The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Page 3 of 5 • Share
Page 3 of 5 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
My opinion on these six photographs is…
The SIX PHOTOS of Madeleine McCann in Praia da Luz
Was there ever any CCTV footage of the McCann's arriving at Faro airport on the 29th I think ?
____________________
For Paulo Sargento, the thesis that Gonçalo Amaral revealed at first hand to "SP" that the blanket could have been used in a funeral ceremony at the Luz chapel "is very interesting".
And he adds: "In reality, when the McCanns went to Oprah's Show, the blanket was mentioned. At a given moment, when Oprah tells Kate that she heard her mention a blanket several times, Kate argued that a mother who misses a child always wants to know if she is comfortable, if she is warm, and added, referring to Maddie, that sometimes she asked herself if the person who had taken her would cover her up with her little blanket (but the blanket was on the bed after Maddie, supposedly, disappeared!!!).
ROSA- Posts : 1436
Activity : 2120
Likes received : 101
Join date : 2011-04-19
Location : Dunedin New Zealand
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
They arrived on Saturday 28th April 2007
They were taken by bus to the complex, checked in, were then taken to their apartment
sorted themselves out, and then went to the children's play area, where the three photos were taken.
(jumping on grass, and the two with the Play house)
as did many other families with children who can be seen in those same photos.
Until that point everything was as normal as one would expect of any family with three small children on the first day of a holiday.
The big fluffy clouds visible in the three photos coincide exactly with the known weather conditions
on that day, and with all the photos posted on Flickr by dozens of other people for that date.
I am not sure how CCTV of arrival at the airport would be important
They were taken by bus to the complex, checked in, were then taken to their apartment
sorted themselves out, and then went to the children's play area, where the three photos were taken.
(jumping on grass, and the two with the Play house)
as did many other families with children who can be seen in those same photos.
Until that point everything was as normal as one would expect of any family with three small children on the first day of a holiday.
The big fluffy clouds visible in the three photos coincide exactly with the known weather conditions
on that day, and with all the photos posted on Flickr by dozens of other people for that date.
I am not sure how CCTV of arrival at the airport would be important
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] - can you find or repost the squirrel story so new members can understand what it means? I remember reading it the first time you posted about squirrel and have kept my eye on him since thanks
sammyc- Posts : 268
Activity : 383
Likes received : 113
Join date : 2011-10-06
Location : UK
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Here you go:
A lawyer advertised for a clerk. The next morning his office was crowded with applicants — all bright, many suitable. He bade them wait until all should arrive, and then ranged them in a row and said he would tell them a story, note their comments, and judge from that whom he would choose.
‘A certain farmer,’ began the lawyer, ‘was troubled with a red squirrel that got in through a hole in his barn and stole his seed corn. He resolved to kill the squirrel at the first opportunity. Seeing him go in at the hole one noon, he took his shot gun and fired away; the first shot set the barn on fire.’
‘Did the barn burn?’ said one of the boys.
The lawyer without answer continued: ‘And seeing the barn on fire, the farmer seized a pail of water and ran to put it out.’
‘Did he put it out?’ said another.
‘As he passed inside, the door shut to and the barn was soon in flames. When the hired girl rushed out with more water.’
‘Did they all burn up?’ said another boy.
The lawyer went on without answer:–
‘Then the old lady came out, and all was noise and confusion, and everybody was trying to put out the fire.’
‘Did any one burn up?’ said another.
The lawyer said: ‘There that will do; you have all shown great interest in the story.’ But observing one little bright-eyed fellow in deep silence, he said: ‘Now, my little man, what have you to say?’
The little fellow blushed, grew uneasy, and stammered out:–
‘I want to know what became of that squirrel; that’s what I want to know.’
‘You’ll do,’ said the lawyer; ‘you are my man; you have not been switched off by a confusion and a barn burning, and the hired girls and water pails. You have kept your eye on the squirrel.’
A lawyer advertised for a clerk. The next morning his office was crowded with applicants — all bright, many suitable. He bade them wait until all should arrive, and then ranged them in a row and said he would tell them a story, note their comments, and judge from that whom he would choose.
‘A certain farmer,’ began the lawyer, ‘was troubled with a red squirrel that got in through a hole in his barn and stole his seed corn. He resolved to kill the squirrel at the first opportunity. Seeing him go in at the hole one noon, he took his shot gun and fired away; the first shot set the barn on fire.’
‘Did the barn burn?’ said one of the boys.
The lawyer without answer continued: ‘And seeing the barn on fire, the farmer seized a pail of water and ran to put it out.’
‘Did he put it out?’ said another.
‘As he passed inside, the door shut to and the barn was soon in flames. When the hired girl rushed out with more water.’
‘Did they all burn up?’ said another boy.
The lawyer went on without answer:–
‘Then the old lady came out, and all was noise and confusion, and everybody was trying to put out the fire.’
‘Did any one burn up?’ said another.
The lawyer said: ‘There that will do; you have all shown great interest in the story.’ But observing one little bright-eyed fellow in deep silence, he said: ‘Now, my little man, what have you to say?’
The little fellow blushed, grew uneasy, and stammered out:–
‘I want to know what became of that squirrel; that’s what I want to know.’
‘You’ll do,’ said the lawyer; ‘you are my man; you have not been switched off by a confusion and a barn burning, and the hired girls and water pails. You have kept your eye on the squirrel.’
____________________
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]MAGA [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]MBGA
A wise man once said:
"Be careful who you let on to your ship,
because some people will sink the whole ship
just because they can't be the Captain."
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Superfast, nice one Jill.
sammyc- Posts : 268
Activity : 383
Likes received : 113
Join date : 2011-10-06
Location : UK
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
ROSA wrote:Was there ever any CCTV footage of the McCann's arriving at Faro airport on the 29th I think ?
If you have any questions or observations on the holiday photographs in general, would you please post here..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Thank you.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Posting this video made in 2018, which again, suggests that the Tennis Balls Photo is a forgery:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
It also suggests that the maker has been paying careful attention to CMOMM and to Petermac's analyses of the Tennis Balls photo, which may be seen here:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
It also suggests that the maker has been paying careful attention to CMOMM and to Petermac's analyses of the Tennis Balls photo, which may be seen here:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Copied over from Dr Martin Roberts 'A Nightwear Job' thread..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Tony Bennett wrote:Posting this video made in 2018, which again, suggests that the Tennis Balls Photo is a forgery:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
It also suggests that the makee has been paying careful attention to CMOMM and to Petermac's analyses of the Tennis Balls photo, which may be seen here:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
The YouTube video is a compilation of observations I've seen and read over the years, both here on CMOMM and other fora and blogs. 10/10 for effort but where does it lead?
By example, I just had to laugh at the commentary relating to the tennis court photograph. Firstly, when trying to analyse the tennis ball image, the video narrator places much emphasis on skin and hair colour along with other detail appertaining to colour.
Making comparison with the poolside photograph, she then goes on to say that Madeleine pictured on a tennis court would appear to be wearing Amelie's sun hat. The two images appear side by side on the video, thus..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
A major discrepency highlighted as regards skin and hair colour in order to suggest the tennis ball image is fake, then a direct assertion that Madeleine is wearing Amelie's sun hat - a totally different colour?
Are you with me ....
That aside, there are any number of Madeleine McCann photographs circulating mainstream and social meda, different colouring, different sizes, cropped/uncropped - even front to back. The more time passes, the more obscure this case becomes.
Meanwhile, a source close to the family begins the beguine..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Verdi wrote:
Meanwhile, a source close to the family begins the beguine..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
The photo appears to have first been circulated on May 7th, in the [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], two days before this article and sans Crimestoppers #.
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Yes ^^^, that's correct..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[Acknowledgement pamalam at gerrymccannsblog]
I have added the e-mail attachment as linked on gerrymccannsblog. I can't vouch for the authenticity of the e-mail content nor the linked tennis ball image as can be seen, the pamalam entry is not a screenshot nor an email copy, therefore the origin of the document is unknown.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
[Acknowledgement pamalam at gerrymccannsblog]
I have added the e-mail attachment as linked on gerrymccannsblog. I can't vouch for the authenticity of the e-mail content nor the linked tennis ball image as can be seen, the pamalam entry is not a screenshot nor an email copy, therefore the origin of the document is unknown.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
The screenshots are in the files, in the link I put above (click 'Pat Perkins'):
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Are the red elbows and knees from crawling on the red bitumen stuff on/by the tennis court? Just asking?
Milo- Posts : 224
Activity : 267
Likes received : 43
Join date : 2017-10-12
Age : 78
Location : WOODY POINT Australia
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
The information posted above by [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] and [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] is very helpful. Thank you, both.
It leads us to review what is known about the hugely controversial Tennis Balls Photo.
That is the ONLY photo of Madeleine that is claimed by the McCanns to have been taken after lunch-time on Sunday 29 April - apart, that is, from (a) the Last/Pool Photo, which many think was taken on sunny Sunday 29 April, but the McCanns say was taken Thursday, and the Make-Up Photo, which has several indications that it may have been taken on the afternoon of Sunday 29 April.
On another thread, [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] made a pronouncement about what it means when the EXIF data accompanying a photograph uses the word 'Created on ____ (date)'. Verdi wrote:
"As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use".
I cannot agree with that statement, as I am sure I have seen other examples of where a photographer or press agency has 'created' an image afresh e.g. by cropping, photoshopping, taking a photo of a photo etc.
But, for a moment, let us assume that Verdi's statement above is correct.
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
Now, who on the forum believes that?
Now let assume that Verdi's statement is NOT correct, and that the Tennis Balls Photo has somehow been 'created' i.e. put together EITHER by photographing a photograph, OR by photoshopping, OR by some other means (we really do need a digital photography expert to come in and help is with this).
THEN the above, most useful information provided above may give is clue about the true provenance of the Tennis Balls Photo.
We see from the news media reports on Wednesday 9 May that "The e-poster has been created by Madeleine's aunt, Philomena McCann. Ms McCann is the sister of Gerry McCann, Maddie's father, and lives in Scotland".
Was it? For we now know that Philomena McCann was not 'Ms McCann' but in reality Mrs Tony Rickwood. And thanks to PeterMac's excellent detective work, we know that Tony Rickwood was an expert photoshopper, specialising, on the 'Deviant Art' site, in composing highly professional, photoshopped images, of near-naked women drowning, a practice known as 'the quicksand fetish".
We also know from this 2006 email that Mr Tony & Mrs Philomena Rickwood were quite well off:
Hello everyone, my wife and I have been restoring a nice spot close to Flix in Tarragona for the last year or so. No plans to move out permanently yet but we visit often and now that the bulk of the work is done, we can start to appreciate the local area a bit more. We spend most of our time in Ullapool, Scottish highlands, which has its own superb scenery and wildlife- I have worked on a land based salmon farm for many years and am always close to the action, as well as the weather and the dreaded scottish midge! My employer is a keen birdwatcher, especially Raptors and always "expects a full report" when I return. I am also a keen photographer, both of the night sky and wildlife- I have been photographing the Aurora borealis from Ullapool for years, but the insects and reptiles in Catalonia are of great interest to me. As a pure courtesy, I get pictures of birds for my employer! I'm currently building an electronic camera trigger for capturing lightning photos from some of those amazing mediterranean storms.
But we also see that the Tennis Balls Photo wasn't initially released by Philomena McCann, it was released in the form of a poster, as early as Monday 7 May, by one of the McCann family's friends, a 'Pat Perkins', who is self-described on the e-mail as 'Pat Perkins, Pre employment lead NHS academy North West'.
She is still in the same job, and has been since 2004, as her publicly-viewable Linked-In profile makes clear.
She is based in Liverpool and described as follows in a recent NHS briefing paper:
LINK - [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Skills for Health
Pat Perkins
North West Pre Employment Development Lead
Since 2004
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.].uk
Her Linked-In profile also tells us that she was educated at Notre Dame Roman Catholic High School, Everton Valley, Liverpool.
So was Kate Marie Healy
It leads us to review what is known about the hugely controversial Tennis Balls Photo.
That is the ONLY photo of Madeleine that is claimed by the McCanns to have been taken after lunch-time on Sunday 29 April - apart, that is, from (a) the Last/Pool Photo, which many think was taken on sunny Sunday 29 April, but the McCanns say was taken Thursday, and the Make-Up Photo, which has several indications that it may have been taken on the afternoon of Sunday 29 April.
On another thread, [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] made a pronouncement about what it means when the EXIF data accompanying a photograph uses the word 'Created on ____ (date)'. Verdi wrote:
"As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use".
I cannot agree with that statement, as I am sure I have seen other examples of where a photographer or press agency has 'created' an image afresh e.g. by cropping, photoshopping, taking a photo of a photo etc.
But, for a moment, let us assume that Verdi's statement above is correct.
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
Now, who on the forum believes that?
Now let assume that Verdi's statement is NOT correct, and that the Tennis Balls Photo has somehow been 'created' i.e. put together EITHER by photographing a photograph, OR by photoshopping, OR by some other means (we really do need a digital photography expert to come in and help is with this).
THEN the above, most useful information provided above may give is clue about the true provenance of the Tennis Balls Photo.
We see from the news media reports on Wednesday 9 May that "The e-poster has been created by Madeleine's aunt, Philomena McCann. Ms McCann is the sister of Gerry McCann, Maddie's father, and lives in Scotland".
Was it? For we now know that Philomena McCann was not 'Ms McCann' but in reality Mrs Tony Rickwood. And thanks to PeterMac's excellent detective work, we know that Tony Rickwood was an expert photoshopper, specialising, on the 'Deviant Art' site, in composing highly professional, photoshopped images, of near-naked women drowning, a practice known as 'the quicksand fetish".
We also know from this 2006 email that Mr Tony & Mrs Philomena Rickwood were quite well off:
Hello everyone, my wife and I have been restoring a nice spot close to Flix in Tarragona for the last year or so. No plans to move out permanently yet but we visit often and now that the bulk of the work is done, we can start to appreciate the local area a bit more. We spend most of our time in Ullapool, Scottish highlands, which has its own superb scenery and wildlife- I have worked on a land based salmon farm for many years and am always close to the action, as well as the weather and the dreaded scottish midge! My employer is a keen birdwatcher, especially Raptors and always "expects a full report" when I return. I am also a keen photographer, both of the night sky and wildlife- I have been photographing the Aurora borealis from Ullapool for years, but the insects and reptiles in Catalonia are of great interest to me. As a pure courtesy, I get pictures of birds for my employer! I'm currently building an electronic camera trigger for capturing lightning photos from some of those amazing mediterranean storms.
But we also see that the Tennis Balls Photo wasn't initially released by Philomena McCann, it was released in the form of a poster, as early as Monday 7 May, by one of the McCann family's friends, a 'Pat Perkins', who is self-described on the e-mail as 'Pat Perkins, Pre employment lead NHS academy North West'.
She is still in the same job, and has been since 2004, as her publicly-viewable Linked-In profile makes clear.
She is based in Liverpool and described as follows in a recent NHS briefing paper:
LINK - [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Skills for Health
Pat Perkins
North West Pre Employment Development Lead
Since 2004
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.].uk
Her Linked-In profile also tells us that she was educated at Notre Dame Roman Catholic High School, Everton Valley, Liverpool.
So was Kate Marie Healy
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
@Tony Bennett wrote:
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
Where on earth does that piece of information stem from? Why is it presumed the photograph was taken on Saturday 5th May 2007?
This particular image could be an original, it's been reproduced so many times, who's to know with any certainty? Not that I necessarily believe it to be an original - at least not taken at the Ocean Club during that fateful week.
Before going any further, it is on public record that Jon Corner was one of the first to arrive in Luz after the alarm was raised, on 4th/5th May 2007 if I remember rightly, apparently armed with a portfolio of Madeleine McCann photographs. It was claimed that he busied himself circulating images to the media.
I will check-out the detail later.
It takes but a few seconds/minutes to electronically 'move' a photograph/image from one place to another. I could take a photograph now, upload it to my laptop and then on the forum within minutes
NB: For the record, I didn't mention EXIF data, I referred only to press agency photographic archives.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Verdi wrote:@Tony Bennett wrote:
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
Where on earth does that piece of information stem from? Why is it presumed the photograph was taken on Saturday 5th May 2007?
Er...from your very own words upthread, [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], where you wrote this, quote:
"...they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken".
Whereas I was clearly suggesting upthread that the word 'created on' does NOT necessarily mean the date the photo was taken
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
The exact words I used, not up-thread but over on the Dr Martin Roberts 'Pyjama Job' were thus..
So back to my question .... 'why is it presumed the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007'?
Vewrdi wrote:As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use.
So back to my question .... 'why is it presumed the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007'?
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Reverting to the video link posted up-page#83, as I said previously, the video (I haven't the vaguest idea who the author is) is a compilation of comments and analysis posted across social media over the years.
Here's an example courtesy of forum member tigger's blog..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
The mark?
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
This is a rubbish image. Who's even flipped the flipping image?
Just goes to how how deceptive it can be to play around with photographs - quite damaging I think.
Here's an example courtesy of forum member tigger's blog..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
tigger wrote:For some reason the photograph was released after it was ‘flipped’. That is: the description given to the police mentions ‘a small brown mark on Left Leg Calf’. When Madeleine faces towards the left, the mark is on the left leg.
The mark?
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
This is a rubbish image. Who's even flipped the flipping image?
Just goes to how how deceptive it can be to play around with photographs - quite damaging I think.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Verdi wrote:The exact words I used, not up-thread but over on the Dr Martin Roberts 'Pyjama Job' were thus..Verdi wrote:As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use.
So back to my question .... 'why is it presumed the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007'?
Again, [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], the assumption/presumption is based entirely on your very own words, as you've just requoted above.
You have asserted that, quote, "Invariably, if not always, the wording 'created on' means the date the photograph was taken".
Your words, not mine.
As it happens, both the controversial Tennis Balls Photo and the controversial Luis Forra pyjamas photo were marked as 'created' on Saturday 5 Saturday (maybe just another of those 'coincidences'.
According to your logic and assertion above, that must mean that you think that both photographs were actually taken on Saturday 5 May.
Have I misunderstood what you say? I think not.
-----
Whereas I still think it is at least possible that the McCanns took that photograph themselves. In their holiday apartment
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Alex Woolfall's name has cropped up recently on this thread.
Here are a few excerpts from one of the Alex Woolfall threads which may once again be of some interest:
=========================================================================
Times, October 6, 2007
Alex Woolfall on Madeleine’s photos:
The McCanns had photographs of Madeleine on their digital camera, which Mr Woolfall began transferring to a laptop computer. "I said to Kate, 'Let's try to identify pictures where her face is visible'. Downloading the images was a very difficult process for them. It was upsetting.
[SNIPPED...]
Mr Woolfall transmitted the photographs to the Press Association in London, from where they were distributed to the media. The portfolio included the now famous image of Madeleine wearing a hat on a tennis court.
Now, once again: WHY wasn't the "Last Picture" there?
sharonl wrote on 08.09.13 11:38
This thread raises a good many questions not only about 'The Last Photo' but also about the other photos supposedly taken of Madeleine that week.
The link on HideHo's site to the article about Alex Woolfall certainly makes interesting reading.
One obvious question, for starters, is what was Alex Woolfall doing sorting through the McCanns' camera's memory card?
Why weren't the Portuguese police looking at it?
Another question is how did this camera get into the hands of a Hampshire Police Officer who examined it on Tuesday 8 May, apparently in his own home.
Who took it there, presumably by plane, and on whose authority?
Were any images deleted from the memory stick? I think they were. Who deleted them and why?
Also, we are talking about 'the McCanns' camera' as if they only had one camera. Did they perhaps have more than one?
Another question: why are there so few photos of her that week?
Plus, who actually took the 'tennis balls' photo?
Aiyoyo wrote:
Official police work not authorised and not carried out within authorised venue can become legal contention as procedures are breached.
Elements of tampering and/or lack of record can become an issue in Court case.
If no record is kept of downloaded materials he would have to rely heavily on memory if the authenticity of the last photo becomes a contentious issue.
Not only that, the digital details set and/or captured on the camera would be lost to his recollection years later.
So yeah, if proven that Madeleine died earlier than the 3rd, Alex Woolfall may face questioning.
Tigger wrote:
From the topic 'Video Analysis of the tennis photo' by Garyp.
Have been doing an analysis of different photos for a while now, this is the first posting and video I have done on them so be gentle.
The tennis court photo - I have read many things about photoshopping of this picture so thought I would look into it further.
It first appeared in the media unless anyone knows different on the morning of Monday 7th May.
This means it must have been in the hands of the editor Sunday 6th May for the layout to be arranged.
6th May was Mothers’ Day and the church service
Would Gerry have been emailing this picture to the editor that day? Possibly...
This photo was not used in PDL in the first days after M disappeared.
7th May was a busy day for this photo. It was also used in the email 'chain letter' sent out by Pat Perkins, family friend of Kate’s mother, where did she get it so quickly? And she doesn’t really look like someone who would be able to cut the picture down from the original. Don’t know, maybe she uses photoshop in her spare time.
[Edited to add: We now know that her husband is Mr Tony Rickwood, a photoshopping expert who produced many images of women drowning in quicksand for a website, ‘Deviant Art’]
unquote
So Woolfall must have missed this one on Monday? It already went out and imo it was never on the camera.
Here are a few excerpts from one of the Alex Woolfall threads which may once again be of some interest:
=========================================================================
Times, October 6, 2007
Alex Woolfall on Madeleine’s photos:
The McCanns had photographs of Madeleine on their digital camera, which Mr Woolfall began transferring to a laptop computer. "I said to Kate, 'Let's try to identify pictures where her face is visible'. Downloading the images was a very difficult process for them. It was upsetting.
[SNIPPED...]
Mr Woolfall transmitted the photographs to the Press Association in London, from where they were distributed to the media. The portfolio included the now famous image of Madeleine wearing a hat on a tennis court.
Now, once again: WHY wasn't the "Last Picture" there?
sharonl wrote on 08.09.13 11:38
This thread raises a good many questions not only about 'The Last Photo' but also about the other photos supposedly taken of Madeleine that week.
The link on HideHo's site to the article about Alex Woolfall certainly makes interesting reading.
One obvious question, for starters, is what was Alex Woolfall doing sorting through the McCanns' camera's memory card?
Why weren't the Portuguese police looking at it?
Another question is how did this camera get into the hands of a Hampshire Police Officer who examined it on Tuesday 8 May, apparently in his own home.
Who took it there, presumably by plane, and on whose authority?
Were any images deleted from the memory stick? I think they were. Who deleted them and why?
Also, we are talking about 'the McCanns' camera' as if they only had one camera. Did they perhaps have more than one?
Another question: why are there so few photos of her that week?
Plus, who actually took the 'tennis balls' photo?
Aiyoyo wrote:
Official police work not authorised and not carried out within authorised venue can become legal contention as procedures are breached.
Elements of tampering and/or lack of record can become an issue in Court case.
If no record is kept of downloaded materials he would have to rely heavily on memory if the authenticity of the last photo becomes a contentious issue.
Not only that, the digital details set and/or captured on the camera would be lost to his recollection years later.
So yeah, if proven that Madeleine died earlier than the 3rd, Alex Woolfall may face questioning.
Tigger wrote:
From the topic 'Video Analysis of the tennis photo' by Garyp.
Have been doing an analysis of different photos for a while now, this is the first posting and video I have done on them so be gentle.
The tennis court photo - I have read many things about photoshopping of this picture so thought I would look into it further.
It first appeared in the media unless anyone knows different on the morning of Monday 7th May.
This means it must have been in the hands of the editor Sunday 6th May for the layout to be arranged.
6th May was Mothers’ Day and the church service
Would Gerry have been emailing this picture to the editor that day? Possibly...
This photo was not used in PDL in the first days after M disappeared.
7th May was a busy day for this photo. It was also used in the email 'chain letter' sent out by Pat Perkins, family friend of Kate’s mother, where did she get it so quickly? And she doesn’t really look like someone who would be able to cut the picture down from the original. Don’t know, maybe she uses photoshop in her spare time.
[Edited to add: We now know that her husband is Mr Tony Rickwood, a photoshopping expert who produced many images of women drowning in quicksand for a website, ‘Deviant Art’]
unquote
So Woolfall must have missed this one on Monday? It already went out and imo it was never on the camera.
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Tony Bennett wrote:Verdi wrote:The exact words I used, not up-thread but over on the Dr Martin Roberts 'Pyjama Job' were thus..Verdi wrote:As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use.
So back to my question .... 'why is it presumed the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007'?
Again, [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], the assumption/presumption is based entirely on your very own words, as you've just requoted above.
You have asserted that, quote, "Invariably, if not always, the wording 'created on' means the date the photograph was taken".
Your words, not mine.
As it happens, both the controversial Tennis Balls Photo and the controversial Luis Forra pyjamas photo were marked as 'created' on Saturday 5 Saturday (maybe just another of those 'coincidences'.
According to your logic and assertion above, that must mean that you think that both photographs were actually taken on Saturday 5 May.
Have I misunderstood what you say? I think not.
-----
Whereas I still think it is at least possible that the McCanns took that photograph themselves. In their holiday apartment
Yes, I believe you have misunderstood me - and totally confused me in the process.
@Tony Bennett wrote:
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
The fact I pointed out that press agency photograph archives use the wording 'created on' equates to presuming the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007? You've lost me.
To simplify, forget anything I've said before, only understand I'm trying to ascertain where this information stems from - as I've said more than once. Where does the suggestion that the tennis ball image was taken/created on Saturday 5th May 2007 originate?
I have never made such a claim.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Verdi wrote:@Tony Bennett wrote:
That would mean that the Tennis Balls Photo was TAKEN on Saturday 5 May.
The fact I pointed out that press agency photograph archives use the wording 'created on' equates to presuming the tennis ball image was taken on 5th May 2007? You've lost me.
To simplify, forget anything I've said before, only understand I'm trying to ascertain where this information stems from - as I've said more than once. Where does the suggestion that the tennis ball image was taken/created on Saturday 5th May 2007 originate?
I have never made such a claim.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], Good morning.
I think part of the problem may be that we are swapping between two threads at the moment, as were are discussing TWO photographs, BOTH said to have been 'created' on Saturday 5 May 2007:
(1) The Tennis Balls Photo, and
(2) The Luis Forra pyjamas photo.
In relation to the Tennis Balls Photo, I posted this image, which shows (in the bottom right of picture) the date of 'creation' of the image as 05-05-2007 i.e. Saturday 5 May:
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Above: A graphic produced by Lizzy Hideho Taylor in 2009. It is available in a slightly clearer image elsewhere on the internet on a couple of YouTube videos, where the puzzling date of 'creation' on 5 May 2007 is also discussed
-----
I then applied your dictum to this photograph, i.e.,
As an aside, if you trawl through the various press agency photograph archives, you will note they ALL use the wording 'created on'. Invariably, if not always, this means the date the photograph was taken. It DOES NOT mean, nor imply, that any particular image has been photo-shopped, manipulated, invented - or whatever other verb you prefer to use.
Now, if you are right, i.e. that CREATED = TAKEN, then clearly the Tennis Balls photo could NOT have been 'TAKEN' on any of the various dates stated for it having been taken by the McCanns and some of their Tapas 7 friends.
Whereas I maintain that CREATED does NOT necessarily mean the date it was TAKEN, but what it says, i.e. 'CREATED' e.g. by photoshopping, other editing, 're-creating' it somehow, taking a photo of a photo etc.
In this connection I think you might agree with me that it may be very significant that AFAIK the Tennis Balls Photo was first, let us say 'produced' for public consumption by, according to two sources on 7 & 9 May, Philomena McCann in Ullapool. It appears to have been sent on Sunday 6 May (see discussion upthread) to Kate McCann's Liverpool school friend Pat Perkins, who promptly emailed it far and wide the following morning (7 May).
But we NOW know that Philomena McCann was living with her husband, Tony Rickwood, a professional photoshopper of 'quicksand fetish' notoriety.
All of this strengthens IMO the case that the Tennis Balls Photo is a photoshopped creation, quite possibly a composite of two or three separate images. In support of this is PeterMac's careful analysis that the image was NOT taken on Kate McCann's Canon Sureshot/Powershot 620 as claimed in Kate McCann's work 'madeleine'.
As an aside I find it of interest that the Luis Forra pyjamas photo which we are discussing elsewhere was also created on Saturday 5 May, and my argument of course applies to that as well.
To give one straightforward possibility: he (Forra) could very well have been given a digital image by Kate McCann of her photo of those pyjamas, then edited it, and pushed it out as 'created' by the Luis Forra press agency.
Is not this similar to some of the McCanns' other images of Madeleine now being accredited to Paul Grover? (who incidentally photographed me outside the High Court in February 2013).
.
____________________
Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"
Amelie McCann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".
Tony Bennett- Investigator
- Posts : 16926
Activity : 24792
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 77
Location : Shropshire
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Aha! So this is what it's all about - now we're getting somewhere..
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
The worrying part of this is the wording, I quote .... 'Is this the EXIF data for the tennis ball pic'
A question, not a statement of fact nor even a hint of authenticity. For this to have any true value, I would expect to see something on the lines of .... 'this is the EXIF data for the tennis ball pic'
Excuse my cynicism, over the years I've seen so many instances of urban myth originating through some misguided, or mischievous, source.
I can't read the EXIF data presented but in the interest of accuracy, I'll hunt around for a readable graphic when I have a spare moment. I hope it's worth the effort, it's not looking too promising at present.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
The worrying part of this is the wording, I quote .... 'Is this the EXIF data for the tennis ball pic'
A question, not a statement of fact nor even a hint of authenticity. For this to have any true value, I would expect to see something on the lines of .... 'this is the EXIF data for the tennis ball pic'
Excuse my cynicism, over the years I've seen so many instances of urban myth originating through some misguided, or mischievous, source.
I can't read the EXIF data presented but in the interest of accuracy, I'll hunt around for a readable graphic when I have a spare moment. I hope it's worth the effort, it's not looking too promising at present.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
I don't really understand all the technical stuff about the photo's, so I'll just say this. Kate Mccann could have sent the tennis ball's photo ( and any other for that matter ) to her parent's soon after taking them and they in turn could have done what they wanted with them, ie sent them to whoever they wanted.
In the PJ files, there is a statement from Aurelio Guerreiro a friend of Pat Perkins who owned a bar in Villamoura. Pat Perkins called him and asked him to help the Mccann's and gave him a contact number for the mccann's.
He phoned the police in Portugal to establish they were aware of missing child. He also rang the Mccann's twice 00-30 & 1am, he
also gave them his phone number.
He said Pat Perkins was staying in Liverpool with Kate's parent's when she rang him in Villamoura.
He didn't hear anymore from Pat Perkins until 7th May when she sent him an email of Madeleine.
In the PJ files, there is a statement from Aurelio Guerreiro a friend of Pat Perkins who owned a bar in Villamoura. Pat Perkins called him and asked him to help the Mccann's and gave him a contact number for the mccann's.
He phoned the police in Portugal to establish they were aware of missing child. He also rang the Mccann's twice 00-30 & 1am, he
also gave them his phone number.
He said Pat Perkins was staying in Liverpool with Kate's parent's when she rang him in Villamoura.
He didn't hear anymore from Pat Perkins until 7th May when she sent him an email of Madeleine.
crusader- Forum support
- Posts : 6797
Activity : 7148
Likes received : 345
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
I've spent some time looking for a readable version of Lizzy 'Hi-De-Ho' Taylor's graphic - to no avail.
However, what I did come across is of interest to this discussion. The date claimed to be when the tennis ball image was 'created' [sic], the 5th May 2007, would appear to have been instigated by a past CMOMM forum member, canada12.
The member posted a link to a Bruno Press which is no longer available - at least not to my laptop. At the time it must have been viewable as Hi-De-Ho produced another graphic showing McCann family handout photographs, including the tennis ball image said to have been created on 5th May 2007.
Without access to Bruno Press I can't comment.
Now the worrying thing here is canada12 talked a good job, implying a good knowledge of photograpics but little else. For a start, s/he said if we had access to the original photograph or a first print-off so to speak, s/he/we would be able to produce the EXIF data from said photograph.
This is the same member who wasted hours of forum time and space trying to convince the world that one photograph of Madeleine McCann showed flowers on and around her neck - if memory serves me well.
It was clear canada12 knew nothing about photography despite claims to the contrary.
My view .... the origin of the image is dubious but without a clue to work on, there is no way of knowing it's true value. As it stands it's just another red herring.
With the likes of canada12 as a leading light, I'm inclined to abandon the subject.
However, what I did come across is of interest to this discussion. The date claimed to be when the tennis ball image was 'created' [sic], the 5th May 2007, would appear to have been instigated by a past CMOMM forum member, canada12.
The member posted a link to a Bruno Press which is no longer available - at least not to my laptop. At the time it must have been viewable as Hi-De-Ho produced another graphic showing McCann family handout photographs, including the tennis ball image said to have been created on 5th May 2007.
Without access to Bruno Press I can't comment.
Now the worrying thing here is canada12 talked a good job, implying a good knowledge of photograpics but little else. For a start, s/he said if we had access to the original photograph or a first print-off so to speak, s/he/we would be able to produce the EXIF data from said photograph.
This is the same member who wasted hours of forum time and space trying to convince the world that one photograph of Madeleine McCann showed flowers on and around her neck - if memory serves me well.
It was clear canada12 knew nothing about photography despite claims to the contrary.
My view .... the origin of the image is dubious but without a clue to work on, there is no way of knowing it's true value. As it stands it's just another red herring.
With the likes of canada12 as a leading light, I'm inclined to abandon the subject.
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]
Guest- Guest
Re: The SIX PHOTOS that provide the biggest clue to when Madeleine died
Rachel Oldfield's Rogatory Interview
[The morning of Friday 4th May 2007]
'I remember having, sort of being on the phone a little bit to the BBC I think that morning, erm and then sort of various phone calls, I talked to John CORNER who's a friend of Gerry and Kate's, erm cos the BBC wanted a picture of Madeleine, erm and he had some photos that he was going to be able to send them, erm and then and I think maybe about ten-ish'
...................
madeleine by KATE MCCANN
Friday 4th May 2007
By this time our friend Jon Corner, a creative director in media production in Liverpool, was circulating photographs and video footage of Madeleine to the police, Interpol and broadcasting and newspaper news desks.
Jon Corner had opened up the file transfer protocol he’d set up on 4 May to circulate Madeleine’s image to family, friends and other supporters. No, I didn’t know what one of those was, either: basically, it provided access via a password to a repository for photographs and other material, allowing people to share their resources. Helpers could post their material on a dedicated server via the FTP and use that supplied by others to create flyers, posters and so on. The press already had the password, which gave them access to pictures and video footage.
[The morning of Friday 4th May 2007]
'I remember having, sort of being on the phone a little bit to the BBC I think that morning, erm and then sort of various phone calls, I talked to John CORNER who's a friend of Gerry and Kate's, erm cos the BBC wanted a picture of Madeleine, erm and he had some photos that he was going to be able to send them, erm and then and I think maybe about ten-ish'
...................
madeleine by KATE MCCANN
Friday 4th May 2007
By this time our friend Jon Corner, a creative director in media production in Liverpool, was circulating photographs and video footage of Madeleine to the police, Interpol and broadcasting and newspaper news desks.
Jon Corner had opened up the file transfer protocol he’d set up on 4 May to circulate Madeleine’s image to family, friends and other supporters. No, I didn’t know what one of those was, either: basically, it provided access via a password to a repository for photographs and other material, allowing people to share their resources. Helpers could post their material on a dedicated server via the FTP and use that supplied by others to create flyers, posters and so on. The press already had the password, which gave them access to pictures and video footage.
Guest- Guest
Last photo
To me it looks like her hair is shorter in the last photograph. She has her head inclined downwards towards her chin in this photo, in order to trap the tennis balls securely. This would make her hair length seem longer than the just below collar bone length of the previous photos. I would say the last photo was taken at a different time from that holiday.
LaRabbita0- Posts : 4
Activity : 6
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2019-05-28
Page 3 of 5 • 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Similar topics
» THE ***SEVEN*** PHOTOS THAT PROVIDE THE BIGGEST CLUE TO WHEN MADELEINE DIED (New photo of Madeleine in Praia da Luz produced by the McCann Team, taken on Sunday 29 April)
» 'The truth has died with him': Uncle of 'Ireland's Madeleine McCann' Mary Boyle, 6, has died - and he was the last person to see her alive before she vanished in 1977
» The Biggest Madeleine McCann Theories: What Really Happened?
» NEW PHOTO CLUE TO MADELEINE MCCANN CASE
» Rachael Oldfield's Rogatory Interview - Notes from a Potting Shedder
» 'The truth has died with him': Uncle of 'Ireland's Madeleine McCann' Mary Boyle, 6, has died - and he was the last person to see her alive before she vanished in 1977
» The Biggest Madeleine McCann Theories: What Really Happened?
» NEW PHOTO CLUE TO MADELEINE MCCANN CASE
» Rachael Oldfield's Rogatory Interview - Notes from a Potting Shedder
Page 3 of 5
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum