Is Blacksmith GA?

by personofinterest 10.10.13 15:49

Hi all

Long (very long) time passive observer here and on various other sites (including 3As and the Mirror forum). Finally registered today to allow me to post.

Please see the latest from Blacksmith here:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

The author of the post appears to be outing himself as someone very close to proceedings in Portugal. I wonder whether his initials are GA?

by Guest 10.10.13 16:02

Interesting

PS
No no no: its Desmond

by jeanmonroe 10.10.13 16:13

personofinterest wrote:Hi all

Long (very long) time passive observer here and on various other sites (including 3As and the Mirror forum). Finally registered today to allow me to post.

Please see the latest from Blacksmith here:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

The author of the post appears to be outing himself as someone very close to proceedings in Portugal. I wonder whether his initials are GA?

Welcome .

So what do you think happened to Madeleine?

ALL 'theories, mysterys, explanations' welcome but probably best to stick to 'Occam's razor' as a starting point!

"We consider it a good principle to explain the phenomena by the simplest hypothesis possible"

big grin

by personofinterest 10.10.13 16:21

jeanmonroe wrote:
personofinterest wrote:Hi all

Long (very long) time passive observer here and on various other sites (including 3As and the Mirror forum). Finally registered today to allow me to post.

Please see the latest from Blacksmith here:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

The author of the post appears to be outing himself as someone very close to proceedings in Portugal. I wonder whether his initials are GA?
Welcome .

So what do you think happened to Madeleine?

ALL 'theories, mysterys, explanations' welcome but probably best to stick to 'Occam's razor' as a starting point!

Thanks for the welcome. I believe that poor Maddie died in the apartment and then her body was disposed of by those who should have been looking after her. I have for years resolutely refused to believe that there is a conspiracy of the great and the good protecting them (it just seemed too far fetched to me). However, the SY stance (i.e. SY's apparent refusal to contemplate the Occam's razor scenario) is making me question my prior beliefs.

by sweetex 10.10.13 18:55

Interesting that he says he was going to testify...never thought he was THAT close to the investigation.

But I don't think it is GA. With all respect.... I just don't think that is his writing style?

by Guest 10.10.13 19:10

Anyone of us know GA to be able to speak english?

No?

Thought not

So lets cut the crap

by Guest 10.10.13 19:37

An English speaker, expected to give evidence but didn't.

You, John Blacksmith, are Ma Healy.

I claim my five pounds big grin

by Guest 10.10.13 19:45

If the Bard were alive today
He would be Him, dear John of deep profoundest Memories; Oh wait and Hail to thee, Blithe Spirit,

But sadly dead
He, perforce

Disabled & uncouth
unpresent and unseeing; blind, blinded and blindest still,

He must himself profess
not with us,

but symphetic, that, at least

let us rejoice
for Bardest sake!

PS
and now, all those of us who think Shakespeare was just a bunch of rot,
instead of a model of thinking clearly and poetically;

Kiss Thee Good Night!

by stillsloppingout 10.10.13 20:50

Blacksmith has just posted again and leaves with a rhetorical question . could the answer be presented here , and its meaning discussed

by AndyB 10.10.13 21:00

As I'm a relative newcomer I lack the intimate knowledge of the documentation necessary to understand what this paragraph means. Can someone please explain what he's suggesting?

Blacksmith wrote:Why do you think that Mr Menezes and his colleague changed the meaning of the PJ report by taking its climax and conclusion – the reconstruction section – and replacing it with a B-Movie I love Kate paragraph while shifting the recon. section several pages back so that it became a subsidiary finding, not a critical conclusion. Answers on a postcard?

by stillsloppingout 10.10.13 21:24

AndyB wrote:As I'm a relative newcomer I lack the intimate knowledge of the documentation necessary to understand what this paragraph means. Can someone please explain what he's suggesting?

Blacksmith wrote:Why do you think that Mr Menezes and his colleague changed the meaning of the PJ report by taking its climax and conclusion – the reconstruction section – and replacing it with a B-Movie I love Kate paragraph while shifting the recon. section several pages back so that it became a subsidiary finding, not a critical conclusion. Answers on a postcard?

Thats the devil , im rubbish at that cut and pasting stuff. !!!

by russiandoll 10.10.13 21:47

Love the bit about PedromacSilva. Also easy, due to the writing style, to suss out who from the coven is posting on Justice. I find it interesting from a linguistic point of view.

I have to smile at how sad it is really, trying to pretend to be a foreigner writing in broken English. Pedro is like a Portuguese Manuel from Fawlty Towers.

Await BS jokes about crazytony all the way from the good ole U S of A soon.

big grin