How can he get away with this?

by picard 17.05.15 22:23

https://www.facebook.com/diggingformadeleinmccann/photos/a.216699198493115.1073741849.205966349566400/471981102964922/?type=1&theater

This is a link to Stephen Birches FB Digging for Madeline.

I would like to know how he is not being sued by the McCann's or why the police are not investigating him!!! This guy posted on FB an offer of £100 for someone to slap Kate in the face and provide photo evidence. Come on really?

Something is very amiss here the guy seems untouchable, in fact he says he is untouchable I am at a complete loss he is at very least the definition of a TROLL and no one is doing anything about it.

Your thoughts guys..

by Guest 17.05.15 22:24

He's a useful idiot for someone.

by picard 17.05.15 22:55

BlueBag wrote:He's a useful idiot for someone.

But how is he getting away with it? you know as well as I do if that was me or you we would be getting a letter through the post of Little Brunty on our doorstep. The guy is saying "I am untouchable" how can he have so much confidence and not hit the radar of the police?

by Guest 17.05.15 23:00

It's useful for someone to say "look.. an idiot... they're all idiots".

by Google.Gaspar.Statements 18.05.15 10:37

I would say he's employed by the McCann's to help make us all look like nutters and haters, that's why they haven't sued him. He's useful to them. spin

by NickE 18.05.15 10:53

Google.Gaspar.Statements wrote:I would say he's employed by the McCann's to help make us all look like nutters and haters, that's why they haven't sued him. He's useful to them.

Yes, Birch think's that Gerry placed Madeleine under Murats driveway?
dontgetit

by Liz Eagles 18.05.15 11:03

What never ceases to amaze me is the attention Stephen Birch continues to receive on this forum. Remember Stephen Birch was given an exclusive slot/rant/diatribe/interview by Sonia Poulton on TPV.

Birch was chucked off this forum after being entertained for a woefully long time by people who later left the forum to begin their own. They didn't entertain Birch on the new forum.

Whilst I understand what posters are saying here, personally I'd not give anything he has to say a nod in the desert.

The why and what for of the existence of Stephen Birch and his mad ramblings doesn't have a place on this forum imo. Twitter and Facebook have that covered and welcome him freely.

Why give a voice to him on this forum?

by Google.Gaspar.Statements 18.05.15 11:25

aquila wrote:What never ceases to amaze me is the attention Stephen Birch continues to receive on this forum. Remember Stephen Birch was given an exclusive slot/rant/diatribe/interview by Sonia Poulton on TPV.

Birch was chucked off this forum after being entertained for a woefully long time by people who later left the forum to begin their own. They didn't entertain Birch on the new forum.

I agree with that analysis thumbsup

by Liz Eagles 18.05.15 11:37

Google.Gaspar.Statements wrote:
aquila wrote:What never ceases to amaze me is the attention Stephen Birch continues to receive on this forum. Remember Stephen Birch was given an exclusive slot/rant/diatribe/interview by Sonia Poulton on TPV.

Birch was chucked off this forum after being entertained for a woefully long time by people who later left the forum to begin their own. They didn't entertain Birch on the new forum.

I agree with that analysis

I would have preferred if you quoted my post in full. The part you have quoted can be misconstrued as divisive.

by NickE 18.05.15 19:04

From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?

by Liz Eagles 18.05.15 19:21

NickE wrote:From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?

Why not ask Stephen Birch directly on Facebook? Why infect this forum with a conversation you could be having elsewhere to answer you question?

Just my opinion.

by NickE 18.05.15 19:42

aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?
Why not ask Stephen Birch directly on Facebook? Why infect this forum with a conversation you could be having elsewhere to answer you question?

Just my opinion.

Obviously, he says that´s true, that´s why he wrote it.
Therefore I ask here if someone who is "independent" from Birch know if it´s true.
I thought a forum was a place for discussions or should we bury our heads in the sand every time someone writes something we do not agree with?

No to censorship, yes to freedom of expression.

by Liz Eagles 18.05.15 19:52

NickE wrote:
aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?
Why not ask Stephen Birch directly on Facebook? Why infect this forum with a conversation you could be having elsewhere to answer you question?

Just my opinion.
Obviously, he says that´s true, that´s why he wrote it.
Therefore I ask here if someone who is "independent" from Birch know if it´s true.
I thought a forum was a place for discussions or should we bury our heads in the sand every time someone writes something we do not agree with?

No to censorship, yes to freedom of expression.

aaaah, I see the usual 'freedom of expression' and 'censorship' soundbites raise their head when it's quite clear to anyone who has been around the block on this forum that this is a meddlesome post. It's not the first you've quoted either Nick E. Remember the disgusting post (from elsewhere) about Madeleine that you chose to dump onto this forum?

Just my opinion.

by NickE 18.05.15 20:07

aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:
aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?
Why not ask Stephen Birch directly on Facebook? Why infect this forum with a conversation you could be having elsewhere to answer you question?

Just my opinion.
Obviously, he says that´s true, that´s why he wrote it.
Therefore I ask here if someone who is "independent" from Birch know if it´s true.
I thought a forum was a place for discussions or should we bury our heads in the sand every time someone writes something we do not agree with?

No to censorship, yes to freedom of expression.
aaaah, I see the usual 'freedom of expression' and 'censorship' soundbites raise their head when it's quite clear to anyone who has been around the block on this forum that this is a meddlesome post. It's not the first you've quoted either Nick E. Remember the disgusting post (from elsewhere) about Madeleine that you chose to dump onto this forum?

Just my opinion.

And I have a different opinion.
Democracy is wonderful, isn't it?
thumbup

by NickE 18.05.15 20:10

NickE wrote:
aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:
aquila wrote:
NickE wrote:From Birch Facebook:

"NOTICE: This page has just learned that the Renault Scenic hired by the McCanns with the number plate 59 DA 27 that had been returned to Budget Lagos was damaged. It seems the cars front left door lock had been tampered with. This information was obtained by Stephen D. Birch from an employee of the company AA Castanheira in Faro. It substantiates Stephen Birch's theory that Portuguese Police, friends of Robert Murat broke into the car, and planted dna belonging to MADDIE in the vehicle after removing it off the corpse buried in the Murat property ! The vehicle was hired 25 days after MADDIE went missing."

Is this true?
Why not ask Stephen Birch directly on Facebook? Why infect this forum with a conversation you could be having elsewhere to answer you question?

Just my opinion.
Obviously, he says that´s true, that´s why he wrote it.
Therefore I ask here if someone who is "independent" from Birch know if it´s true.
I thought a forum was a place for discussions or should we bury our heads in the sand every time someone writes something we do not agree with?

No to censorship, yes to freedom of expression.
aaaah, I see the usual 'freedom of expression' and 'censorship' soundbites raise their head when it's quite clear to anyone who has been around the block on this forum that this is a meddlesome post. It's not the first you've quoted either Nick E. Remember the disgusting post (from elsewhere) about Madeleine that you chose to dump onto this forum?

Just my opinion.
And I have a different opinion.
Democracy is wonderful, isn't it?
But I can ask the question in another thread,,if it feels better for you.

by Mark Willis 19.05.15 10:17

By the same token you could say, "Maddie? Well she's been discussed to every length imaginable. So let's talk about Venezuelan Beaver Cheese instead."
Nothing is irrelevant in this bizarre case. It's not like anyone is promoting the clown that is Birch.
As has been said, he serves a useful purpose to the Mcs by deflecting attention from them to this complete nutter.
The question is, is he on the McPay roll to do so?
Seems a legitimate question to me.

by **Tony Bennett** 19.05.15 10:26

Mark Willis wrote: It's not like anyone is promoting the clown that is Birch.

There are only two people on this earth that I know who have activley promoted 'the clown that is Birch'.

One is Chris Spivey, the one with the blog replete with the 'f' and 'c' words, who gave him and his madcap theory a plug and spoke to him at length on the 'phone.

The other of course is Sonia Poulton, who gave Birch an uncritical 40-minute platform when she was a presenter of David Icke's ill-fated 'People's TV', utterly failing to challenge his arrant nonsense.

Stephen Birch...Chris Spivey...Sonia Poulton...hmmm

by Mark Willis 19.05.15 10:27

Tony Bennett wrote:
Mark Willis wrote: It's not like anyone is promoting the clown that is Birch.
There are only two people on this earth that I know who have activley promoted 'the clown that is Birch'.

One is Chris Spivey, the one with the blog replete with the 'f' and 'c' words, who gave him and his madcap theory a plug and spoke to him at length on the 'phone.

The other of course is Sonia Poulton, who gave Birch an uncritical 40-minute platform when she was a presenter of David Icke's ill-fated 'People's TV', utterly failing to challenge his arrant nonsense.

Stephen Birch...Chris Spivey...Sonia Poulton...hmmm

I think that says it all, Tony. Amen to that. high5