Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Madeleine Beth McCann :: McCann Case: The most important areas of research
Page 19 of 24 • Share
Page 19 of 24 • 1 ... 11 ... 18, 19, 20 ... 24
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
[size=13]John Major and the Symington family
[/size]by Get'emGonçalo in The Gagged Section
Not sure if that will link you but if you put John Major and the Symington family in the search box if should take you there
dottyaussie- Posts : 161
Activity : 337
Likes received : 170
Join date : 2016-02-25
Location : NorthWest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Thank you this got me there
____________________
“Basically, I’m just an ordinary, straightforward guy who’s the victim of the biggest f***-up on this planet – if you’ll excuse the language.”
Robert Murat talking to David Jones, Daily Mail, 02 June 2007
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-459316/Madeleine-Is-Robert-Murat-suspect-scapegoat.html
MayMuse- Posts : 2033
Activity : 3472
Likes received : 1413
Join date : 2016-04-15
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Haha well I had no idea what I was doing so I think I just performed a technical miracle
dottyaussie- Posts : 161
Activity : 337
Likes received : 170
Join date : 2016-02-25
Location : NorthWest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
If you scroll down the forum you'll find a whole section of FOI's.MayMuse wrote:@dottyaussie Thank you, I have keyed in search but nothing comes up & for the FOI...where can I find the links to it would you know?dottyaussie wrote:@MayMuse have a look at this thread John Major and the Symington Family. It talks about who is related to who including Murat and how people are involved
I've just read it and all I can say is WOW!!
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
CMOMM & MMRG Blog
A wise man once said: "Be careful who you let on your ship, because some people will sink the whole ship just because they can't be The Captain."
Jill Havern- The Captain (& Chief Faffer)
- Posts : 29302
Activity : 42040
Likes received : 7716
Join date : 2009-11-25
Location : Parallel universe
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Thank you still finding my way around.
____________________
“Basically, I’m just an ordinary, straightforward guy who’s the victim of the biggest f***-up on this planet – if you’ll excuse the language.”
Robert Murat talking to David Jones, Daily Mail, 02 June 2007
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-459316/Madeleine-Is-Robert-Murat-suspect-scapegoat.html
MayMuse- Posts : 2033
Activity : 3472
Likes received : 1413
Join date : 2016-04-15
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Who looks uncannily like Dr David Payne? Funny, that.MayMuse wrote:Symington is that the one who is the son of the owner of the complex? The one who looks uncannily like Murat?
BarryTheHatchet- Posts : 187
Activity : 443
Likes received : 256
Join date : 2016-05-08
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
That was Carole Tranmer, - her niece, not Pamela Fenn.April28th wrote:Let's not forget, also, that the late Mrs. Fenn, of crying incident fame, was a former employee at Windsor Castle.
____________________
“ The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi- ex moderator
- Posts : 34684
Activity : 41936
Likes received : 5932
Join date : 2015-02-02
Location : Flossery
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
@Verdi Quite correct, I'd just deleted that post on seeing the 'stay on topic' post above, didn't think anyone would've caught it. Let this post stand as confirmation of correction.
Guest- Guest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I didn't realise - your post popped up in the top right corner of my screen (as they do) and I replied directly.April28th wrote:@Verdi Quite correct, I'd just deleted that post on seeing the 'stay on topic' post above, didn't think anyone would've caught it. Let this post stand as confirmation of correction.
I'm 100% with keeping this particular thread on topic. It's a stand alone subject that shouldn't be adulterated or diverted.
____________________
“ The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi- ex moderator
- Posts : 34684
Activity : 41936
Likes received : 5932
Join date : 2015-02-02
Location : Flossery
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Ironically I'd done the opposite - replied to a thread I had left open in a tab and not refreshed!
On topic - I would contend that the deleted phone records on the day before the third - the volume of traffic they infer - and the radio silence on the third (prior to shock and awe), point to attempted deception, with either ignorance or overconfidence that they could/would be retrieved.
Anyone contending that everything took place on the third needs to find a logical explanation for this, not least because the flurry of activity (or at least some) would've been expected on the third if there was no prior conspiracy afoot.
And another CB related note which requires explanation, why did she end up in Greece in short order?
On topic - I would contend that the deleted phone records on the day before the third - the volume of traffic they infer - and the radio silence on the third (prior to shock and awe), point to attempted deception, with either ignorance or overconfidence that they could/would be retrieved.
Anyone contending that everything took place on the third needs to find a logical explanation for this, not least because the flurry of activity (or at least some) would've been expected on the third if there was no prior conspiracy afoot.
And another CB related note which requires explanation, why did she end up in Greece in short order?
Guest- Guest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I think the earlier phone records would be very interesting if they were ever released. Are deleted text messages retrievable or able to be read by PJ ?
dottyaussie- Posts : 161
Activity : 337
Likes received : 170
Join date : 2016-02-25
Location : NorthWest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Depends on the IM server. If logging is not specifically switched on, then probably not, no. Unfortunately
BarryTheHatchet- Posts : 187
Activity : 443
Likes received : 256
Join date : 2016-05-08
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
There is a wealth of information afloat on this subject. Where better to start than Portugal..dottyaussie wrote:I think the earlier phone records would be very interesting if they were ever released. Are deleted text messages retrievable or able to be read by PJ ?
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DELETED_CALLS.htm
Don't forget also, the McCanns and their group of friends were given mobile phones, apparently locally acquired, soon after Madeleine allegedly disappeared.
____________________
“ The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made" - Groucho Marx
Verdi- ex moderator
- Posts : 34684
Activity : 41936
Likes received : 5932
Join date : 2015-02-02
Location : Flossery
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
If were going with the theory that something happened before the third then we could agree that something happened on the Monday the 30th based on
1. Its the day that everyone avoided talking about.
2. Its the day that Madeleine was in and out of the creche within 15 mins
3. Its the day that neither GM or KM mentioned doing anything with M that afternoon or that she was unwell.
4. Its the day GM & KM changed their routine.
The questions then if she became ill on the Monday who was looking after her and where was she?
Ok this may sound really random but how about the delightful and very helpful.....Charlotte Pennington ? Her statements are just as messed up as TM. But if she was looking after Madeleine then she may have been telling the truth when she said she read stories to her. In Russel O'Brien's statement he said she was looking after Dave & Fiona's kids.Did he mean in the creche or as a nanny? In the Charlotte Pennington thread it is mentioned that she worked at the same hospital as KM in New Zealand which could imply KM knew her before they were in PDL. Are the creche records available for the group she apparently worked with?
If the cleaner or tradesmen were at the apartment Monday morning then there was nothing to witness. After Mon afternoon if anyone came round simply shut the bedroom door, nothing to see here.
As far as the twins asking questions, from personal experience when a family member is seriously ill, children that age are easily distracted and have a memory like a sieve. Even when they were at the house everyday they never asked any questions. They never even knew that person had become deceased until they were told.
Questions about the Creche Records and CB
Well we already know the creche records are dodgy and past posts have said how the conversation with CB could've gone re CB going along with keeping the creche records dodgy. The same/similar conversation could've happened with Charlotte.
The OMG momemt.
This OMG moment could've happened Mon afternoon/night, Tues, Wed or even Thursday day at a push. So needing someone to look after MBM would've only been for one or two days, maximum three days and for only a few hours during the morning, later in the afternoon and a few hours in the evening.
If that moment was,
Mon Afternoon/Night - The day no-one speaks of. KM went to supermarket with JT. Apparently to buy cleaning products. No need to involve CP
Tuesday - If MBM was ill/alive CP could've been looking after her during the day. OMG moment during the evening. Mrs Fenn apparently hears crying. Wednesday- Either CP looking after MBM if she was still ill/alive or "Thanks CP she's fine now" if she was not. (I know, but not totally unbelievable)
Thursday- Same as Wednesday. But that doesn't leave alot of time for cleaning, making up a plan etc.
In all of this I'm not entirely sure if ALL the Tapas 7 were completely 'in the know'. So we have GM, KM, some of the Tapas 7, CB, and CP. Also the person/s that helped them when the moment happened who was the reason all this high level assistance was brought in for.
This is just my thoughts and trying to find the pieces that fit the jigsaw.
1. Its the day that everyone avoided talking about.
2. Its the day that Madeleine was in and out of the creche within 15 mins
3. Its the day that neither GM or KM mentioned doing anything with M that afternoon or that she was unwell.
4. Its the day GM & KM changed their routine.
The questions then if she became ill on the Monday who was looking after her and where was she?
Ok this may sound really random but how about the delightful and very helpful.....Charlotte Pennington ? Her statements are just as messed up as TM. But if she was looking after Madeleine then she may have been telling the truth when she said she read stories to her. In Russel O'Brien's statement he said she was looking after Dave & Fiona's kids.Did he mean in the creche or as a nanny? In the Charlotte Pennington thread it is mentioned that she worked at the same hospital as KM in New Zealand which could imply KM knew her before they were in PDL. Are the creche records available for the group she apparently worked with?
If the cleaner or tradesmen were at the apartment Monday morning then there was nothing to witness. After Mon afternoon if anyone came round simply shut the bedroom door, nothing to see here.
As far as the twins asking questions, from personal experience when a family member is seriously ill, children that age are easily distracted and have a memory like a sieve. Even when they were at the house everyday they never asked any questions. They never even knew that person had become deceased until they were told.
Questions about the Creche Records and CB
Well we already know the creche records are dodgy and past posts have said how the conversation with CB could've gone re CB going along with keeping the creche records dodgy. The same/similar conversation could've happened with Charlotte.
The OMG momemt.
This OMG moment could've happened Mon afternoon/night, Tues, Wed or even Thursday day at a push. So needing someone to look after MBM would've only been for one or two days, maximum three days and for only a few hours during the morning, later in the afternoon and a few hours in the evening.
If that moment was,
Mon Afternoon/Night - The day no-one speaks of. KM went to supermarket with JT. Apparently to buy cleaning products. No need to involve CP
Tuesday - If MBM was ill/alive CP could've been looking after her during the day. OMG moment during the evening. Mrs Fenn apparently hears crying. Wednesday- Either CP looking after MBM if she was still ill/alive or "Thanks CP she's fine now" if she was not. (I know, but not totally unbelievable)
Thursday- Same as Wednesday. But that doesn't leave alot of time for cleaning, making up a plan etc.
In all of this I'm not entirely sure if ALL the Tapas 7 were completely 'in the know'. So we have GM, KM, some of the Tapas 7, CB, and CP. Also the person/s that helped them when the moment happened who was the reason all this high level assistance was brought in for.
This is just my thoughts and trying to find the pieces that fit the jigsaw.
dottyaussie- Posts : 161
Activity : 337
Likes received : 170
Join date : 2016-02-25
Location : NorthWest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
dottyaussie wrote:If were going with the theory that something happened before the third then we could agree that something happened on the Monday the 30th based on
1. Its the day that everyone avoided talking about.
2. Its the day that Madeleine was in and out of the creche within 15 mins
3. Its the day that neither GM or KM mentioned doing anything with M that afternoon or that she was unwell.
4. Its the day GM & KM changed their routine.
5. Its the day when there was no pings from Kate´s and Gerry´s phones in Pdl.
6. Its the day when they went on a trip to Sagres....erm...or maybe not...confusion is good.
7. Its the day when WBM logged "CEOP´s missing Madeleine" website.
The questions then if she became ill on the Monday who was looking after her and where was she?
Ok this may sound really random but how about the delightful and very helpful.....Charlotte Pennington ? Her statements are just as messed up as TM. But if she was looking after Madeleine then she may have been telling the truth when she said she read stories to her. In Russel O'Brien's statement he said she was looking after Dave & Fiona's kids.Did he mean in the creche or as a nanny? In the Charlotte Pennington thread it is mentioned that she worked at the same hospital as KM in New Zealand which could imply KM knew her before they were in PDL. Are the creche records available for the group she apparently worked with?
If the cleaner or tradesmen were at the apartment Monday morning then there was nothing to witness. After Mon afternoon if anyone came round simply shut the bedroom door, nothing to see here.
As far as the twins asking questions, from personal experience when a family member is seriously ill, children that age are easily distracted and have a memory like a sieve. Even when they were at the house everyday they never asked any questions. They never even knew that person had become deceased until they were told.
Questions about the Creche Records and CB
Well we already know the creche records are dodgy and past posts have said how the conversation with CB could've gone re CB going along with keeping the creche records dodgy. The same/similar conversation could've happened with Charlotte.
The OMG momemt.
This OMG moment could've happened Mon afternoon/night, Tues, Wed or even Thursday day at a push. So needing someone to look after MBM would've only been for one or two days, maximum three days and for only a few hours during the morning, later in the afternoon and a few hours in the evening.
If that moment was,
Mon Afternoon/Night - The day no-one speaks of. KM went to supermarket with JT. Apparently to buy cleaning products. No need to involve CP
Tuesday - If MBM was ill/alive CP could've been looking after her during the day. OMG moment during the evening. Mrs Fenn apparently hears crying. Wednesday- Either CP looking after MBM if she was still ill/alive or "Thanks CP she's fine now" if she was not. (I know, but not totally unbelievable)
Thursday- Same as Wednesday. But that doesn't leave alot of time for cleaning, making up a plan etc.
In all of this I'm not entirely sure if ALL the Tapas 7 were completely 'in the know'. So we have GM, KM, some of the Tapas 7, CB, and CP. Also the person/s that helped them when the moment happened who was the reason all this high level assistance was brought in for.
This is just my thoughts and trying to find the pieces that fit the jigsaw.
____________________
Goncalo Amaral: "Then there's the window we found Kate's finger prints.
She said she had never touched that window and the cleaning lady assured that she had cleaned it on the previous day....it doesn't add up"
NickE- Posts : 1404
Activity : 2151
Likes received : 499
Join date : 2013-10-27
Age : 49
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I'm afraid I'm a tad confused here, dottyaussie, because you were replying to Grandad who was patently advancing an hypothesis purporting that another party may have been enlisted to aid an ailing Madeleine, not to cover any situation they may have found themselves in. Hence my assumption that it would had to have been a person with a modicum of medical knowledge, after all, it wouldn't have benefited their cause to have enlisted a plumber, builder et al, would it now.dottyaussie wrote:@Realist
No I was talking about it being joint venture. That someone assisted them in the situation they were in whatever that situation was.
I think, along with a number of others, you have been watching too many TV spy thrillers, whereby a bondesque type character calls in the clean up squad, complete with white overalls and unobtrusive van to dispose of a body, along with all incriminating evidence
''And if someone else OTHER than the McCanns or the Tapas crew assisted in the original problem, who then became part of this JOINT VENTURE, then maybe the involvement of Govt/MIS/Embassy was for THAT person or THOSE persons and not the McCanns.''@Grandad wrote:
At this point A JOINT VENTURE is formed – NOT to cover up a murder or to dispose of a corpse – but to treat her and SAVE HER LIFE!
Realist- Posts : 421
Activity : 602
Likes received : 179
Join date : 2014-11-05
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Would you please explain why you called me JD? You seem to have been missing from the forum for quite a few hours since I asked.Realist wrote:I'm afraid I'm a tad confused here, dottyaussie, because you were replying to Grandad who was patently advancing an hypothesis purporting that another party may have been enlisted to aid an ailing Madeleine, not to cover any situation they may have found themselves in. Hence my assumption that it would had to have been a person with a modicum of medical knowledge, after all, it wouldn't have benefited their cause to have enlisted a plumber, builder et al, would it now.dottyaussie wrote:@Realist
No I was talking about it being joint venture. That someone assisted them in the situation they were in whatever that situation was.
I think, along with a number of others, you have been watching too many TV spy thrillers, whereby a bondesque type character calls in the clean up squad, complete with white overalls and unobtrusive van to dispose of a body, along with all incriminating evidence''And if someone else OTHER than the McCanns or the Tapas crew assisted in the original problem, who then became part of this JOINT VENTURE, then maybe the involvement of Govt/MIS/Embassy was for THAT person or THOSE persons and not the McCanns.''@Grandad wrote:
At this point A JOINT VENTURE is formed – NOT to cover up a murder or to dispose of a corpse – but to treat her and SAVE HER LIFE!
Liz Eagles- Posts : 10979
Activity : 13387
Likes received : 2217
Join date : 2011-09-03
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I do have other matters to attend to outside of the internet, Aquila, if you read your PM's, all will be revealed.aquila wrote:
Would you please explain why you called me JD? You seem to have been missing from the forum for quite a few hours since I asked.
Realist- Posts : 421
Activity : 602
Likes received : 179
Join date : 2014-11-05
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
@ Realist
Ok this is the third time now you have been completely wrong about me. I don't watch spy thrillers and am certainly not a Bond fan.
P.s Not meant as an offence to anyone else that is a Bond fan
Ok this is the third time now you have been completely wrong about me. I don't watch spy thrillers and am certainly not a Bond fan.
P.s Not meant as an offence to anyone else that is a Bond fan
dottyaussie- Posts : 161
Activity : 337
Likes received : 170
Join date : 2016-02-25
Location : NorthWest
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I've just read your PM and it means nothing...what is 'it was an advertisement from years ago' have to do with anything?Realist wrote:I do have other matters to attend to outside of the internet, Aquila, if you read your PM's, all will be revealed.aquila wrote:
Would you please explain why you called me JD? You seem to have been missing from the forum for quite a few hours since I asked.
Don't PM me again. When I ask you for an answer to something you have written openly on the forum please have the courtesy to answer it openly.
____________________
PeterMac's FREE e-book
Gonçalo Amaral: The truth of the lie
NEW CMOMM & MMRG Blog
Sir Winston Churchill: “Diplomacy is the art of telling people to go to hell in such a way that they ask for directions.”
Liz Eagles- Posts : 10979
Activity : 13387
Likes received : 2217
Join date : 2011-09-03
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
Re your being a tad confused Realist -My hypothesis - such as it was - was that the MccDocs MAY have had the help of some or all of the T7 during the week treating an injured MBM and that to cover her absence from the time of whatever incidence befell her, such that she remained 'out of sight' thereafter - they could also have been able to use another child as a substitute for her at critical moments.
Other than these people I suggest that they would not have wanted anyone to know what was going on and therefore NOT enlisted anyone else's help - for anything!
However I think that Tony has shot down any notion that MBM was dead: incapacitated or otherwise missing earlier in the week thus -
"Cat Baker met Madeleine and her parents on the Saturday AND had Madeleine in her care all of Sunday (there is even evidence she may have known the family well before May 2007).
Your theory was that ANOTHER CHILD was put forward as Madeleine for the next FOUR days (while she was very ill) and that she as 'too dopey...too gormless' to know otherwise.
If there was another child put forward as Madeleine, but who had a quite different name, how is it remotely conceivable that she did not immediately know this was not Madeleine and say (on the Monday): "Oh, where is Madeleine today?"
You wrote: "But it’s not difficult to see how a dopey nanny could come away convinced she saw a child that wasn’t there!"
With respect, it is not only difficult, but IMPOSSIBLE. There were only 7 children in Madeleine's crèche group. In sole charge of them for a week, she would know EXACTLY who was with her each day of that week."
Other than these people I suggest that they would not have wanted anyone to know what was going on and therefore NOT enlisted anyone else's help - for anything!
However I think that Tony has shot down any notion that MBM was dead: incapacitated or otherwise missing earlier in the week thus -
"Cat Baker met Madeleine and her parents on the Saturday AND had Madeleine in her care all of Sunday (there is even evidence she may have known the family well before May 2007).
Your theory was that ANOTHER CHILD was put forward as Madeleine for the next FOUR days (while she was very ill) and that she as 'too dopey...too gormless' to know otherwise.
If there was another child put forward as Madeleine, but who had a quite different name, how is it remotely conceivable that she did not immediately know this was not Madeleine and say (on the Monday): "Oh, where is Madeleine today?"
You wrote: "But it’s not difficult to see how a dopey nanny could come away convinced she saw a child that wasn’t there!"
With respect, it is not only difficult, but IMPOSSIBLE. There were only 7 children in Madeleine's crèche group. In sole charge of them for a week, she would know EXACTLY who was with her each day of that week."
Grandad- Posts : 15
Activity : 52
Likes received : 35
Join date : 2016-04-07
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
aquila wrote:
I've just read your PM and it means nothing...what is 'it was an advertisement from years ago' have to do with anything?
Don't PM me again. When I ask you for an answer to something you have written openly on the forum please have the courtesy to answer it openly.
If you care to check the timing of my PM you will note that I had already sent it out of courtesy, prior to your asking me openly on this forum. The reason I did so was because it was merely an innocuous throw away line which I didn't consider merited a mention on this thread.
Heaven forbid, you should think I had temerity to PM you with any ulterior motive in mind. For the benefit of all to see, voila:-
Sent :: Message
ONLY KIDDING, JD.
From Realist To aquila, Today at 8:03 pm
It was a TV advertisement catchphrase from many yrs. ago, Aquila, so long ago in fact, that I can't remember what the ad. was advertising.
Best wishes,
Realist- Posts : 421
Activity : 602
Likes received : 179
Join date : 2014-11-05
Re: Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
I wasn't confused by anything you wrote, Grandad. I was merely confused by dottyaussie confusing what you had written.Grandad wrote:Re your being a tad confused Realist -
Realist- Posts : 421
Activity : 602
Likes received : 179
Join date : 2014-11-05
Page 19 of 24 • 1 ... 11 ... 18, 19, 20 ... 24
Similar topics
» THE ***SEVEN*** PHOTOS THAT PROVIDE THE BIGGEST CLUE TO WHEN MADELEINE DIED (New photo of Madeleine in Praia da Luz produced by the McCann Team, taken on Sunday 29 April)
» "What's the evidence that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April?"
» Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
» Madeleine McCann - 13th Anniversary of her disappearance, but when did this really happen?
» "What's the evidence that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April?"
» "What's the evidence that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April?"
» Was Madeleine seen after Sunday?
» Madeleine McCann - 13th Anniversary of her disappearance, but when did this really happen?
» "What's the evidence that Madeleine died on Sunday 29 April?"
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Madeleine Beth McCann :: McCann Case: The most important areas of research
Page 19 of 24
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum