BRICK Reviews
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse
Page 5 of 18 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ... 11 ... 18
Re: BRICK Reviews
Thankyou, yes Peter. Im presuming its web as I havent got Mac. Its fine, it sits as an icon on my laptop and I crank it up to have a look at Bernts book. Im just nervous about using new things. I will get used to it. I liked the idea of having it as a file on my computer so that I could back it up and stuff, but its fine. No doubt I will find the facility enormously helpful. I have just been resistant to getting any kindle stuff because I prefer to sit and read a book. However, cross referencing is an enormous challenge with a book. This will make it easy. As with many things inlife, once weve got used to them we wonder how we ever managed without.PeterMac wrote:Have you downloaded Kindle onto your computer. Kindle for Mac, or Kindle for Web ?
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
PeterMac likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
to a DAY EARLIER might prompt people who saw and heard things on Wednesday 2/5/7 but thought they were irrelevant to reconsider and realise they were important.
The PJ statements tended to skip over 2/5/7, for obvious reasons.
Just a thought.
Nina, crusader, Bluebagthepirate and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Basically they are telling the truth but not in the right order as it happened.
So it would make perfect sense, to me anyway, to confuse when someone saw something but thought it to be irrelevant.
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Silentscope likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
It reminds me of the conversation between Andre Previn and Eric morecambe. Where Andre accused Eric of playing all the wrong notes on the piano and Eric retorted by saying he was playing all the right notes but not necessarily in the right order.
This seems to be exactly what they are doing. It is a good tactic, because it means you can tell the truth about something happening, just omit to say that it was a different day than is being asked about.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
crusader and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
The Photo is real
The time may well be correct but is irrelevant
The DATE is wrong
and for a long time it worked. Until this forum started to get suspicious
We began to suspect it was wrong, and debated for a long time about exaclty what was wrong with it
and then came the revelation.
Nothing wrong with the PHOTO
Lots wrong with the DATE
We, and the PJ, had been looking in the wrong direction.
As they had intended.
When the history is written it will note that it was Mitchell who alerted us to that, by giving us "too much information" and insisting we looked the time which he said was wrong because it had not been changed on the internal clock - even though the UK and Portugal are in the SAME time zone
So we looked at the time, and it actually seemed ok. Lunch time-ish
Then we looked at the date, and compared with with the Mccanns OWN statements. And it didn't quite seem to match.
Then we looked further and found it was a Forgery.
Then we traced it back and found who had done the alteration, and who had brought the memory stick back to PdL, and it all fitted perfectly into place.
By looking at another DATE
They had told the truth,
Only the date had been altered
sparkyhorrox, sandancer, Cammerigal, crusader, Silentscope, Jimtheblue, Cake Lover and like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Didnt bargain for Portugese law allowing release of documents, or eagle eyed investigators!!!
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
PeterMac, Nina, sandancer, crusader, Silentscope, Shash T and Jojo1 like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Re: BRICK Reviews
I also note the deafening sound of crickets from the British, Australian and American media regarding the brick and its exposure of the great abduction lie. Squeaky bum time for the media shills!
Cammerigal- Posts : 184
Activity : 263
Likes received : 75
Join date : 2017-06-18
Location : Australia
Re: BRICK Reviews
Below is taken from an interview with Lorraine Kelly (GMB)PeterMac wrote:A Tactic they used with the Pool Photo.
The Photo is real
The time may well be correct but is irrelevant
The DATE is wrong
and for a long time it worked. Until this forum started to get suspicious
We began to suspect it was wrong, and debated for a long time about exaclty what was wrong with it
and then came the revelation.
Nothing wrong with the PHOTO
Lots wrong with the DATE
We, and the PJ, had been looking in the wrong direction.
As they had intended.
When the history is written it will note that it was Mitchell who alerted us to that, by giving us "too much information" and insisting we looked the time which he said was wrong because it had not been changed on the internal clock - even though the UK and Portugal are in the SAME time zone
So we looked at the time, and it actually seemed ok. Lunch time-ish
Then we looked at the date, and compared with with the Mccanns OWN statements. And it didn't quite seem to match.
Then we looked further and found it was a Forgery.
Then we traced it back and found who had done the alteration, and who had brought the memory stick back to PdL, and it all fitted perfectly into place.
By looking at another DATE
They had told the truth,
Only the date had been altered
LK = 3 years is a long time, you still got an image of her in your head, can you still hear her, if you know what I mean
KM = yeah obviously the image we have of Madeleine we knew, So Madeleine at 4 day (corrects herself) you know know 4 years minus 9 days
pinkgladioli- Posts : 138
Activity : 141
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Re: BRICK Reviews
Stellander said Martin Smith said Gerry was wearing beige pants with buttons.
That is not accurate and is misleading, it was Aoife who said that in her first statement.
He also said, he wouldn't be surprised if Smith found that photo of Gerry wearing those pants and added that distinctive detail, which he could not have seen in the dark at that position.
He said he probably wanted to avoid the embarrassment of being wrong.
Stellander also say's he could be speculating.
As far as I have seen, Martin Smith never mentioned buttons on the man's pants in any of his statements.
That is misinformation in my opinion.
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Buzz Shine likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: BRICK Reviews
Martin never talks to Aoife? Martin is unaware of what Aoife said?crusader wrote:From the brick.
Stellander said Martin Smith said Gerry was wearing beige pants with buttons.
That is not accurate and is misleading, it was Aoife who said that in her first statement.
He also said, he wouldn't be surprised if Smith found that photo of Gerry wearing those pants and added that distinctive detail, which he could not have seen in the dark at that position.
He said he probably wanted to avoid the embarrassment of being wrong.
Stellander also say's he could be speculating.
As far as I have seen, Martin Smith never mentioned buttons on the man's pants in any of his statements.
That is misinformation in my opinion.
Really, really, really tiny "mistake" and not misinformation and doesn't affect the opinion Bernt Stellander puts forward.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 685
Activity : 710
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: BRICK Reviews
"Above all the shouting" ... what are you implying?
This is a civilised forum with, naturally, differing opinions, perspectives and personalities but no shouting.
Ladyinred- Posts : 1593
Activity : 1789
Likes received : 196
Join date : 2017-11-25
Re: BRICK Reviews
I thought it was off topic so I came over to the Brick reviews.
I do think it reflects what is in the book because there is no real reason to say the Smith sighting is not relevant because he believes Madeleine died the day before.
That is not proof of anything, it's an opinion.
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: BRICK Reviews
Does not affect Stellander's point in the slightest, and if that's the worst "misinformation" you can find then it's looking good for the Brick.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 685
Activity : 710
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: BRICK Reviews
If Madeleine died evening May 3rd then where did the cadaverine come from?crusader wrote:My point was Stellander, ( I think I'll call him Bernt from now on, Stellander sounds a bit aggressive),in relation to a conversation I was having with Bluebag on the other thread about the Smith sighting.
I thought it was off topic so I came over to the Brick reviews.
I do think it reflects what is in the book because there is no real reason to say the Smith sighting is not relevant because he believes Madeleine died the day before.
That is not proof of anything, it's an opinion.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 685
Activity : 710
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: BRICK Reviews
Martin Smith has never said any such thing.
I'm not an expert on cadaverine, so I can't comment on that point.
I'm not trying to discredit Bernt in any way, but if someone is writing a book as important as this one, the details should be accurate.
If Madeleine died after high tea, would that be long enough for cadaver odour to form or whatever it does?
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: BRICK Reviews
What I find strange is that for someone who was on a 7 day holiday when we have seen certain repetition of some attire worn and despite me searching through Getty images solarpix i cant find him wearing the same clothes, I wonder what happened to them and were they ever tested by Keela and Eddie?
I’m sorry I can’t do links although if anyone is interested they can find the clip on YouTube
07/05/04 CH4 Girl snatched in Portugal ( Gerry enters the clip at 1.31
Just to say Crusader I
pinkgladioli- Posts : 138
Activity : 141
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
crusader likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
pinkgladioli- Posts : 138
Activity : 141
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
crusader likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Honestly this is trivial.crusader wrote:It wasn't about the colour of the trousers, more about the buttons, and then saying Smith saw a photo of Gerry in pants with buttons and added it to save his embarrassment.
Martin Smith has never said any such thing.
I'm not an expert on cadaverine, so I can't comment on that point.
I'm not trying to discredit Bernt in any way, but if someone is writing a book as important as this one, the details should be accurate.
If Madeleine died after high tea, would that be long enough for cadaver odour to form or whatever it does?
The Smiths mentioned beige trousers and "possibly buttons".
Martin is the catch-all for the family, doesn't matter.
It's not a big deal and it does seem like you are trying to discredit Bernt because he thinks smithman is irrelevant - which it is.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 685
Activity : 710
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: BRICK Reviews
It's not a big deal and it does seem like you are trying to discredit Bernt because he thinks smithman is irrelevant - which it is.
It wasn't me who brought Bern't into the conversation, it was you.
I was just saying why I thought the Smith sighting was relevant, I never mentioned Bernt.
And just to be clear, I think the Brick is fantastic, but if I see a mistake, I will comment.
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: BRICK Reviews
Yes because he makes complete sense.crusader wrote:It wasn't me who brought Bern't into the conversation, it was you.
You brought up the minor detail about the Smith statements to put a bad light on his opinion of the Smith sighting.
By the way I just reread the part of the book where he mentions the beige trousers and buttons. The emphasis is on the colour beige and not the buttons.
Page 248: "He probably wanted desperately to avoid embarrassment of being wrong; so, that was convenient, as he could have thought those pants were for holidays, beige chinos. I'm speculating of course'.
You have to ask yourself why Gerry would walk around PDL at that time with a child in his arms (dead or not) and run the risk of bumping into someone he knew - like happened 45 minutes earlier.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 685
Activity : 710
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: BRICK Reviews
I will admit I used to think it was Gerry, but because I don't know, and by the way the Smiths have never positively identified Gerry, I believe they saw "a man with a child".
By the way, I didn't bring up the minor detail to put a bad light on his opinion of the Smith sighting.
I only quoted what he himself wrote in the Brick, and only to say it's because it doesn't fit in with his theory.
crusader- Posts : 6320
Activity : 6664
Likes received : 338
Join date : 2019-03-12
Bluebagthepirate likes this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
Cake Lover- Posts : 2574
Activity : 2624
Likes received : 50
Join date : 2024-02-13
crusader and Bluebagthepirate like this post
Re: BRICK Reviews
I had success ordering Bernt's book after emailing modocromia editora@gmail.com and, following a few e-mails back and forth exchanging details, I did a bank transfer, as requested. Maria Esther was efficient and I received my 'brick', in Scotland, within a week.
THE NUGGETS
As Bernt gave a couple of hints re the Scottish Golden Nuggets, I thought of a few simple things to google and .. hey presto .... I've identified them, although I'll stress that I don't know them! After going into several websites, I had a 'well, I never' moment when I saw a post relating to Mr Nugget's anticipated advice to law firms. An appreciative east coast of Scotland lawyer stated: 'Can't wait ___________. Always good nuggets from you'.
The person who commented is actually someone I know, but not well. You couldn't make
it up! Rest assured, I'll not be trying to find out more from that person.
What could the connections be?
Did the Ns simply offer friendship and hospitality after meeting G and K at the PDL church? My feeling is that are of different religious persuasions, but if there's not much choice of church in PDL and if people are intent on attending, they'll take what's on offer.
Did they already know each other, despite an age gap of 19 years? G is from the south side of Glasgow and it looks as though the Ns are from the south-west side, nearby.
Did this help to establish a rapport?
Could they have friends/acquaintances in common?
Could G have friends/ex-colleagues who were neighbours of the Ns?
Could a relative/friend of G's have used the law firm services at some point?
Could it be a golf connection?
Could it relate to G's days with Glasgow Celtic?
Is J.G. of church key and car garaging somehow linked?
I'll rule out Catenians - see my comment above re religion.
Is there a sinister London connection?
I must say that if the Ns have been hoodwinked by G&K and then embroiled in their hot mess, I have sympathy for them. The whole situation is baffling to say the least.
Clishmaclaver- Posts : 8
Activity : 8
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-08-17
Age : 72
Location : Scotland
crusader and Jojo1 like this post
Page 5 of 18 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ... 11 ... 18
![-](https://2img.net/i/empty.gif)
» Official Find Madeleine Campaign on Facebook
» Garth's Theory
» Crime Analyst, Chelsea Hoffman's 'Madeleine McCann' book is complete - but it has very bad reviews so far
» Challenge to the Met Police and the Home Office over their non-supply of information about Operation Grange - Internal Reviews sought (22 Sep 2016)
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse