Re: LIBEL TRIAL DISCUSSION HERE

by ShuBob 08.10.13 16:51

plebgate wrote:Reportedly ID lost her cool and launched a tirade at Anne G. Can it all have been too much for her?

Never mind ID. It's all to much for me bigshock

by tiny 08.10.13 16:51

I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns

by Cristobell 08.10.13 16:54

candyfloss wrote:Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 1m
judge says book cover says it contains `exclusive revelations'..`ok so then I have to conclude this is misleading advertising', #McCann

Kate's book says all the proceeds will go to the Madeleine Fund.

by plebgate 08.10.13 16:55

tiny wrote:I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns

Was it Hobbs who posted a message to Mrs? Careful what you wish for. I think it was.

by Cristobell 08.10.13 16:56

So sorry I can't c/p - but saw a tweet that said Scotland Yard are only investigating abduction. Did anyone capture it? Didn't like the sound of that at all.

by plebgate 08.10.13 16:59

Cristobell wrote:So sorry I can't c/p - but saw a tweet that said Scotland Yard are only investigating abduction. Did anyone capture it? Didn't like the sound of that at all.

Yes one of Mr. A.'s witnesses said it today apparently.

Edited to add:

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 1m
Flores says `prophetic and dogmatic vision' behind current SY #McCann probe. UK cops `only putting forward the hypothesis of abduction'

by sallypelt 08.10.13 17:03

T @JerryLawton: Judge to Paiva: `What's new in the book that's not in the police files?' Paiva: `Nothing' #McCann

by Guest 08.10.13 17:03

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 3m
Gerry and Kate #McCann and Goncalo Amaral have all now applied to the judge to give evidence at libel trial

by tiny 08.10.13 17:06

plebgate wrote:
tiny wrote:I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns
Was it Hobbs who posted a message to Mrs? Careful what you wish for. I think it was.

any idea where I can find this post by hobbs,thanks

by gbwales 08.10.13 17:06

I think that things like this are exclusive revelations, but are not the same as the conclusions....

Madeleine's parents are already back in Vila da Luz when we receive photos taken on an area of the motorway: you can make out the figure of a little girl, who looks like Madeleine, accompanied by a couple. These images come from a CCTV camera on the motorway linking Lagos to the Spanish border. The McCanns are asked to come to Portimão in order to proceed to an identification. It's the end of the day. Kate Healy seems annoyed at coming back and made uncomfortable by the speed of the police car taking her. We are somewhat astonished by her reaction, as if she was not expecting to get her daughter back. The identification turns out negative.

https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t1716-chapter-3-announcement-of-a-disappearance

by sallypelt 08.10.13 17:08

Not sure where to put this, but admins please move to appropriate place: BREAKING NEWS

Newspapers' press regulation plans rejected

Newspaper industry proposals for a royal charter on press regulation have been rejected, Culture Secretary Maria Miller has told the House of Commons.

She said the plans did not comply with some of the "fundamental principles" of the Leveson report on press regulation, such as independence and access to arbitration.

The alternative plans proposed by the government after cross-party talks would now be "improved", she added.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24452108

by Truthandjustice 08.10.13 17:10

tiny wrote:I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns

It could be unfortunate for the Mcs particularly if the Judge elucidates the meaning of shelving of the case and arguido status according to Portuguese law which is slightly different to what the Mcs have been spinning to the press.

by plebgate 08.10.13 17:10

gbwales - you are a great addition to this forum imo. thumbup

Sorry forgot to add copy of your post gbwales:

Re: LIBEL TRIAL DISCUSSION HERE
LIBEL TRIAL DISCUSSION HERE - Page 13 Empty

gbwales Today at 5:06 pm
I think that things like this are exclusive revelations, but are not the same as the conclusions....

Madeleine's parents are already back in Vila da Luz when we receive photos taken on an area of the motorway: you can make out the figure of a little girl, who looks like Madeleine, accompanied by a couple. These images come from a CCTV camera on the motorway linking Lagos to the Spanish border. The McCanns are asked to come to Portimão in order to proceed to an identification. It's the end of the day. Kate Healy seems annoyed at coming back and made uncomfortable by the speed of the police car taking her. We are somewhat astonished by her reaction, as if she was not expecting to get her daughter back. The identification turns out negative.

https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t1716-chapter-3-announcement-of-a-disappearance

by plebgate 08.10.13 17:12

tiny wrote:
plebgate wrote:
tiny wrote:I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns
Was it Hobbs who posted a message to Mrs? Careful what you wish for. I think it was.
any idea where I can find this post by hobbs,thanks

Can't remember which post it was Tiny, but I think it was Hobbs.

I know Hobbs has posted today, maybe s/he might be able to help?

by tiny 08.10.13 17:14

plebgate wrote:
tiny wrote:
plebgate wrote:
tiny wrote:I hope the judge allowes Hate McCann to testify , will she still lie under oath and with this judge who seems to have the measure of the mccanns
Was it Hobbs who posted a message to Mrs? Careful what you wish for. I think it was.
any idea where I can find this post by hobbs,thanks
Can't remember which post it was Tiny, but I think it was Hobbs.

I know Hobbs has posted today, maybe s/he might be able to help?

thanks plebgate

by Guest 08.10.13 17:15

All tweets from Mr Amaral's witnesses today are now in Libel trial UPDATE thread to read altogether.

by Cristobell 08.10.13 17:21

plebgate wrote:
Cristobell wrote:So sorry I can't c/p - but saw a tweet that said Scotland Yard are only investigating abduction. Did anyone capture it? Didn't like the sound of that at all.
Yes one of Mr. A.'s witnesses said it today apparently.

Edited to add:

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 1m
Flores says `prophetic and dogmatic vision' behind current SY #McCann probe. UK cops `only putting forward the hypothesis of abduction'

Thank you Plebgate - don't like the sound of that, especially combined with the filming in Spain. Can they really persuade the world that the McCanns are innocent?

by Guest 08.10.13 17:25

Anne Guedes clapping

has added this in reply to this tweet from Jerry Lawton........

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 37m
judge says book cover says it contains `exclusive revelations'..`ok so then I have to conclude this is misleading advertising', #McCann

anne guedes ‏@aacg 21m
@JerryLawton @xklamation And, getting no clear answer, she concluded firmly : Then there are no revelations !

So is the Judge saying if there are no revelations, then it is nothing new and all in the files???? Does anyone else read it that way? Or have I got that wrong?

by plebgate 08.10.13 17:26

Could it be Cristsobell that she is hoping that something from Monday's Crimewatch prog. will help during any questioning by the Judge?

by Newintown 08.10.13 17:28

Cristobell wrote:
plebgate wrote:
Cristobell wrote:So sorry I can't c/p - but saw a tweet that said Scotland Yard are only investigating abduction. Did anyone capture it? Didn't like the sound of that at all.
Yes one of Mr. A.'s witnesses said it today apparently.

Edited to add:

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 1m
Flores says `prophetic and dogmatic vision' behind current SY #McCann probe. UK cops `only putting forward the hypothesis of abduction'
Thank you Plebgate - don't like the sound of that, especially combined with the filming in Spain. Can they really persuade the world that the McCanns are innocent?

After the whole world has read GA's book and the PJ files thanks to all the advertising they've had at the trial I would say "no". big grin

by Truthandjustice 08.10.13 17:29

candyfloss wrote:

So is the Judge saying if there are no revelations, then it is nothing new and all in the files???? Does anyone else read it that way? Or have I got that wrong?

Yes that is what she meant. I think the book was intended to be published before the publication of the files, maybe that's why it claimed exclusive on the cover

by plebgate 08.10.13 17:29

candyfloss wrote:Anne Guedes has added this in reply to this tweet from Jerry Lawton........

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 37m
judge says book cover says it contains `exclusive revelations'..`ok so then I have to conclude this is misleading advertising', #McCann

anne guedes ‏@aacg 21m
@JerryLawton @xklamation And, getting no clear answer, she concluded firmly : Then there are no revelations !

So is the Judge saying if there are no revelations, then it is nothing new and all in the files???? Does anyone else read it that way? Or have I got that wrong?

Yes I think that is what she is saying CF.

by Cristobell 08.10.13 17:31

Hi Candyfloss, I think the Judge is trying to establish if the conclusions of the book are the same as the conclusions of the file, is that what you are thinking too? Or perhaps, she means any revelations that would stop people searching?

by Newintown 08.10.13 17:32

candyfloss wrote:Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 5m
Port police organised crime unit head Luis Neves said Amaral's conclusion Madeleine was dead was accepted early on by parents

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 9m
Contrary to #McCann claim Paiva says publication of Amaral's book did not hinder the `flow of information' coming in to police

Jerry Lawton ‏@JerryLawton 11m
Paiva: the book `contains the professional and personal opinions of Goncalo Amaral as a police officer' #McCann

It's been mentioned on this forum a few times by different people that very early on the McCanns have stated that they accept that Madeleine could be dead (although I can't remember if it was printed in an article or said in an interview) so I've always wondered why they started the Fund and the libel trial knowing full well they have said that in the past.

by Cristobell 08.10.13 17:36

Apologies Candyfloss, I didn't see AG's follow up tweet.

No revelations - they have no case!

Log in for more topics