Posts : 125
Activity : 127
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-05-13
GreenTara likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
Re: BRICK Reviews
She dismissed it as nonsense simply because it didn't match her own theory of Gerry carrying Maddie's corpse to the beach and hiding her under a boat.
And if her analysis is based on one podcast, then her analysis of Bernt's entire seven-year investigation cannot be complete.
PeterMac believes Madeleine died on the Sunday, but at least he's willing to expand on this own theory if confronted with new evidence, whereas others are not.
We need to see what this new evidence is in JE's upcoming podcast. We need to see what happens after that. Peter told us that Bernt will be showing his new video evidence to the PJ.
For goodness sake, let all this play out...there is still more to come yet.
And above all, keep it civil.
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
MAGA MBGA
Nina, CaKeLoveR, GreenTara, Jojo1, pinkgladioli, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
There’s a whole chapter dedicated to the Nanny. PB reduced it to “The McCanns told the Nanny to lie, so she lied”. He never said that. What you say here, is on par with it being reasonable to critique a piece of literature if you’ve seen the movie. Personally I think if you want to critique a book, you should have read it first. PB was like a bull in a china shop with her so called review, but she can’t see how clear that is to see.Honesty wrote:Surely, most people who are interested in this case will be aware of Bernt's theories. He explained them at length in his interview with JE and his theories have been analysed by the DD and PB.deepeepee wrote:Tony, I am sure Bernt will be happy to let you know what he thinks of the evidence for the earlier death and why if you present it here. That would be more useful to me and everyone else to be able to understand both your views and his views.
Also, if you have read his book, you can also raise specific points in it that you may disagree with. He will no doubt also answer these.
If you have not read his book (like me) it is not really fair to comment on why you think his theories may be wrong.
Note - the quotes are saying that’s as good as what she said
Note also when I say “you”, I mean “one”
GreenTara- Posts : 118
Activity : 125
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-05
Jojo1 and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
deepeepee wrote:Yep, they should not be here in the Brueckner topic. It has gone well off track.
?
Clishmaclaver- Posts : 228
Activity : 228
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-08-17
Age : 72
Location : Scotland
Jojo1 likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
You can't "analyse" a theory without knowing the arguments behind the theory. DD and PB don't know the arguments behind my theories. You have to read the book to do so.
What people are missing about en earlier accident and a later death, is that there is no purpose for faking creche records, when they simply could tell the staff that Maddie is sick.
It amazes me how poor common sense is behind that idea.
It's backwards thinking. Oh, so the creche records were faked, so something must have happened earlier, without any evidence that they were actually faked. It is clearly established the sloppiness of those records, so we can't take anything from them. But the logical fallacy of having to fake them, rather than simply telling them that Maddie is sick, is evident.
If Maddie was sick, then it wasn't known that she'd die later, which exposes the logical fallacy by that idea that the creche records were faked for days, with no purpose whatsoever.
I give up.
Enjoy the hamster wheel another decade
Ciao
Guest- Guest
Re: BRICK Reviews
I've already moved the posts to which deepeepee referred...to this threadClishmaclaver wrote:deepeepee wrote:Yep, they should not be here in the Brueckner topic. It has gone well off track.
?
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
MAGA MBGA
CaKeLoveR, Jojo1 and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
Jojo1 and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Not bragging, but I think I did a mean bit of successful profiling right there
GreenTara- Posts : 118
Activity : 125
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-05
Nina, Jojo1, pinkgladioli, MikaelaB, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
Re: BRICK Reviews
I hope Bernt doesn’t mean that,CaKeLoveR wrote:Bernt, what do you mean by 'I give up' ? You're not leaving the forum, are you?
pinkgladioli- Posts : 563
Activity : 566
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Jojo1 likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
He did ask me this morning to delete his account but I'm hoping I've managed to persuade him to stay until, at least, after the next podcast.pinkgladioli wrote:I hope Bernt doesn’t mean that,CaKeLoveR wrote:Bernt, what do you mean by 'I give up' ? You're not leaving the forum, are you?
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
MAGA MBGA
AnneCGuedes, Jojo1, MikaelaB, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
Nina, Jojo1, MikaelaB, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
crusader- Forum support
- Posts : 7252
Activity : 7607
Likes received : 349
Join date : 2019-03-12
AnneCGuedes likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Please try and 'chill', Bernt. It seems you believe passionately in your theories. Others may have different opinions, of course, but surely, at the end of the day, we are all on the same team, as I think the DD put it.BerntS wrote:Honesty.
You can't "analyse" a theory without knowing the arguments behind the theory. DD and PB don't know the arguments behind my theories. You have to read the book to do so.
What people are missing about en earlier accident and a later death, is that there is no purpose for faking creche records, when they simply could tell the staff that Maddie is sick.
It amazes me how poor common sense is behind that idea.
It's backwards thinking. Oh, so the creche records were faked, so something must have happened earlier, without any evidence that they were actually faked. It is clearly established the sloppiness of those records, so we can't take anything from them. But the logical fallacy of having to fake them, rather than simply telling them that Maddie is sick, is evident.
If Maddie was sick, then it wasn't known that she'd die later, which exposes the logical fallacy by that idea that the creche records were faked for days, with no purpose whatsoever.
I give up.
Enjoy the hamster wheel another decade
Honesty- Posts : 235
Activity : 245
Likes received : 6
Join date : 2024-04-02
crusader, CaKeLoveR, AnneCGuedes and Jojo1 like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
The McCann case was also stale and going nowhere after 17 years, then along came Bernt fresh from his seven-year investigation with new info in a Brick of a book for us all to debate.
Yet, without even reading his book, he's come under attack so, of course, he's going to get fed up and defend himself. Or leave.
I personally invited Bernt to this forum - something I don't think he even wanted to do after his experience on farcebewk groups.
We need to see where his investigation will lead...it's not over yet.
I don't want Bernt to leave.
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
MAGA MBGA
Nina, sandancer, Cammerigal, crusader, CaKeLoveR, Bluebagthepirate, AnneCGuedes and like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Bluebagthepirate- Forum support
- Posts : 1206
Activity : 1234
Likes received : 28
Join date : 2024-01-30
Jill Havern, Nina, crusader, Jojo1, pinkgladioli, MikaelaB, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
CaKeLoveR- Forum support
- Posts : 5556
Activity : 5624
Likes received : 76
Join date : 2022-02-19
crusader, Jojo1, MikaelaB and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
For anyone who has read the Brick, they know there is a hell of a lot more to it that gets discussed on the forum,GreenTara wrote:Remember the period of time when everyone was waiting for PB’s review to emerge? I myself, could not imagine someone like her reading this book, I kept thinking “how is she going to do a review without reading the book?”. Yes I was that sure she wouldn’t read it. Then came the review and it was beyond clear she hasn’t read it. She didn’t even grasp what was meant by The Sudden Impulse.
Not bragging, but I think I did a mean bit of successful profiling right there
Pat Brown chose to cherry pick and missed things that could potentially end up being highly signicant IMO, I was surprised that she failed to mention in her critique so it was obvious to me she hadn’t read it
She was sent a copy of the book in good faith by Bernt, which I’d say was extremely generous of him I’d imagine the postal cost alone would have been expensive, You know I’d go as far and say Bernt could potentially be on the right tracks he may or may not have everything 100% time will tell
As Jill reminded us in a previous post this could be Madeleine’s last chance,
After all she is the purpose we are all here
pinkgladioli- Posts : 563
Activity : 566
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Nina, crusader, CaKeLoveR, Bluebagthepirate, GreenTara, Jojo1, MikaelaB and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Neither do I, Jill. I'm very sorry that Bernt took such exception to my post. I wouldn't have posted it if I had known that.Jill Havern wrote:Let's not forget that I was going to close this forum at the beginning of the year because, for one reason, I was tired of all the drama spoiling so many threads.
The McCann case was also stale and going nowhere after 17 years, then along came Bernt fresh from his seven-year investigation with new info in a Brick of a book for us all to debate.
Yet, without even reading his book, he's come under attack so, of course, he's going to get fed up and defend himself. Or leave.
I personally invited Bernt to this forum - something I don't think he even wanted to do after his experience on farcebewk groups.
We need to see where his investigation will lead...it's not over yet.
I don't want Bernt to leave.
If it helps, I won't make any further comments on Bernt's book or his theories.
Honesty- Posts : 235
Activity : 245
Likes received : 6
Join date : 2024-04-02
crusader, CaKeLoveR, AnneCGuedes, Jojo1 and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Fingers and toes crossedJill Havern wrote:He did ask me this morning to delete his account but I'm hoping I've managed to persuade him to stay until, at least, after the next podcast.pinkgladioli wrote:I hope Bernt doesn’t mean that,CaKeLoveR wrote:Bernt, what do you mean by 'I give up' ? You're not leaving the forum, are you?
pinkgladioli- Posts : 563
Activity : 566
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Jill Havern, Nina, crusader, Jojo1, MikaelaB, Clishmaclaver and moxie.blacksmith like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Me too!!pinkgladioli wrote:I hope Bernt doesn’t mean that,CaKeLoveR wrote:Bernt, what do you mean by 'I give up' ? You're not leaving the forum, are you?
For many, this is a great way to be able to contact/interact with Bernt. I appreciate his input a lot.
Bernt, I do get the idea that you have had a lot of shit thrown your way but you don't have to respond to every post or take everyone or anyone seriously if you don't want to.
A lot of people have your back here.
deepeepee- Posts : 125
Activity : 127
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-05-13
Jill Havern, Nina, crusader, CaKeLoveR, Bluebagthepirate, Jojo1, pinkgladioli and Clishmaclaver like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
I don't think he's been under attack though, the forum would be going nowhere if we all agreed on the same thing.
Surely he didn't expect everyone on the forum to believe his every word, I don't think he was challenged by unreasonable questions, he's bigger than that.
We do more squabbling amongst ourselves than we do with Bernt, but we just carry on.
crusader- Forum support
- Posts : 7252
Activity : 7607
Likes received : 349
Join date : 2019-03-12
CaKeLoveR, Honesty, AnneCGuedes and Jojo1 like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
I don't think so. From memory, you've always seemed very supportive of Bernt's theories.CaKeLoveR wrote:Neither do I, and I hope I haven't contributed to his considering leaving. I was negative about him before he joined.
Honesty- Posts : 235
Activity : 245
Likes received : 6
Join date : 2024-04-02
crusader and Jojo1 like this post
Page 19 of 21 • 1 ... 11 ... 18, 19, 20, 21
» Official Find Madeleine Campaign on Facebook
» Has anyone got any questions from reading 'The Brick' or watching the James English podcast?
» Crime Analyst, Chelsea Hoffman's 'Madeleine McCann' book is complete - but it has very bad reviews so far
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse