Bernt Stellander interview
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse
Page 2 of 19 • 1, 2, 3 ... 10 ... 19
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
crusader- Posts : 6347
Activity : 6693
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
GreenTara likes this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Silentscope- Posts : 2872
Activity : 2983
Likes received : 117
Join date : 2020-06-30
GreenTara likes this post
alan, GreenTara and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
I will watch the video again, but I don’t remember much new information - just almost verbatim repetition of Amaral’s book, and many of the theories I have read on here. He even name checks this forum several times.
Like I said - I hope I’m wrong and that there is more to come from this, I’ve followed this case since the day it happened, and strongly believe Maddie was not abducted and that the McCanns hold the key. I just hope this isn’t a bait and switch to sell books. Perhaps he’ll release a teaser of the footage he has, who knows.
phil_burton- Posts : 86
Activity : 97
Likes received : 1
Join date : 2013-10-14
AnneCGuedes likes this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
You should post more often - you last posted seven years ago - as it's good to have a variety of viewpoints.
Bern t is building on existing knowledge so obviously is going to reference Amaral and this forum.
Ladyinred- Posts : 1604
Activity : 1801
Likes received : 197
Join date : 2017-11-25
GreenTara and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
I will watch the video again, but I don’t remember much new information - just almost verbatim repetition of Amaral’s book, and many of the theories I have read on here. He even name checks this forum several times.
It is very far from a "repetition of Amaral’s book"
It tears apart - with the benefit of 17 years of analysis and a lot of new evidence which Dr Amaral did not have - the fundamental invented ‘story’ which DCI Amaral had to contend with.
even in the first two ‘half kilos; of the Brick it picks the story apart and then reconstructs in the right order which reveals a new and seriously credible scenario
This new scenario, using much of what the Tapas and the McCanns themselves said and did as the foundation, is compelling.
He pays respect to - or as you disparagingly say “Name Checks” - this forum and several individuals for the contribution they have made to the deeper understanding of the case as a whole, and their dedication to picking apart the lies and deceits which so many have unthinkingly accepted.
I recommend your buying a copy and studying it in detail so you may compare it with your other sources of information and your own research notes
You will find much to interest you.
Nina, Cammerigal, Ladyinred, Silentscope, GreenTara, Shash T and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Yes, good luck to Bernt Stellander.crusader wrote:All the other authors of books about Madeleine haven't gone nearly as far as Bernt Stellander.
He's camped out on the Rocher Negra and fitted many field cameras.
I can't wait for the video's to be released showing what he caught, I hope it's sooner rather than later.
If what he say's is true, the McCann's will have a lot of explaining to do.
That in itself is worth him making money from his findings, I begrudge him nothing, I hope he makes a fortune, he will need it if he gets Carter Rucked.
I don't think he needs to worry about being Carter Rucked. I think the days of the McCanns suing people are over.
Honesty- Posts : 115
Activity : 122
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-04-02
Nina, Silentscope, Cake Lover and GreenTara like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
No problem, fixing dinner is perfectly acceptable of course!phil_burton wrote:Sorry, I simply wasn’t online - have a young family I was making dinner.
I will watch the video again, but I don’t remember much new information - just almost verbatim repetition of Amaral’s book, and many of the theories I have read on here. He even name checks this forum several times.
Like I said - I hope I’m wrong and that there is more to come from this, I’ve followed this case since the day it happened, and strongly believe Maddie was not abducted and that the McCanns hold the key. I just hope this isn’t a bait and switch to sell books. Perhaps he’ll release a teaser of the footage he has, who knows.
I’m struggling to understand how you can be so strong in a such a simplistic view that’s way off the mark. You sound like this view is fixed tho, so not sure there will be much worth in a second watch of the interview.
GreenTara- Posts : 49
Activity : 53
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-06-05
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
So I'm going in. The spectacles are buffed and the coffee perc is on.
____________________
Not one more cent from me.
Nina- Posts : 3025
Activity : 3385
Likes received : 348
Join date : 2011-06-16
Age : 81
crusader, Silentscope, GreenTara, Shash T and pinkgladioli like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
I didnt want to dissect my copy into parts (I’m not the best with a Stanley blade,) I found perching the brick on a cushion on my lap I was able to read it quite comfortably Enjoy!Nina wrote:It has arrived. The delivery man said '' Careful love it's heavier than it looks'' so I told him it was nicknamed the brick. He plaited his brows so I told him it was a book. ''Heavy reading then'' he answered grinning at his own joke.
So I'm going in. The spectacles are buffed and the coffee perc is on.
pinkgladioli- Posts : 156
Activity : 159
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Nina, crusader, GreenTara and Shash T like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Amy Dean- Posts : 522
Activity : 634
Likes received : 108
Join date : 2014-11-13
Location : Wherever I hang my hat
Nina, crusader, Cake Lover and GreenTara like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
GreenTara- Posts : 49
Activity : 53
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-06-05
pinkgladioli likes this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Did you "strongly believe M wasn't abducted" from day 1 (ie you heard of it via the media) ?phil_burton wrote:Sorry, I simply wasn’t online - have a young family I was making dinner.
I will watch the video again, but I don’t remember much new information - just almost verbatim repetition of Amaral’s book, and many of the theories I have read on here. He even name checks this forum several times.
Like I said - I hope I’m wrong and that there is more to come from this, I’ve followed this case since the day it happened, and strongly believe Maddie was not abducted and that the McCanns hold the key. I just hope this isn’t a bait and switch to sell books. Perhaps he’ll release a teaser of the footage he has, who knows.
AnneCGuedes- Posts : 237
Activity : 245
Likes received : 8
Join date : 2024-05-23
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Regarding others posts in reply to mine - I don’t necessarily agree with all the theories on this site (there have been many!), I think the truth lies in a mixture of many of the theories posted here - there’s too much detail to go in to here, but I fundamentally agreed with the logic of Amarals book - he seemed to have the case nailed.
My original post on this thread was simply because I found it strange for there to be another in the long line of people of have profited from this case simply by going over the publicly known facts, and I’m sorry Peter_Mac but I don’t see what Bernt has deconstructed - I listened to the interview (granted I’ve not read the book) but he sounded like he was reading word for word the old “truth of the lie”. Perhaps you could correct me and tell me what *new* information or analyses he brought to the table apart from the as yet unproved discovery of a location containing several ‘markers’ that attracted visits from McCanns and associates.
Like I say, happy to be proven wrong, but no one has yet shown me something that is new.
phil_burton- Posts : 86
Activity : 97
Likes received : 1
Join date : 2013-10-14
AnneCGuedes likes this post
crusader- Posts : 6347
Activity : 6693
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
The Book is in two parts. The first part basically puts the events in an order based on what was said in the PJ files, McCann tv/media interviews, and their bewk, and makes sense of it all. The video interview seems to be based on part one of the Book. So, yes, as far as part one is concerned it doesn't tell "us" (the people who have followed/studied the case for many years) anything new, but has been enormously helpful in making sense of what was done/said by Team McCann, and why. In my opinion. But, I believe this part one, and the interview, is more for the benefit of those who have not followed the "real" story. It also gives "us" hope that finally there will be justice for Madeleine.phil_burton wrote:No I watched the news closely, and I got a very bad feeling about the parents - that’s what piqued my interest 17 years ago. Obviously, the initial information coming out of Portugal was very contrived - on the one hand we’d got Amaral making them Arguidos and therefore suspects, but the UK media backing the McCanns.
Regarding others posts in reply to mine - I don’t necessarily agree with all the theories on this site (there have been many!), I think the truth lies in a mixture of many of the theories posted here - there’s too much detail to go in to here, but I fundamentally agreed with the logic of Amarals book - he seemed to have the case nailed.
My original post on this thread was simply because I found it strange for there to be another in the long line of people of have profited from this case simply by going over the publicly known facts, and I’m sorry Peter_Mac but I don’t see what Bernt has deconstructed - I listened to the interview (granted I’ve not read the book) but he sounded like he was reading word for word the old “truth of the lie”. Perhaps you could correct me and tell me what *new* information or analyses he brought to the table apart from the as yet unproved discovery of a location containing several ‘markers’ that attracted visits from McCanns and associates.
Like I say, happy to be proven wrong, but no one has yet shown me something that is new.
Part two is about how he, the Foreign Detective, went about finding the grave. He hasn't given us all the details yet, as he is waiting to release his videos and photos, which, hopefully, will prove where Madeleine is buried.
And now we wait for justice!
All my opinion.
Shash T- Posts : 38
Activity : 38
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-06-13
Nina, GreenTara, pinkgladioli and MikaelaB like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
He told the police about one place he thought she was buried but they found nothing.
If I had gone to all the trouble he has and I thought I had found Madeleine's grave, I would have dug there until I found it or not.
I was under the impression that was what it was all about.
It's not a criticism of Stellander, it's just an observation, he has his reasons which hopefully will be revealed soon.
crusader- Posts : 6347
Activity : 6693
Likes received : 340
Join date : 2019-03-12
Nina, Ladyinred, AnneCGuedes and Shash T like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
2 main things for me
1] The story and the new timeline
I think he has looked at a lot of the McCann data in detail and has told his story very convincingly. It is not a fact it is a theorem. Plausible. Interesting. Based on assumptions. The repetition, for me, fogs things a bit. I would like the whole thing to be summarized and the justification for the assumptions made crystal clear. If you think he has, then OK, mea culpa.
2] The grave location
I found this part of the book difficult to follow clearly.
I have to say, I was not overly convinced by the author's narrative in this part of the brick. It might be correct, it might not be. As others have said - maybe photos and videos will add more substance to these claims.
Nevertheless, the key thing for me is his assumption-based [is it evidence-based?] hypothesis re what happened that night that he has laid out before us.
And, for me, what is missing in all of this story is how did this event generate such an extremely rapid, high level intelligence/political input?
And, for the Tapas 9 to have maintained their pact of silence for so many years is quite incredible. Bernt gives a decent explanation for this. But still...
Abduction or accident - neither diagnosis excuses neglect.
pablowski- Posts : 5
Activity : 6
Likes received : 1
Join date : 2019-12-07
Nina, Shash T and MikaelaB like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Deception Detective: How to ANALYZE a THEORY
4,137 views Aug 9, 2024 Deception Detective Podcast
Investigator Bernt Stellander (AKA "Foreign Detective") claims to know where Madeleine McCann is buried. But is his theory credible? Let’s react to his recent interview with James English (@JamesEnglish) to find out.
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
A wise man once said: "Be careful who you let on your ship,
because some people will sink the whole ship just because they can't be The Captain."
[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] MAGA MBGA
Jill Havern- The Captain (& Chief Faffer) Oh yeah, and Forum Owner
- Posts : 30732
Activity : 43537
Likes received : 7755
Join date : 2009-11-25
Location : Parallel universe
alan and crusader like this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Abduction is impossible.pablowski wrote:Abduction or accident - neither diagnosis excuses neglect.
Bluebagthepirate- Posts : 730
Activity : 755
Likes received : 25
Join date : 2024-01-30
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
He was a bit harsh wasnt he? He didnt seem to get that Bernt had to be annonomous initially to test the water.
He only did a little bit of the interview, perhaps if he does more he will understand why Bernt took the approach he did.
However it would seem that he has done a lot of work previously on the Mccanns.
He said that he and his subscribers had come to the conclusion that MM had ended up in a dark place such as a Cave!!!;;;;I nearly choked on my Pizza!!! A cave??? Those with kindle to to page 1044!!!
Ive tried to watch the DD before but found his constant interruptions too irritating. But having rediscovered him I decided to watch more of his analysis of the Mccanns. It was interesting.
Whilst listening to him talking about the curtains whooshing open, I had a bit of an epiphany.
What if their constant talking about how open the door was, really was significant.?
Lets imagine theyve almost closed the bedroom door, not completely, but just enough to let some light from the lounge in.
Then theyve gone out.
Theyve come back a few hours later and entered the lounge and the door is wide open!!! What a shock!!! why woukld the door be wide open? Frantic checking would ensue.
In the interview that the DD analyses, GM says something to the effect of being pleased to see the twins happily sleeping and then within minutes their peace was shattered. I suspect they went into the bedroom and saw the twins were fine but that MM wasnt in her bed. We all know what happened next.
Its awful imagining it.
MM had obviously woken up and wandered into the lounge looking for her parents.
That moment of realisation that something was seriously amiss would never leave you. No wonder the door being open was so significant.
Paddingtom- Posts : 207
Activity : 223
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2024-04-28
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Amy Dean- Posts : 522
Activity : 634
Likes received : 108
Join date : 2014-11-13
Location : Wherever I hang my hat
Ladyinred likes this post
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Ladyinred- Posts : 1604
Activity : 1801
Likes received : 197
Join date : 2017-11-25
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
Cake Lover- Posts : 2611
Activity : 2664
Likes received : 53
Join date : 2024-02-13
Re: Bernt Stellander interview
He also mentioned that Bernt could have went to the tabloid’s rather than write the book
Personally I think DD is one that is capable of falling in love with his own theory especially when hasn’t done his homework over many years like oor Bernt!
pinkgladioli- Posts : 156
Activity : 159
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2024-06-25
Page 2 of 19 • 1, 2, 3 ... 10 ... 19
» Chapter 59: PeterMac's review of The Foreign Detective Bernt Stellander's book: The Sudden Impulse
» Letter from PeterMac to Operation Grange dated 6th May re: Bernt Stellander, The Foreign Detective's, new book 'The Sudden Impulse'
» All Mccann Video Interviews - Full length
» Interview Or No Interview? That is the question.
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Bernt Stellander, 'The Foreign Detective': The Sudden Impulse