Investigator ensures that Maddie's body in the backyard of Murat

ShuBob wrote:

Woofer wrote:So how would the `planter` of Maddie`s DNA managed to have got hold of it before placing it in the car?

By stealing Maddie's sandals and the twins' soiled nappies of course. How else? :sigh:

uppatoffee wrote:Well, well what a surprise. We said that it would all come back around the time of the trial. I am just surprised that Mr Birch has come out in support of the McCanns after all. He certainly did not give the impression he believed them in his previous interviews. Perhaps he has had a little phone call from CR in the interim period which has focused his opinions somewhat.

I am interested to hear how Mr Birch thinks that the Portuguese police planted the various blood spots and DNA evidence. In particular I would love to know how they managed to only plant cadaver odour in McCann locations. Quite an impressive feat. Or were these all false alerts as Kate suggested?

Jean wrote:http://www.linkedin.com/pub/stephen-birch/11/6ab/701

I think that it will surprise everyone to learn that Mr Birch has been "acknowledged worldwide" for solving this case.

aiyoyo wrote:

Stephen Birch guarantees that the girl is buried at Robert Murat’s home

At most what he can guarantee, one would have thought, is that there is something interned there.
How could he possibly guarantee it was Madeleine unless he's inside information.
No wonder no authority is taking him seriously.
He can bark about it to every authority but on one will waste time and resources unless he produces substantive evidence how he guarantees it was Madeleine.

Jean wrote:http://www.linkedin.com/pub/stephen-birch/11/6ab/701

I think that it will surprise everyone to learn that Mr Birch has been "acknowledged worldwide" for solving this case.

ProfessorPPlum wrote:Agree, Russiandoll.

I have no time for people who come up with theories but are so precious about them they can't or won't share them. First of all, it's never in the interest of justice, it's always coloured by their need for fame, approval or some other kind of pay-off. Stephen Birch has to have an explanation for why he claims Madeleine's body is there but I suspect he doesn't share it because doing so would immediately end his brief moment of fame. He can only remain in the picture so long as he doesn't lay bare his reasoning because it would pretty quickly be taken apart assuming it was b****ks.

I have the same reaction to @Oddityfinder on Twitter who claims to have a picture of Madeleine's body although she never actually says that (it's all part of manipulating the 'mystery') in the Rocha Negra cliffs - but will never show it. She's a retired artist, living in the UK and is an active 'UFO spotter' (by her own account). That, for me, just about says it all.

aiyoyo wrote:

ProfessorPPlum wrote:Agree, Russiandoll.

I have no time for people who come up with theories but are so precious about them they can't or won't share them. First of all, it's never in the interest of justice, it's always coloured by their need for fame, approval or some other kind of pay-off. Stephen Birch has to have an explanation for why he claims Madeleine's body is there but I suspect he doesn't share it because doing so would immediately end his brief moment of fame. He can only remain in the picture so long as he doesn't lay bare his reasoning because it would pretty quickly be taken apart assuming it was b****ks.

I have the same reaction to @Oddityfinder on Twitter who claims to have a picture of Madeleine's body although she never actually says that (it's all part of manipulating the 'mystery') in the Rocha Negra cliffs - but will never show it. She's a retired artist, living in the UK and is an active 'UFO spotter' (by her own account). That, for me, just about says it all.

LOL. Perhaps she is suggesting Maddie was UFO abducted!

Jean wrote:If I understand this correctly, Mr Birch is sure that Madeleine died on 3rd May (after falling over the back of the sofa) and was buried the same day in the Murats' garden.

Yet he doesn't think the McCanns had anything to do with either event and they were framed with the later DNA evidence?

I'm just going to lie down in my darkened room......

Portia wrote:

aiyoyo wrote:

Stephen Birch guarantees that the girl is buried at Robert Murat’s home

At most what he can guarantee, one would have thought, is that there is something interned there.
How could he possibly guarantee it was Madeleine unless he's inside information.
No wonder no authority is taking him seriously.
He can bark about it to every authority but on one will waste time and resources unless he produces substantive evidence how he guarantees it was Madeleine.

Loony bin territory, as far as I'm concerned

bobbin wrote:

Jean wrote:If I understand this correctly, Mr Birch is sure that Madeleine died on 3rd May (after falling over the back of the sofa) and was buried the same day in the Murats' garden.

Yet he doesn't think the McCanns had anything to do with either event and they were framed with the later DNA evidence?

I'm just going to lie down in my darkened room......

I love your succinct summary. It would go down so well in a crowded court room.

I listened to the entire discussion and heard Mr Birch say his theory is that the Tapas 9 all pointed at Murat,[ the patsy though this word was not used] wanted the body found so that Murat would be charged and the case closed..

jd wrote:

I listened to the entire discussion and heard Mr Birch say his theory is that the Tapas 9 all pointed at Murat,[ the patsy though this word was not used] wanted the body found so that Murat would be charged and the case closed..

Imo, this is exactly what they wanted and tried to do in 2007. They wanted the same result as Soham, murat charged case closed. Symingtons would have been very happy too. But the 'story' magnified to levels nobody expected and murat fought back with the Smith sighting