The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Welcome to 'The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann' forum 🌹

Please log in, or register to view all the forums as some of them are 'members only', then settle in and help us get to the truth about what really happened to Madeleine Beth McCann.

When you register please do NOT use your email address for a username because everyone will be able to see it!

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Mm11

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Regist10

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Page 23 of 24 Previous  1 ... 13 ... 22, 23, 24  Next

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Mainline on 13.03.19 0:16

"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
Mainline
Mainline

Posts : 111
Join date : 2018-10-01

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 13.03.19 0:55

@Mainline wrote:"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
So you don't know what his current opinion is, the question asked was who has information or evidence that he is not sticking by the Thursday death, do you have that per chance?
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Mainline on 13.03.19 0:58

HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
So you don't know what his current opinion is, the question asked was who has information or evidence that he is not sticking by the Thursday death, do you have that per chance?

Noone knows how he currently thinks, or if they do, they can't step forward because for legal reasons he can't be blunt. Personally I have no idea, so in my case your question is inane and irrelevant (not saying that's your normal contribution, just in relation to me).
Mainline
Mainline

Posts : 111
Join date : 2018-10-01

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 13.03.19 1:00

@Jill Havern wrote:
HKP wrote:
@Jill Havern wrote:Indeed aquila, and why, when Dr Amaral finished writing his book two years ago, is he still waiting for the right time to publish it if was just going to be more of the same for which he's already been to court? Surely it's because he's got something more to add to his original book now that many years have passed?
All guesswork Jill, anything a bit more tangible than just what your thoughts are?
It's not guesswork actually.

Dr Amaral has received all our research as has Paulo Reis and the Portuguese Attorney-General and Operation Grange. I know Dr Amaral is in direct communication with Paulo Reis and PeterMac who, as we know, has researched this case and concluded that Madeleine died on the Sunday...as have others who have researched from various angles but reached the same conclusion.

Why is it so difficult for you all to assume Dr Amaral, who is highly intelligent, is still stuck in 2007 when the case has moved on significantly?
Or, why is it so difficult for you or anybody to provide some information that he has come to the conclusion she died earlier. Providing him with evidence/theories/information doesn't mean he accepts that this is the right answer
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 13.03.19 1:03

@Mainline wrote:
HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
So you don't know what his current opinion is, the question asked was who has information or evidence that he is not sticking by the Thursday death, do you have that per chance?

Noone knows how he currently thinks, or if they do, they can't step forward because for legal reasons he can't be blunt. Personally I have no idea, so in my case your question is inane and irrelevant (not saying that's your normal contribution, just in relation to me).
Thank you for confirming you have no idea
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Mainline on 13.03.19 1:07

HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:
HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
So you don't know what his current opinion is, the question asked was who has information or evidence that he is not sticking by the Thursday death, do you have that per chance?

Noone knows how he currently thinks, or if they do, they can't step forward because for legal reasons he can't be blunt. Personally I have no idea, so in my case your question is inane and irrelevant (not saying that's your normal contribution, just in relation to me).
Thank you for confirming you have no idea

Thanks for providing no semblance of rebuttal and proving my contributions are based on opinion not gang mentality  roses
Mainline
Mainline

Posts : 111
Join date : 2018-10-01

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 13.03.19 1:10

@Mainline wrote:
HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:
HKP wrote:
@Mainline wrote:"Guesswork"

Have you gone to the lengths of contacting publishers Guerra e Paz? Several of us did. If you're unaware of such efforts then I encourage you to redouble and contact them yourself.

Goncalo Amaral was not a top detective for sticking to one theory with an obsequious bent. Demonstrably from his own words, he never had a one track mind. I don't pretend to know what his current opinion is - whatever it is will be vastly more informed than my own. But I do recognise that a senior detective, even after leaving his employ, does not live in an echo chamber. Not one person among us can speak for him, aside from Paulo who actually (regularly) assorts with Dr Amaral.
So you don't know what his current opinion is, the question asked was who has information or evidence that he is not sticking by the Thursday death, do you have that per chance?

Noone knows how he currently thinks, or if they do, they can't step forward because for legal reasons he can't be blunt. Personally I have no idea, so in my case your question is inane and irrelevant (not saying that's your normal contribution, just in relation to me).
Thank you for confirming you have no idea

Thanks for providing no semblance of rebuttal and proving my contributions are based on opinion not gang mentality  roses
My pleasure
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Dannz on 13.03.19 1:19

HKP wrote:On post #509 of this thread was a very good question which then raised an absurd retort but Pheobe's question remains, who was the (only) girl in the creche group on Thursday afternoon if it wasn't Maddie? 
 
HKP - I think JimbobJones’ point may perhaps have been that it is only assumed that there was a girl in the crèche at that time. The only evidence there was is crèche records, Catriona Baker and the McCanns. None of those are considered credible. Richard Hall suggests that Maddie was signed in but no one was actually dropped off. 

Phoebe’s other point was why remove other girls when it would only highlight Madeleine’s absence. The answer is perhaps that other parents would not notice and Cat and her supervisor were involved in the cover up.  Cat supposedly had a close relationship with the McCanns - they shared meals together (children’s. teas) and Cat was Facebook Friends since 2006 with the daughter of Madeleine’s godfather (and we don’t know how many others). 

Richard Hall tells us that the McCanns had lunch in their apartment to keep Madeleine’s absence concealed from the Tapas 7 - apparently up to 3 May. I get confused as to why the McCanns then included the T7 on 3 May rather than go for a simpler story of Madeleine being taken at the beach. In any event Cat Baker must have been more highly trusted than the T7. I’m not sure how many childrens’ teas the McCanns attended - was it only the one on the Sunday? However many, there was evidently very strong bonding. I’m not sure how the supervisor fits in, or if Cat without any girl attended the tea on Thursday. However, if following this theory, IMO it is likely that the other childminders were part of it too as they might have said something otherwise. Ms Romao and others would also need to be included as it would be a risk that they might also notice. 

So there was no little girl in the crèche group on Thursday. There was no need as all relevant people were part of it (except the T7 until Thursday after lunch).  Does that make it clearer?
Dannz
Dannz

Posts : 85
Join date : 2019-02-23

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Phoebe on 13.03.19 2:00

Where I run into problems with death on Sunday is when I consider the enormous unnecessary risks the whole group would have to have been running in trying to pretend Madeleine was there all week when she wasn't.
 I can't believe ALL the nannies, tennis coaches and sailing coaches could have been party to this deception. All it would have taken was any of these to ask the children their names so they could address them by name - in a game or coaching session say - and the game would have been up!!
 I also cannot believe the Tapas 9 could have behaved normally, played tennis, gone to and from the creche, taken the children to the playground, breakfasted in the Millenium, dined each night, enjoyed socialising in the Tapas Bar etc. with sang froid, all the while knowing they were covering up such a crime.
I cannot understand why they took all the kids to the beach on the very afternoon of the day Madeleine was to go missing. They must have known that the police would home in on that last day and afternoon, yet they removed all their kids, leaving Madeleine supposedly alone in the creche. It just doesn't ring true to me, try as I may.
avatar
Phoebe

Posts : 1367
Join date : 2017-03-01

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 13.03.19 9:53

@Dannz wrote:
HKP wrote:On post #509 of this thread was a very good question which then raised an absurd retort but Pheobe's question remains, who was the (only) girl in the creche group on Thursday afternoon if it wasn't Maddie? 
 
HKP - I think JimbobJones’ point may perhaps have been that it is only assumed that there was a girl in the crèche at that time. The only evidence there was is crèche records, Catriona Baker and the McCanns. None of those are considered credible. Richard Hall suggests that Maddie was signed in but no one was actually dropped off. 

Phoebe’s other point was why remove other girls when it would only highlight Madeleine’s absence. The answer is perhaps that other parents would not notice and Cat and her supervisor were involved in the cover up.  Cat supposedly had a close relationship with the McCanns - they shared meals together (children’s. teas) and Cat was Facebook Friends since 2006 with the daughter of Madeleine’s godfather (and we don’t know how many others). 

Richard Hall tells us that the McCanns had lunch in their apartment to keep Madeleine’s absence concealed from the Tapas 7 - apparently up to 3 May. I get confused as to why the McCanns then included the T7 on 3 May rather than go for a simpler story of Madeleine being taken at the beach. In any event Cat Baker must have been more highly trusted than the T7. I’m not sure how many childrens’ teas the McCanns attended - was it only the one on the Sunday? However many, there was evidently very strong bonding. I’m not sure how the supervisor fits in, or if Cat without any girl attended the tea on Thursday. However, if following this theory, IMO it is likely that the other childminders were part of it too as they might have said something otherwise. Ms Romao and others would also need to be included as it would be a risk that they might also notice. 

So there was no little girl in the crèche group on Thursday. There was no need as all relevant people were part of it (except the T7 until Thursday after lunch).  Does that make it clearer?
Thanks Dannz, I am aware of Richard D Hall's take on it and of the crèche records validity. Whilst the specific question was about Thursday the principle applies to every day past Sunday. With it being a holiday club with young 'nannies' who were there temporarily I don't think that it's to be unexpected that the records are not 100% accurate, you'd do it yourself if someone forgot to sign there child out but you had seen/spoken to them on their way out (sign them out). I'd at least expect them (nannies) to be aware of who was there and who was not, in particular those kids in your group. There are too many people saying Madeleine was around (from Sunday) for them all to be mistaken/lying/covering up. The investigation team at the time were comfortable with something happening on Thursday and also that some of the independent witnesses had seen her that week (after Sunday). The first port of call for the investigation is usually who outside the family/group (independent witness) saw her last then verifying that's a true and accurate fact. The PJ were not stupid, they rapidly worked out no abduction, Tannerman was false and the behaviours pointed to some sort of cover up. 



With a group of kids in your charge you need to know their names and you would call them by that on frequent occasions (or you may ask/reaffirm on several occasions), if you were wrong about their name they'll tell you! Being mixed up with another of the Tapas group's kids has to be a non starter (kids of that age in general run to their parents at pickup point). That leaves signing in but not attending, they'd be relying on people lying and taking that to their grave with them, not a risk to be taken lightly especially when it turns out to be the world's most famous missing person case (those in the know would have to be kept to the bare minimum).
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Guest on 10.04.19 17:50

@Phoebe wrote:Where I run into problems with death on Sunday is when I consider the enormous unnecessary risks the whole group would have to have been running in trying to pretend Madeleine was there all week when she wasn't.
 I can't believe ALL the nannies, tennis coaches and sailing coaches could have been party to this deception. All it would have taken was any of these to ask the children their names so they could address them by name - in a game or coaching session say - and the game would have been up!!
 I also cannot believe the Tapas 9 could have behaved normally, played tennis, gone to and from the creche, taken the children to the playground, breakfasted in the Millenium, dined each night, enjoyed socialising in the Tapas Bar etc. with sang froid, all the while knowing they were covering up such a crime.
I cannot understand why they took all the kids to the beach on the very afternoon of the day Madeleine was to go missing. They must have known that the police would home in on that last day and afternoon, yet they removed all their kids, leaving Madeleine supposedly alone in the creche. It just doesn't ring true to me, try as I may.

I have the same problem. There are just too many unmanageables for that to have been possible let alone workable.  I've always felt that the night of Tuesday 1st (the night Mrs Fenn heard prolonged crying from 5A) was the night something happened and that the subterfuge began from that point.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by charyoung on 11.06.19 10:31

@Jill Havern wrote:
I believe Neil Berry's daughter Jessica's (Madeleine's little friend) account of Madeleine jumping into the water on the mini sail for Jessica's straw sun hat. That puts Madeleine alive on Thursday and also  sea air may account for some of Madeleine's tiredness.

Lizzy Hideho Taylor
to
‎HiDeHo CONTROVERSY of Madeleine McCann
23 hrs ·

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Mbm10

I CHALLENGE anyone to find a statement that could be considered PROOF that Madeleine was alive during the week... Was Madeleine seen after SUNDAY?

I did not come to the conclusion that something may have happened to her earlier in the week on a whim... I discovered some MAJOR discrepancies started happening on Tuesday and researched all the statements to try to pinpoint the day she was last seen... SUNDAY LUNCHTIME!

I have TWO VERY LONG threads collating some of the research. I don't 'guess' I worked hard to try to find ANYTHING that I considered proof... In 6 years or more, I have NEVER found anything...

Note: It doesn't mean she wasn't seen, but there is nothing to prove she was!

1) Title: People that saw Madeleine during the holiday
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/WELCOME-to-HDH-Controversy-Info/People-that-saw-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344234.html

2) Title: Did ANYONE see Madeleine during the holiday?
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/category/Did-ANYONE-see-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344239.html

https://www.facebook.com/groups/HiDeHoCONTROVERSYofMadeleineMcCann/permalink/527143374108823/
avatar
charyoung

Posts : 7
Join date : 2018-01-04

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Verdi on 11.06.19 11:59

charyoung,

I'm not sure why you've quoted a couple of previous posts without commentary.

Do you have anything to add?

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 15406
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by PeterMac on 11.06.19 16:07

I believe Neil Berry's daughter Jessica's (Madeleine's little friend) account of Madeleine jumping into the water on the mini sail for Jessica's straw sun hat. That puts Madeleine alive on Thursday and also sea air may account for some of Madeleine's tiredness.

I think that reliance on the Creche activity sheet and the creche records may be a 'belief too far.'
Here they are for comparison.

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Lobste10
Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Lobste11
Assuming that Mini-sail did take place on Thursday 3rd, in the 30 minutes allocated  [their figures, not mine] which must included schlepping all 6 children down to the beach, changing into wet suits and life jackets, launching, sailing – in a Force 4 because we remember there was an International Windsurfing Competition at Portimão – landing, beaching the craft, changing and returning to the creche, 
and THEN, after lunch, taking the 3 surviving children to the pool for diving at 3.30pm. [ From the creche sheets it is clear that one did not make it back after the morning session, and is presumed "missing'. ]
At 3.30pm William T is booked in at the creche, where one assumes everyone else wasn't.  which may explain why he wasn't signed in
though oddly he is signed Out at some unspecified time, by some unspecified person, 
and we note Ella signed out at 4.30, for fun and ice-creams and dancing with the entire Tapas gang and all the children at the Paraiso – except Madeleine who was left on her own . . .



Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Windsu10

Have I missed anything ?

____________________

PeterMac
PeterMac
Investigator

Posts : 11131
Join date : 2010-12-06

http://whatreallyhappenedtomadeleinemccann.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Verdi on 12.06.19 1:38

Apart from anything else, the daily childcare activities would be very dependent of weather conditions.

They're hardly likely to take the children to the kiddies pool in freezing slashing rain or mini tennis in a snow storm. Same would apply to the outdoor high tea at the Tapas bar - rain stop play.

It was late April early May on the Algarve, not Florida in midsummer - even that can be very unpredictable. If no kids are at the childcare facilities then it could be safely concluded that the days activities would be cancelled.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 15406
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by PeterMac on 12.06.19 8:31

Exactly.
The creche Activity Sheet is generic, not specific to the McCanns' week.
Is it likely that children would be chucked into the pool – which on the McCann's own admission caused Kate serious hypothermia after a few minutes – in Late April, when earlier that same day they had been cast adrift on the Open Atlantic in a Force 4 stiff breeze, and Madeleine had already thrown herself in to retrieve a straw hat . . . ?

The weather was pleasant enough, although there was a cool breeze. It was still April, after all. As I am one of those people who really feel the cold . . . when Madeleine immediately wanted me to go swimming with her, I was not exactly keen. But she was so excited about the pool. I took one look at her eager little face and went off to put on my costume. The water was absolutely freezing, but Madeleine was straight in there, even if her voice disappeared for a second or two with the shock of it. ‘Come on, Mummy!’ she called when she’d got her breath back. I tentatively inched my way in. ‘The things you do for your kids!’ I remember commenting to a dad lying on a sun-lounger with his two sons nearby, watching us. I told Madeleine to count to three and steeled myself. It was worth it – it will always be worth it – just to see her delight. Even if it did take us both the best part of three hours to warm up afterwards.
  We were still shivering when we went off to a ‘welcome’ meeting with the Mark Warner team, who outlined the facilities and events on offer.

There is, of course, no particular reason why we should believe any of this ! It is only "A Version" of the truth.  There are clearly other "versions" available.

____________________

PeterMac
PeterMac
Investigator

Posts : 11131
Join date : 2010-12-06

http://whatreallyhappenedtomadeleinemccann.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by skyrocket on 12.06.19 8:55

Just for the record there was an indoor pool, which must have been used for the kid's club as the the pool sessions are shown as progressing through the week to 'dive and find' on the Thursday afternoon. The pool is at the far end of the main reception block - it can be seen with a partial glass roof on Google Earth. Having said that, I am equally sceptical about the activity timetable. It has always puzzled me why there is no mention in statements about use of the pool - early season you'd have expected families to be using it regularly.


IMO, the creche sheets are largely fictitious. And, whilst we're on the subject I'd just like to make another point regarding the sheets:
Having worked with children within the modern confines of health and safety AND data protection, the creche sheets make no sense. Parents would have filled in a sheet for each child with essential information. These sheets would have included parental details and mobile numbers and would have been on hand at all times for emergencies but out of view (most likely in a clip file carried with the nanny at all times). The third column of the creche sheets asks for 'parent's location' not parent's 'mobile number', which most people wouldn't want lying around in full view. If parents were unsure of their plans they had the option of simply writing 'mobile', as can be seen in a few places on the sheets. If we look at the Jellyfish/Toddler 2 records, the system seems to have been used correctly most of the time by parents - except of course, by the McCanns who consistently record their mobile numbers. Interestingly, on 4 May not one mobile number is recorded. If we examine the Mini Club/Lobster sheets we see that 5 out of the 7 parents (including the McCanns) consistently record their mobile numbers in full view - the Manns and Patels are the exceptions. Also, if the sheets are genuine and both a.m. and p.m. Lobster sessions were recorded on a single sheet - why on earth would anyone (never mind several) supposedly intelligent people not simple write 'above/as above' instead repeating their mobile numbers when registering their children for the afternoon session? The creche sheets (particularly the Lobster's) seem way to contrived for me (apart from all the other anomalies).
skyrocket
skyrocket

Posts : 755
Join date : 2015-06-18

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by PeterMac on 12.06.19 9:29

And again a comment stimulates another interesting question.

Were the nannys 'authorised' to undress the 3 and 4 and 5 year old children - in a mixed group - and then strip them after swimming and dry them thoroughly before dressing them again – without parental or other supervision ?

____________________

PeterMac
PeterMac
Investigator

Posts : 11131
Join date : 2010-12-06

http://whatreallyhappenedtomadeleinemccann.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Verdi on 12.06.19 12:56

The Ocean Club, Praia da Luz is a third rate holiday destination for cattle class - the package tour industry.  The facilities were in place for parents to dump their kids for a few hours whilst they went off to do their own thing.

The tour operator/proprietor has an obligation for overall elf 'n safety, if something goes wrong then the proverbial hits the fan.  Otherwise they just jog along day by day, doing a bit and dodging a bit.

Children are the responsibility of their parents or guardians.

It's not on a parallel with Busy Bees childcare dot UK.

Don't overplay this.

____________________
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi
Verdi
Moderator/Researcher
Moderator/Researcher

Posts : 15406
Join date : 2015-02-02

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by NickE on 13.06.19 20:36

@PeterMac wrote:I believe Neil Berry's daughter Jessica's (Madeleine's little friend) account of Madeleine jumping into the water on the mini sail for Jessica's straw sun hat. That puts Madeleine alive on Thursday and also sea air may account for some of Madeleine's tiredness.

I think that reliance on the Creche activity sheet and the creche records may be a 'belief too far.'
Here they are for comparison.

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Lobste10
Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Lobste11
Assuming that Mini-sail did take place on Thursday 3rd, in the 30 minutes allocated  [their figures, not mine] which must included schlepping all 6 children down to the beach, changing into wet suits and life jackets, launching, sailing – in a Force 4 because we remember there was an International Windsurfing Competition at Portimão – landing, beaching the craft, changing and returning to the creche, 
and THEN, after lunch, taking the 3 surviving children to the pool for diving at 3.30pm. [ From the creche sheets it is clear that one did not make it back after the morning session, and is presumed "missing'. ]
At 3.30pm William T is booked in at the creche, where one assumes everyone else wasn't.  which may explain why he wasn't signed in
though oddly he is signed Out at some unspecified time, by some unspecified person, 

and we note Ella signed out at 4.30, for fun and ice-creams and dancing with the entire Tapas gang and all the children at the Paraiso – except Madeleine who was left on her own . . .



Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Windsu10

Have I missed anything ?
(William T is Tannerman's....erm..Dr Totman's boy.)

____________________
Goncalo Amaral: "Then there's the window we found Kate's finger prints.
She said she had never touched that window and the cleaning lady assured that she had cleaned it on the previous day....it doesn't add up"
NickE
NickE

Posts : 1403
Join date : 2013-10-27
Age : 44

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Hobs on 14.06.19 3:40

@PeterMac wrote:And again a comment stimulates another interesting question.

Were the nannys 'authorised' to undress the 3 and 4 and 5 year old children - in a mixed group - and then strip them after swimming and dry them thoroughly before dressing them again – without parental or other supervision ?


Maybe payne offered to help??


I'll take myself off to the naughty corner bignono

____________________
The little unremembered acts of kindness and love are the best parts of a person's life.
Hobs
Hobs
Researcher/Analyst

Posts : 1049
Join date : 2012-10-20
Age : 55
Location : uk

http://tania-cadogan.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by happybiscuit on 06.08.19 18:33

@Jill Havern wrote:
Lizzy Hideho Taylor
to
‎HiDeHo CONTROVERSY of Madeleine McCann
23 hrs ·

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Mbm10

I CHALLENGE anyone to find a statement that could be considered PROOF that Madeleine was alive during the week... Was Madeleine seen after SUNDAY?

I did not come to the conclusion that something may have happened to her earlier in the week on a whim... I discovered some MAJOR discrepancies started happening on Tuesday and researched all the statements to try to pinpoint the day she was last seen... SUNDAY LUNCHTIME!

I have TWO VERY LONG threads collating some of the research. I don't 'guess' I worked hard to try to find ANYTHING that I considered proof... In 6 years or more, I have NEVER found anything...

Note: It doesn't mean she wasn't seen, but there is nothing to prove she was!

1) Title: People that saw Madeleine during the holiday
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/WELCOME-to-HDH-Controversy-Info/People-that-saw-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344234.html

2) Title: Did ANYONE see Madeleine during the holiday?
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/category/Did-ANYONE-see-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344239.html

https://www.facebook.com/groups/HiDeHoCONTROVERSYofMadeleineMcCann/permalink/527143374108823/
What I find odd is that the McCann's friends (tapas 7) and their children saw so little of Madeleine during the week, considering that they were there on holiday together. When did each member of tapas 7 actually see Madeliene last? What do they claim?
happybiscuit
happybiscuit

Posts : 1
Join date : 2019-08-06

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by sharonl on 06.08.19 19:45

@happybiscuit wrote:
@Jill Havern wrote:
Lizzy Hideho Taylor
to
‎HiDeHo CONTROVERSY of Madeleine McCann
23 hrs ·

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Mbm10

I CHALLENGE anyone to find a statement that could be considered PROOF that Madeleine was alive during the week... Was Madeleine seen after SUNDAY?

I did not come to the conclusion that something may have happened to her earlier in the week on a whim... I discovered some MAJOR discrepancies started happening on Tuesday and researched all the statements to try to pinpoint the day she was last seen... SUNDAY LUNCHTIME!

I have TWO VERY LONG threads collating some of the research. I don't 'guess' I worked hard to try to find ANYTHING that I considered proof... In 6 years or more, I have NEVER found anything...

Note: It doesn't mean she wasn't seen, but there is nothing to prove she was!

1) Title: People that saw Madeleine during the holiday
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/WELCOME-to-HDH-Controversy-Info/People-that-saw-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344234.html

2) Title: Did ANYONE see Madeleine during the holiday?
http://forum4.aimoo.com/madeleinemccanncontroversy/category/Did-ANYONE-see-Madeleine-during-the-holiday-1-2344239.html

https://www.facebook.com/groups/HiDeHoCONTROVERSYofMadeleineMcCann/permalink/527143374108823/
What I find odd is that the McCann's friends (tapas 7) and their children saw so little of Madeleine during the week, considering that they were there on holiday together. When did each member of tapas 7 actually see Madeliene last? What do they claim?

Excellent question.

You would expect stories from the friends saying what the kids, including Madeleine got up that week.  

There was also the trip to the beach which Madeleine missed because she was, allegedly, in crèche.  You would think that, if the party were taking the kids out of crèche to go to the beach Kate and Gerry would have known about it and joined them.  Even if they didn't, would the friends have asked their permission to take Madeleine?.

____________________
"WE ARE ALL IN THIS TOGETHER" - Rebekah Brooks to David Cameron
sharonl
sharonl
Co-Admin
Co-Admin

Posts : 6695
Join date : 2009-12-29

http://www.cold2012.org.uk

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by Blackpied on 06.08.19 20:05

Happy biscuit you will never find evidence of Madeleine after sat/sun
because she was no more ,gone forever,all to save certain peoples 
character and a high flying job.
Madeleine was betrayed by politicians and high up police etc,ordinary
cops and top cops know they are being made to look like idiots but alas
none of them have the guts to come clean.
Blackpied
Blackpied

Posts : 71
Join date : 2018-10-29

Back to top Go down

Was Madeleine seen after Sunday? - Page 23 Empty Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?

Post by sharonl on 06.08.19 20:32

Neither will you find out what the group were doing on Sunday.  Even in one of Jane Tanners interviews with Leics Police she is questioned about the holiday but the interviewer says words to the effect of, "no point in discussing this, we will just skim over Sunday".  

I would need to find the link to be more certain of what was said, but it was along those lines.

____________________
"WE ARE ALL IN THIS TOGETHER" - Rebekah Brooks to David Cameron
sharonl
sharonl
Co-Admin
Co-Admin

Posts : 6695
Join date : 2009-12-29

http://www.cold2012.org.uk

Back to top Go down

Page 23 of 24 Previous  1 ... 13 ... 22, 23, 24  Next

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum