Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Debate Section - for purporting theories
Page 2 of 2 • Share
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
I agree, PP. Do you believe that Madeleine died before 3rd?
Guest- Guest
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
As I recall, when the bedroom door slammed shut in her face Kate immediately went to check that she hadn't left the patio doors open thereby creating a draught.PeterMac wrote:And Kate has compounded it with the "whooshing curtains" storyCristobell wrote:What a shame the McCanns cannot bury the open window and the jemmied shutters. . . ..
In her 4/5/7 statement the curtains were wide open. A year or so later they are tight closed, and demonstrated on the video by holding her forearms together, so that we know.
Then in the PJ photos the curtains are full length and trapped behind the bed and the wicker chair
And the weather reports show a flat calm night, with a light Force 3 breeze, sufficient only to move dust and light paper round.
No gusts
And in any even only on of the panes can open at a time.
It is a tissue of LIES from start to finish.
Having satisfied herself that the patio doors were closed, and having therefore established that the door did not slam shut due to any draught coming from the south/rear of the building, she then opened the bedroom door.
Given that this door is not directly opposite to that part of the patio doors used for entering/exiting the apartment it occurs to me that, in the absence of a wind blowing in from the front/north of the building, any wind entering the apartment from the rear would most probably have caused the half open door to blow fully open, banging against the wall as it did so, and the curtains to have billowed outwards through the open window.
ultimaThule- Posts : 3355
Activity : 3376
Likes received : 7
Join date : 2013-09-18
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
ProfessorPPlum wrote:Sorry to quote all but mobile and editing quotes becomes all but impossible on iPhone. Yes, totally agree with PeterMacs reminder there. Back to the basics: everything from the McCs is considered to be a falsehood. No abduction, then also no checking routine because no 'leaving children in locked/unlocked apartment'; no 'Mummy why didn't you come when...?" etc etc.Trust Your Instincts wrote:Thank you PeterMac ...
In two sentences , you gently reminded me to challenge myself on what it is I really believe about this case!
I initially ( many years ago) believed there had been no checking on the children and the apartment had been locked, hence the open window and shutters to allow for an abduction ( which in my opinion did not take place) . When this didnt seem to wash, it was then added the patio doors were unlocked, which I believed was added as an after thought to make the abduction story more believable.
Somewhere along the line, my initial instincts and beliefs have been influenced by 'spin' , confusion sets in and its good to go back every now and again and question what you think you believe.
Great Forum.
The facts are: MBM missing, no evidence of abduction. Dogs alert to cadaver and blood. T9 stories highly inconsistent. McCann behaviour over last 7 years combative and focused on controlling the media - consistent with something to hide.
End of facts. We should stop discussing '35 mins checking' or '...when MO did this' or 'JT did that...' Until we regain that discipline we are sadly doing CM's work for him...as of course they intended.
Not forgetting the twins being put back in the creche the next day or soon after. What parents of a supposedly "abducted" child would chance putting their other two children back amongst strangers who have only been known to them for 3 or 4 days, only parents of course who knew there was no abduction. That act confirmed in my own mind that there definitely was no abduction.
____________________
Laurie Levenson, Quoted in the Guardian ........
"Never trust an eyewitness whose memory gets better over time"
Newintown- Posts : 1597
Activity : 1622
Likes received : 2
Join date : 2011-07-19
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
A child doesn't just cry for neglect Swannie. And prolonged crying getting more desperate by the minute, as Mrs Fenn statement tells us makes me think that the child was in desperate state.Swannie wrote:But, if there was NO neglect, how come Mrs Fenn heard Madeleine crying for over an hour one night??
____________________
Not one more cent from me.
Nina- Posts : 2862
Activity : 3218
Likes received : 344
Join date : 2011-06-16
Age : 81
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
Oh well said prof Plum. Discipline is required.ProfessorPPlum wrote:Sorry to quote all but mobile and editing quotes becomes all but impossible on iPhone. Yes, totally agree with PeterMacs reminder there. Back to the basics: everything from the McCs is considered to be a falsehood. No abduction, then also no checking routine because no 'leaving children in locked/unlocked apartment'; no 'Mummy why didn't you come when...?" etc etc.Trust Your Instincts wrote:Thank you PeterMac ...
In two sentences , you gently reminded me to challenge myself on what it is I really believe about this case!
I initially ( many years ago) believed there had been no checking on the children and the apartment had been locked, hence the open window and shutters to allow for an abduction ( which in my opinion did not take place) . When this didnt seem to wash, it was then added the patio doors were unlocked, which I believed was added as an after thought to make the abduction story more believable.
Somewhere along the line, my initial instincts and beliefs have been influenced by 'spin' , confusion sets in and its good to go back every now and again and question what you think you believe.
Great Forum.
The facts are: MBM missing, no evidence of abduction. Dogs alert to cadaver and blood. T9 stories highly inconsistent. McCann behaviour over last 7 years combative and focused on controlling the media - consistent with something to hide.
End of facts. We should stop discussing '35 mins checking' or '...when MO did this' or 'JT did that...' Until we regain that discipline we are sadly doing CM's work for him...as of course they intended.
HelenMeg- Posts : 1782
Activity : 2081
Likes received : 213
Join date : 2014-01-08
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
After reading a post by MissWillYa, I've been reading about the Lindbergh baby. Makes very interesting reading. Makes the time gap between 1932 and 2007 look very small. Jaw hit the table several times. Smoke and mirrors to say the least. Peter Mac and PP are right, we need to go back to basics and filter out the noise created by those with another agenda.
Guest- Guest
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
chilli wrote: Smoke and mirrors to say the least. Peter Mac and PP are right, we need to go back to basics and filter out the noise created by those with another agenda.
The wild conspiracy theories are all good stuff for the McCanns, the wilder the better in the bigger picture. They provide them with a target rich environment to denigrate the plausibility of their detractors.
diatribe- Posts : 602
Activity : 608
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2013-11-15
Location : London
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
The facts are: MBM missing, no evidence of abduction. Dogs alert to cadaver and blood. T9 stories highly inconsistent. McCann behaviour over last 7 years combative and focused on controlling the media - consistent with something to hide.
End of facts. We should stop discussing '35 mins checking' or '...when MO did this' or 'JT did that...'
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A bit like “The process is like peeling back layers of an onion,”
End of facts. We should stop discussing '35 mins checking' or '...when MO did this' or 'JT did that...'
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A bit like “The process is like peeling back layers of an onion,”
jeanmonroe- Posts : 5818
Activity : 7756
Likes received : 1674
Join date : 2013-02-07
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
This is absolutely unbelievable when you think about it. There was a Police Women on Daybreak saying it is absolutely illegal and immoral to leave you kids in the car for even a few seconds as in breaks some 1930's law. Whether it is to go to a cash machine, pay for petrol or nip into the corner shop it is no, no, no all the way.
She even banged on about lots of abductions from cars. What abductions and are there really that many? Typical of the plod really, it is perfectly ok for two Doctors to leave kids and go out to be wined and dined every night but not for someone to take their eyes off their kids in a car for 30 secs.
I could have thrown the TV out the window listening to her dribble on. On one hand we have the police assuring us there are not gangs of sexual predators lurking around every corner (sorry TM), then they come up with this nonsense. Is there evidence to back up all these abducted children from parked cars?
I personal don't leave my 9 year old in the car, not because I fear he would get taken, I am more worried about him playing with the handbrake etc. Far more compelling argument not to do it.
She even banged on about lots of abductions from cars. What abductions and are there really that many? Typical of the plod really, it is perfectly ok for two Doctors to leave kids and go out to be wined and dined every night but not for someone to take their eyes off their kids in a car for 30 secs.
I could have thrown the TV out the window listening to her dribble on. On one hand we have the police assuring us there are not gangs of sexual predators lurking around every corner (sorry TM), then they come up with this nonsense. Is there evidence to back up all these abducted children from parked cars?
I personal don't leave my 9 year old in the car, not because I fear he would get taken, I am more worried about him playing with the handbrake etc. Far more compelling argument not to do it.
Pershing36- Posts : 674
Activity : 721
Likes received : 13
Join date : 2011-12-03
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
PeterMac wrote:Trust Your Instincts wrote:Jeanmonroe, my point exactly.
So many people are still unaware Madeleine and her younger siblings were left in an unlocked apartment, night after night, out of sight .
Or so the McCanns insist.
There is little evidence to support this., but for the abduction scenario it is important to insist on their own criminal and serial neglect.
I don't believe anything they say.
If they told me it was raining outside I'd have to check.
Halfwit- Posts : 87
Activity : 91
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-01-07
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
I would like to hear of any genuine proven cases of children taken from cars by strangers.
They are much more likely to come to grief by themselves as Pershing36 says. I remember a terrible case where a child set himself and the car on fire and couldn't be saved.
They are much more likely to come to grief by themselves as Pershing36 says. I remember a terrible case where a child set himself and the car on fire and couldn't be saved.
Guest- Guest
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
Very wise. Kate told us there were two hard gusts around 10pm which slammed the door and whooshed the curtains.Halfwit wrote:
I don't believe anything they say.
If they told me it was raining outside I'd have to check.
There were not.
Kate told you that the Last Photo was taken at lunchtime on 3rd, when it was sunny and hot.
It wasn't. It was cloudy and cold with a Force 4 wind.
And so on.
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
Sorry, but that made me laugh Pershing36. So true.Pershing36 wrote:This is absolutely unbelievable when you think about it. There was a Police Women on Daybreak saying it is absolutely illegal and immoral to leave you kids in the car for even a few seconds as in breaks some 1930's law. Whether it is to go to a cash machine, pay for petrol or nip into the corner shop it is no, no, no all the way.
She even banged on about lots of abductions from cars. What abductions and are there really that many? Typical of the plod really, it is perfectly ok for two Doctors to leave kids and go out to be wined and dined every night but not for someone to take their eyes off their kids in a car for 30 secs.
I could have thrown the TV out the window listening to her dribble on. On one hand we have the police assuring us there are not gangs of sexual predators lurking around every corner (sorry TM), then they come up with this nonsense. Is there evidence to back up all these abducted children from parked cars?
I personal don't leave my 9 year old in the car, not because I fear he would get taken, I am more worried about him playing with the handbrake etc. Far more compelling argument not to do it.
plebgate- Posts : 6729
Activity : 8938
Likes received : 2123
Join date : 2013-02-01
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
I too raised the comparison on a radio talk programme earlier this week. Glad to see other people have had similar thoughts; it should be raised properly. Laurence Fox apparently left his children in the car only briefly, to collect a medicine for another of his children. This hardly compares to three children under four being left night after night on their own, in a foreign country, in a locked / unlocked apartment. Yet he has been villified and they have not.
Searcher- Posts : 373
Activity : 404
Likes received : 21
Join date : 2013-07-25
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
My sulky young teenager quite often refuses to get out of the car. Why come to the shop and be seen in public with your mother, when you can sit in tbe car, turn the music up loud and play with your phone!
One day I nipped into Tesco in a fairly rough area and somehow he set the alarm off. Despite it being really busy in tne car park, the alarm blaring and the lights flashing, no one a) checked he was OK, b) checked he wasn't stealing the car or c) abducted him.
He was a bit red faced though and has been somewhat keener on shopping since.
One day I nipped into Tesco in a fairly rough area and somehow he set the alarm off. Despite it being really busy in tne car park, the alarm blaring and the lights flashing, no one a) checked he was OK, b) checked he wasn't stealing the car or c) abducted him.
He was a bit red faced though and has been somewhat keener on shopping since.
Guest- Guest
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
Well I suppose that leaving your children in your car at a Tescos Car Park is like leaving your children in your car in your garden. No different really.
Jemmied_Shatter- Posts : 67
Activity : 67
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-01-12
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
Even the fragrant LK said to her pal Aled....."we have all heard about children being left then taken haven't we,...." [ no names mentioned].
----------------------------------------------------------
Strangely this 'episode' of Daybreak, with LK 'comments' about 'children being left then taken' has been WHOOSHED/ABDUCTED!
ITV Daybreak Catch up, ...................Mon, Tues, WHOOSHED, Thu, Fri!
WHY do they even bother to do THAT?
Chances are, somebody has it all 'saved/recorded' for posterity, somewhere.
Weird, innit?
----------------------------------------------------------
Strangely this 'episode' of Daybreak, with LK 'comments' about 'children being left then taken' has been WHOOSHED/ABDUCTED!
ITV Daybreak Catch up, ...................Mon, Tues, WHOOSHED, Thu, Fri!
WHY do they even bother to do THAT?
Chances are, somebody has it all 'saved/recorded' for posterity, somewhere.
Weird, innit?
jeanmonroe- Posts : 5818
Activity : 7756
Likes received : 1674
Join date : 2013-02-07
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
I don't take that remark from the lovely Lorraine as being critical of her special friends.
She just means as I understand it that we all know that there are nasty strangers everywhere waiting to pounce on children momentarily left alone.
She just means as I understand it that we all know that there are nasty strangers everywhere waiting to pounce on children momentarily left alone.
Guest- Guest
Re: Mail Online Comments ..Kids left in car being compared to Madeleine being left in apartment
No Fate Worse Than De'Ath wrote:I don't take that remark from the lovely Lorraine as being critical of her special friends.
She just means as I understand it that we all know that there are nasty strangers everywhere waiting to pounce on children momentarily left alone.
"Catch up" replay episode still 'whooshed' though!
Must have been whooshed for something else that was said, on Wednesday's show, i suppose.
jeanmonroe- Posts : 5818
Activity : 7756
Likes received : 1674
Join date : 2013-02-07
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Latest News and Debate :: Debate Section - for purporting theories
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum