New book: 'Lies & Deception': Madeleine-the impossible kidnapping by Peter Scharrenberg ***NEW*** Unanimous verdict is that this is a thoroughly bad 'book' - so thread closed

[Jill Havern]

Journalist Peter Scharrenberg studied the very large Portuguese police file on the missing three-year-old British toddler Madeleine McCann.  She disappeared on May 3, 2007 mysteriously from her bed in a Portuguese holiday village, where she ao with her parents Gerry and Kate, was on vacation.  According to them, she is kidnapped by a pedophile burglar.
 Scharrenberg has in his research two key witnesses in the cases have been found which are obviously completely forgotten or overlooked are seen by the police and who have played no role in the research.  These two witnesses have, however, already one day after the loss, made very incriminating statements to Gerry McCann, Madeleine's father.  Because of this there must be serious doubts about the accuracy of the timeline that has been made at the time by the police and is always used as a guide in the investigation.  The implications of the statements of these two 'forgotten' witnesses are enormous, as this seems to be demonstrated that Father Gerry itself the "kidnapper" was.  In addition, these statements come from a Roman Catholic priest and a retired British businessman picture as possible of helping hands to hide the little body of the toddler.  Both men are never investigated.
 In this book he also describes the main findings, witness statements and forensic evidence and put it into context, making it the reader, according to the author, it is increasingly clear that the parents have been or should involved in the disappearance of their daughter and that while they have had help.

http://www.boekenbestellen.nl/boek/leugens-misleiding/12782

https://translate.google.co.uk/translate?hl=en&sl=nl&u=http://www.boekenbestellen.nl/boek/leugens-misleiding/12782&prev=search

[hogwash]

Wakey wakey Carter Ruck!  

[jeanmonroe]

"In addition, these statements come from a Roman Catholic priest and a retired British businessman picture as possible of helping hands to hide the little body of the toddler. BOTH MEN ARE NEVER INVESTIGATED"

WAKEY, WAKEY! DCI, KM 'mini me', Wall!

'Nick' BOTH of these 'men' even before they KNOW they've been 'nicked', by YOU!

[worriedmum]

Is this available in English?

[PeterMac]

Is this available in English?

It has just put my copy into my "Winkel Wagon"
Dutch is wonderful !

[Rogue-a-Tory]

Is this available in English?

Even if it isn't, I'm sure it'll be serialised on the twins' school bus journey - just like Dr Amaral's was

[Guest]

Ordered!

[Guest]

Hi all. Being Dutch I decided to look up this Peter Scharrenberg. I had never heard of him.
There is no journalist named Peter Scharrenberg that has published anything other than this book (self-published, no publisher).
There is a crime journalist called Koen Scharrenberg who published a book in 2011.
Peter Scharrenberg gets no mention on internet anywhere, ever, apart from a linkedin profile without a picture and with 1 connection.
I am very curious if this is indeed a serious book he has written.

Call me paranoid, but it is a great way for people who are interested in say "the McCann stalkers" to get details (shipping address, name etc.)
I am also curious who brought this book to the attention of (the owner of) this forum.
Maybe the writer is a trustworthy person, who used the name Peter Scharrenberg as a pseudonym. But I would like to know more before I buy the book.

[hogwash]

Hi all. Being Dutch I decided to look up this Peter Scharrenberg. I had never heard of him.
There is no journalist named Peter Scharrenberg that has published anything other than this book (self-published, no publisher).
There is a crime journalist called Koen Scharrenberg who published a book in 2011.
Peter Scharrenberg gets no mention on internet anywhere, ever, apart from a linkedin profile without a picture and with 1 connection.
I am very curious if this is indeed a serious book he has written.

Call me paranoid, but it is a great way for people who are interested in say "the McCann stalkers" to get details (shipping address, name etc.)
I am also curious who brought this book to the attention of (the owner of) this forum.
Maybe the writer is a trustworthy person, who used the name Peter Scharrenberg as a pseudonym. But I would like to know more before I buy the book.

Looking at the image in the OP, it looks like a tweet by PR_UK_1  @Papa_Rico on #mccann

[Guest]

Too many official investigations and official inquiries and unofficial investigations and unofficial inquiries and official documentaries and unofficial documentaries and official unofficial books and unofficial 'Untold Stories of Madeleine McCann' for my liking.  All that's required is the initial investigation by the PJ and latterly the exemplary combined works of Richard D Hall - the rest is superfluous!

Don't waste yer money!

[Jill Havern]

Hi all. Being Dutch I decided to look up this Peter Scharrenberg. I had never heard of him.
There is no journalist named Peter Scharrenberg that has published anything other than this book (self-published, no publisher).
There is a crime journalist called Koen Scharrenberg who published a book in 2011.
Peter Scharrenberg gets no mention on internet anywhere, ever, apart from a linkedin profile without a picture and with 1 connection.
I am very curious if this is indeed a serious book he has written.

Call me paranoid, but it is a great way for people who are interested in say "the McCann stalkers" to get details (shipping address, name etc.)
I am also curious who brought this book to the attention of (the owner of) this forum.
Maybe the writer is a trustworthy person, who used the name Peter Scharrenberg as a pseudonym. But I would like to know more before I buy the book.

Looking at the image in the OP, it looks like a tweet by PR_UK_1  @Papa_Rico on #mccann

Twitter account

@scharmedia

- ‏@scharmedia 21h21 hours ago
Okee, sorry. http://www.boekenbestellen.nl/boek/madeleine  I'm afraid it's in Dutch. But I can give you some highlights in the next few days. Revealing stuff.

[woodpecker]

Ordered!

parapono - when you have read it, could you please post a detailed review here?

[petunia]

- ‏@scharmedia 46m46 minutes ago
TImeline made by police evening May 3rd 2007 is wrong. This is a big mistake. The prove is there...just pick it up.#mccann



9:19 PM

[aiyoyo]

Let's see if the McCanns are going to ban this book !

Do they need one year to decide, like they did to Dr. Amaral's book?  We shall see.

[Mark Willis]

Too many official investigations and official inquiries and unofficial investigations and unofficial inquiries and official documentaries and unofficial documentaries and official unofficial books and unofficial 'Untold Stories of Madeleine McCann' for my liking.  All that's required is the initial investigation by the PJ and latterly the exemplary combined works of Richard D Hall - the rest is superfluous!

Don't waste yer money!

By god you are a right pessimistic, doom mongering swine, sir.
Which is handy because I totally agree with you.
Nothing is what it seems with this case and we should always ask "why?" before we accept what we see is what it purports to be.
Imagine if we thought that Scummers and Swansong's book really was "the definitive account"?
As opposed to it being a thinly veiled, co-Mc-SKY-MSM compilation of total crap.

[guest12345]

This will be another book full of waffle, regurgitated snippets and theories by someone else who has no more access to the case files than you or i. I wouldn't waste your money.

The only books worth reading come from those involved in the case, either in Portugal or the UK. 

Unfortunately, only 1 of these books has been released to date (Amarals) based on half of the case files (the POI files only), so until the remainder of the Portuguese files are released (currently held by OG and PJ as part of the on-going case) or Redwood/other brings out a book based on his 'experience' of the case, then this is just more of the same.

Save your money and donate it to Amaral instead, he needs his livelihood back.

[pennylane]

Ordered!

parapono - when you have read it, could you please post a detailed review here?

I too am interested to know, when you have the time to spare dear parapono.

[PeterMac]

Ordered!

parapono - when you have read it, could you please post a detailed review here?

I too am interested to know, when you have the time to spare dear parapono.

Now there is a radical thought.
Reading the book BEFORE criticising it
We could extend that to seeing the trailer, and then the documentary BEFORE criticising them . . .

Sorry, That is Heresy, I know.

[MRNOODLES]

http://www.boekenbestellen.nl/boek/leugens-misleiding/12782

via google translator
Journalist Peter Scharrenberg studied the very large Portuguese police file on the missing three-year-old British toddler Madeleine McCann. She disappeared on May 3, 2007 mysteriously from her bed in a Portuguese holiday village, where she ao with her ​​parents Gerry and Kate, was on vacation. According to them, she is kidnapped by a pedophile burglar. 
Scharrenberg has in his research two key witnesses in the cases have been found which are obviously completely forgotten or overlooked are seen by the police and who have played no role in the research. These two witnesses have, however, already one day after the loss, made ​​very incriminating statements to Gerry McCann, Madeleine's father. Because of this there must be serious doubts about the accuracy of the timeline that has been made ​​at the time by the police and is always used as a guide in the investigation. The implications of the statements of these two 'forgotten' witnesses are enormous, as this seems to be demonstrated that Father Gerry itself the "kidnapper" was. In addition, these statements come from a Roman Catholic priest and a retired British businessman picture as possible of helping hands to hide the little body of the toddler. Both men have never been 
investigated.'ve Been in this book, he also describes the main findings, witness statements and forensic evidence and put it into context, making it the reader, according to the author, it is increasingly clear that the parents have to involved in the disappearance of their daughter and that they thereby have had help.

[willowthewisp]

Hi MRNOODLES
I hope this book is not making reference to the procure of the church keys and who stored a certain silver vehicle for a short while on a certain couple's behalf, who then caught an easyjet flight back to the UK before the Portugal, PJ had time to go to Court for papers that could have decided travel restrictions to them?

[lj]

I doubt CR will do anything. They left the other book "Fake(d) Abduction  (from Brian ???) alone, and that one was in English. 

IMO Dr Amaral was attacked because of what he knows. They know he knows, but they don't know when he is going to publish all. That's why he has to be destroyed, at all cost, the sooner the better.

[aiyoyo]

Snipped from PM's comment left at GoFundMe
Also new book out in Holland naming the people who perhaps inadvertently helped to move or store the body - allegedly, obviously !

Fascinating !
It will be interesting to know who the Dutch author named as body disposal helper or helpers.

[sallypelt]

Snipped from PM's comment left at GoFundMe
Also new book out in Holland naming the people who perhaps inadvertently helped to move or store the body - allegedly, obviously !

Fascinating !
I will be interesting to know who the Dutch author named as body disposal helper or helpers.

inadvertently helped??? 

[aiyoyo]

Snipped from PM's comment left at GoFundMe
Also new book out in Holland naming the people who perhaps inadvertently helped to move or store the body - allegedly, obviously !

Fascinating !
It will be interesting to know who the Dutch author named as body disposal helper or helpers.

inadvertently helped??? 

either.....the inadvertently bit....

[Guest]

Ordered!

parapono - when you have read it, could you please post a detailed review here?

I too am interested to know, when you have the time to spare dear parapono.

I'll try.

[Guest]

This will be another book full of waffle, regurgitated snippets and theories by someone else who has no more access to the case files than you or i. I wouldn't waste your money.

The only books worth reading come from those involved in the case, either in Portugal or the UK. 

Unfortunately, only 1 of these books has been released to date (Amarals) based on half of the case files (the POI files only), so until the remainder of the Portuguese files are released (currently held by OG and PJ as part of the on-going case) or Redwood/other brings out a book based on his 'experience' of the case, then this is just more of the same.

Save your money and donate it to Amaral instead, he needs his livelihood back.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hI1nPd7hezM

[PeterMac]

inadvertently helped??? 

either.....the inadvertently bit....

1 Can I just leave this tennis bag here for a couple of days
- v -
2 Can I just leave this tennis bag - which contains a child - here for a couple of days

Possibly. I haven't received my copy yet, so it is pure guesswork - like almost everything else.

[Guest]

I just posted on another thread the news that Peter Scharrenberg will retract his book from the market.
I have his permission to post this on the forum.
parapono

[Tony Bennett]

I just posted on another thread the news that Peter Scharrenberg will retract his book from the market.
I have his permission to post this on the forum.
parapono

After research that he undertook
Peter Scharrenberg published his book
Two-year-old twins were aged 'one'
The whole work was a con
After parapono had a good look.

[pennylane]

I just posted on another thread the news that Peter Scharrenberg will retract his book from the market.
I have his permission to post this on the forum.
parapono

Thank you very much for your prompt report parapono.