The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Welcome to 'The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann' forum 🌹

Please log in, or register to view all the forums as some of them are 'members only', then settle in and help us get to the truth about what really happened to Madeleine Beth McCann.

When you register please do NOT use your email address for a username because everyone will be able to see it!

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Mm11

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Regist10
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Welcome to 'The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann' forum 🌹

Please log in, or register to view all the forums as some of them are 'members only', then settle in and help us get to the truth about what really happened to Madeleine Beth McCann.

When you register please do NOT use your email address for a username because everyone will be able to see it!

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Mm11

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Regist10

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Page 12 of 27 Previous  1 ... 7 ... 11, 12, 13 ... 19 ... 27  Next

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by jeanmonroe 10.06.14 17:41

At the rate, AR & Grange 'produce' new 'witnesses', even ones now that can SEE a person SPEAKING English, everyone in PDL, will have 'seen' the nastyman, carrying Madeleine about town.Their 'evidence' will be put in the big box, at Belgravia, marked 'new witnesses, QUITE urgent'
avatar
jeanmonroe

Posts : 5818
Activity : 7756
Likes received : 1674
Join date : 2013-02-07

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by CynicAl 10.06.14 18:07

aiyoyo wrote:
SixMillionQuid wrote:So this mysterious financial backer had their own personal interests in seeing things spun or the media?

How can you jump from one paid job into another job where you dont know if you're going to get paid or how long your services will be required? Unless it was planned out fully before he jumped ship.

Very good point SMQ.

If Maddie were to be found shortly after he started with the McCanns he would soon find himself out of job.

It does not  make sense to accept a job to represent two unknown individuals (vs not a corporation) in a missing child case, unprecedented in many aspects, with too many unknown factors.  

No long term job security and definitely no prospects of advancement/promotion in any shape or form.
She could be found  alive relatively quickly and he would out of job.
She could be found dead also relatively quickly or 7 years later and he would still be out of a job.

For a job with the McCanns, where would his office be I wonder.
I can't imagine Rothley's garden shed being his office, so where did he go to report in for work to earn his £70K/year salary.
I think they call it "freelance". You tend to work from home, teleconference, commute where necessary, but its kind of a job that you define. 

And playing devil's advocate a moment, these people were operating in a vacuum of information at the time. No PJ files, no dogs, no investigation. We don't know what stories athe Mc's were telling everyone they recruited. They could have been saying 'something' s happened, it isn't us, but it will look like us, we need a fair crack at persuading the public so that we can prove our innocence.'

He might be a tepid slimy turd, but he might have started out believing a plausible lie in a vacuum of information. He may be bought into the account still. Or this may just be a sacrifice that is worth the compromise for a golden paycheck.
avatar
CynicAl

Posts : 181
Activity : 181
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-02-03

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by nobodythereeither 10.06.14 18:09

The Rooster wrote:I don't understand why Mr Amaral would want to undermine in such a public and thoroughly unprofessional manner the efforts of the Portuguese Authorities and the British Police.  I believe there is a proper investigation going on, so do many others on the forum with some very good posts published by cynicAL, the person with Ireland in their name and someone else who's name escapes me (sorry).

He seems to have lost his cool.  He's entitled to his opinion of course but it's the manner of delivery that's inconsistent with his previous persona.

I completely agree with that.

It's very strange.

And thanks from me also to CynicAl for his common sense.

Edited to add a capital C to his name!

____________________

avatar
nobodythereeither

Posts : 273
Activity : 273
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2010-11-26

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by CynicAl 10.06.14 18:26

canada12 wrote:Regarding coverup, whitewash, protection of someone higher up...
Just a thought, but how do we know that Clarence Mitchell wasn't there at that time Madeleine disappeared?
Perhaps Clarence Mitchell is the reason for the "coverup" and for all the "protection".
Perhaps Clarence Mitchell was quietly let go of his job with the government, and found himself in a bit of a tight spot.
IMO, the only reason Clarence Mitchell would know that a PR job for the McCanns would be long term is if he was part of the original problem and KNEW exactly what was going on.
And the best way to protect himself would be working as spokesman for the McCanns, to control everything coming out of Rothley, TM, and the press.
Idle speculation, just an opinion. But as valid as any other speculation right now.
I'm sorry, but saying "Mickey Mouse did it" is not as 'valid' as any other speculative suggestion. The point of intelligent debate is to be rational and thoughtful, objective and logical. It isn't to pull out the wildest assumptions to try to contort them to create a narrative which fills in all the blanks of what we don't know and aren't actually entitled to be privy to. 

I think we're taking the 'democratic citizen' demands a bit too seriously. We are NOT entitled, even as taxpayers, to read every word of an interview, every detail of an investigation or to know every fact. To fill in the perceived blanks with wild, irrational speculations to make the dots connect doesn't serve to do anything but discredit the act of speculating out of dissent with official reports. 

We've gone from the wild theory of massive cover up and whitewash to protect a high level cabinet minister who was there banging Mrs McCann and her friends, to a similarly high, extreme form of protection to protect clarence Mitchell... 

I kid you not, if Mitchell had compromised himself in PDL it would not be a short queue of government figures who'd happily flush the toad, rather than move hell and high water to protect him. We're talking about the unlawful death of a child here in the highest profile case in decades - even if those high level politicos were cold enough to not care and get involved anyway, they're not stupid enough to know the risks of becoming an accessory and conspiring to pervert the course of justice and the scandal of being exposed. There is nothing that can be plausibly put on the table which puts forward anything which is worth that kind of risk.
avatar
CynicAl

Posts : 181
Activity : 181
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-02-03

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by AndyB 10.06.14 18:34

CynicAl wrote:We are NOT entitled, even as taxpayers, to read every word of an interview, every detail of an investigation or to know every fact.
No we're not but perhaps we should be. The Portuguese are, or at least their criminal justice system provides for it.

ETA

CynicAl wrote:I kid you not, if Mitchell had compromised himself in PDL it would not be a short queue of government figures who'd happily flush the toad, rather than move hell and high water to protect him. We're talking about the unlawful death of a child here in the highest profile case in decades - even if those high level politicos were cold enough to not care and get involved anyway, they're not stupid enough to know the risks of becoming an accessory and conspiring to pervert the course of justice and the scandal of being exposed. There is nothing that can be plausibly put on the table which puts forward anything which is worth that kind of risk
I can think of one thing.

Don't forget the course of justice continues to be perverted by senior people in the case of the former Conservative cabinet minister accused of paedophilia and rape so its not as far fetched as you make out

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
avatar
AndyB

Posts : 692
Activity : 724
Likes received : 2
Join date : 2013-06-03
Age : 61
Location : Consett, County Durham

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 18:44

CynicAl wrote:
aiyoyo wrote:
SixMillionQuid wrote:So this mysterious financial backer had their own personal interests in seeing things spun or the media?

How can you jump from one paid job into another job where you dont know if you're going to get paid or how long your services will be required? Unless it was planned out fully before he jumped ship.

Very good point SMQ.

If Maddie were to be found shortly after he started with the McCanns he would soon find himself out of job.

It does not  make sense to accept a job to represent two unknown individuals (vs not a corporation) in a missing child case, unprecedented in many aspects, with too many unknown factors.  

No long term job security and definitely no prospects of advancement/promotion in any shape or form.
She could be found  alive relatively quickly and he would out of job.
She could be found dead also relatively quickly or 7 years later and he would still be out of a job.

For a job with the McCanns, where would his office be I wonder.
I can't imagine Rothley's garden shed being his office, so where did he go to report in for work to earn his £70K/year salary.
I think they call it "freelance". You tend to work from home, teleconference, commute where necessary, but its kind of a job that you define. 

And playing devil's advocate a moment, these people were operating in a vacuum of information at the time. No PJ files, no dogs, no investigation. We don't know what stories athe Mc's were telling everyone they recruited. They could have been saying 'something' s happened, it isn't us, but it will look like us, we need a fair crack at persuading the public so that we can prove our innocence.'

He might be a tepid slimy turd, but he might have started out believing a plausible lie in a vacuum of information. He may be bought into the account still. Or this may just be a sacrifice that is worth the compromise for a golden paycheck.

I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by MissDaisy 10.06.14 19:04

BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.
avatar
MissDaisy

Posts : 123
Activity : 126
Likes received : 1
Join date : 2013-05-30

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 19:24

MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by JackieL 10.06.14 19:56

For what it's worth, my view is a sort of mix of what Amaral's saying and also Blacksmith. 

I think the 11 pm call on 3rd May by John Buck, British ambassador to Ribeiro, head of the PJ who interrupted a private dinner to take it, was probably a result of PE (nephew of MH, Labour politician) being in PdL at the time.  He must've made a call to Aunty Margaret.  Similarly the report  in the Daily Telegraph after 2 hours.

The next day PE left the country - is there anything sinister in that?  Not in my opinion - why? cos that's what rich people do....would you hang around when there was a tragedy like that unfolding before your eyes, involving people you didn't know, when you were supposed to be on holiday?  If you could get the hell out of there, wouldn't you?  All the middle-class Warner crowd on their package deals had to hang around cos their flights weren't until the weekend, with the helicopters overhead and the place swarming with police.  Rich people don't have to put up with that. They can just steer a wide berth of strangers' messy lives.

What happened next? Well, never underestimate how lazy and sloppy people can be - that goes for journalists, politicians and doctors.  Politicians - first Labour, then Tory, latched on to the idea of being the pivotal figure to "bring Madeleine home" because they thought it would bring them popularity and votes.  Ditto Rebekah Brookes who thought it would sell more of Rupert Murdoch's unpleasant newspapers.  The traditional deference which the British insist on showing toward doctors, no matter how poorly they perform their work, means that the politicos and the journos went along with the story without bothering to check out the facts. 

Plus, the McCanns had some very well-placed Scottish friends in 2007 - remember Kate's friend Gill Renwick, who just conveniently happened to bump into Gordon Brown's brother John, who lived on the same street as her, and Gill Renwick's pal who nipped round and knocked on the door of Newsnight presenter Kirsty Wark etc. etc. 

So the urge to bask in the reflected glory of tracing the working class made good doctors, who managed to bring home their little girl was just too good a chance to miss.  Once the Establishment realised that not was all as it seemed and there were some murky areas lurking underneath the facade, it was too late to turn back, without losing face.  So they have to push on, supporting the McCanns regardless. Hence the involvement of MI5 and possibly the 'inconclusive' results from the lab following Eddie and Keela.

The arrogance of Blair, Brown, Cameron, Lord Leveson and the Murdoch press astounds me.  They think they can make an accurate judgement of character and the circumstances without checking out the facts and studying the case properly.

Remember Deep Throat's famous lines in 'All the President's Men' when he tells Woodward to 'follow the money' - 
Forget the myths the media's created about the White House. The truth is, these are not very bright guys, and things got out of hand.


For me, there's no big, clever cover-up. Leveson, Brown, Cameron etc. are not very bright guys and things got out of hand - now they've got to engineer an outcome so they don't lose face.
avatar
JackieL

Posts : 222
Activity : 236
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2013-02-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by aiyoyo 10.06.14 20:00

BlueBag wrote:
MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?

He was not there literally next day, but not far off, within first week of disappearance if I am not wrong.
aiyoyo
aiyoyo

Posts : 9610
Activity : 10084
Likes received : 326
Join date : 2009-11-28

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by JackieL 10.06.14 20:09

aiyoyo wrote:
BlueBag wrote:
MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?

He was not there literally next day, but not far off, within first week of disappearance if I am not wrong.
Yep - wasn't he the person who organised the trip to see the Pope? Gotta find the link......
avatar
JackieL

Posts : 222
Activity : 236
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2013-02-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by roy rovers 10.06.14 20:27

From the date it was announced that Gordon Brown would take over from Tony Blair as Prime Minister on 27 June 2007 he was desperate to paint himself as a multi faceted man of the people not just a policy 'wonk' and numbers man. He only had a partial term in office before the general election. The Madeleine McCann case was a perfect opportunity for him to be seen to be pro-active, firm, caring, involved etc etc. He just chose the wrong subject. Being in reality a stubborn control freak he had to avoid looking foolish as the election started looming into view. Instead of assisting the PJ and having the McCanns arrested Brown's personal intervention and the later actions of his government gave the McCanns the vital breathing space to assemble and promulgate their version of events etc. It suited Brown and his party well when the popular press took up the cause.
If this case is cracked before the next election on Teresa May's watch I suspect the Tories will use it to mock Brown's then right hand men Milliband and Balls. All IMHO.
roy rovers
roy rovers

Posts : 473
Activity : 538
Likes received : 51
Join date : 2012-03-04

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by JackieL 10.06.14 21:25

roy rovers wrote:From the date it was announced that Gordon Brown would take over from Tony Blair as Prime Minister on 27 June 2007 he was desperate to paint himself as a multi faceted man of the people not just a policy 'wonk' and numbers man. He only had a partial term in office before the general election. The Madeleine McCann case was a perfect opportunity for him to be seen to be pro-active, firm, caring, involved etc etc. He just chose the wrong subject. Being in reality a stubborn control freak he had to avoid looking foolish as the election started looming into view. Instead of assisting the PJ and having the McCanns arrested Brown's personal intervention and the later actions of his government gave the McCanns the vital breathing space to assemble and promulgate their version of events etc. It suited Brown and his party well when the popular press took up the cause.
If this case is cracked before the next election on Teresa May's watch I suspect the Tories will use it to mock Brown's then right hand men Milliband and Balls. All IMHO.

all very true Roy.  (I'm afraid.....I speak as a lifetime Labour Party member)  Sad
avatar
JackieL

Posts : 222
Activity : 236
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2013-02-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 21:27

@ CynicAl today 12:33 pm



No doubt many people agree with your description of Clarence Mitchell but his appearance and personality are irrelevant, his professional position is the point in question so perhaps you could now answer the question posed originally by Hicks? Not forgetting his predecessor Sheree Dodds.



While your at it, perhaps you can also give your view as to the level of diplomatic presence at camp pdl.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by nglfi 10.06.14 21:34

View-from-Ireland wrote:


Personally, I feel that the fact that this happened on Portuguese soil is a complicating factor. Had Madeleine disappeared from her own bedroom in Rothley and the same scenario been presented by the Tapas crew and the McCanns we'd be looking at a very different case. I think the fact that government became involved in any shape in the early days had everything to do with the fact that the family were seen as British holidaymakers to Portugal who had been victims of a terrible crime. Also, because it happened 'out foreign', I'd imagine the British public were more conditioned to sympathise with the family than ask the type of questions that would have come to mind had it happened on British soil.
I know a lot of people read negatively into the statement in OG's remit that they aim to investigate 'the abduction as if it happened in the UK', but I take a far more positive interpretation.  I think what is being hinted at is that if the MCs had called up in a panic and said their bany had just 'disappeared' from their house with no trace of a break in, and engaged in all the behaviour they subsequently engaged in when it happened in Portugal,  it would have been investigated very differently.  If you ignore the word abduction that's how it reads to me. In fact it seems to be saying 'if this 'abduction' had happened in the UK it wouldn't be classed as an abduction'. All my super positive take on it ofc
avatar
nglfi

Posts : 568
Activity : 866
Likes received : 274
Join date : 2014-01-09

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 21:45

ShuBob wrote:
Gollum wrote:@ CynicAl

FFS, an intelligent high level conspiracy would have sent them a female PR, to empathise with KM and have people thinking 'an attractive, modern woman in PR would definitely never cover up a crime like this.'


Justine McGuiness for example?

The general consensus on the forums when Ms McGuiness was at the helm of the McCann PR machine was that she was inept. If only we'd known then what Clarence Mitchell would become!

IMO she didn't help the couple at all and I got the impression she wasn't a fan of Gerry's. Remember after she left she sued when a "source close to the McCanns" told a Sunday newspaper she had effectively fleeced them of fund money and she also wrote a not-so-helpful article about her time with the couple.

I recall she skulked off under a cloud but she managed to stay the course didn't she, taking over from Mitchell in June 2007 and not leaving their side until they returned to England in September 2007 and Mitchell was back in the driving seat.  Having said that, she was only another pawn in the game wasn't she?
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Woofer 10.06.14 21:53

@ JackieL - "The next day PE left the country - is there anything sinister in that?  Not in my opinion - why? cos that's what rich people do....would you hang around when there was a tragedy like that unfolding before your eyes, involving people you didn't know, when you were supposed to be on holiday?  If you could get the hell out of there, wouldn't you? "

When did he realise there was a tragedy unfolding though ? Obviously well before the early evening of the 3rd because he had told another couple who were dining near him that he was leaving the next day. (Can`t remember the couple`s name but its in their statement).   Which means he got the tip-off during Thursday 3rd, or even before that.

____________________
The constant assertion of belief is an indication of fear - Jiddu Krishnamurti
Woofer
Woofer

Posts : 3390
Activity : 3508
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2012-02-06

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 21:55

JackieL wrote:
aiyoyo wrote:
BlueBag wrote:
MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?

He was not there literally next day, but not far off, within first week of disappearance if I am not wrong.
Yep - wasn't he the person who organised the trip to see the Pope? Gotta find the link......

Clarence Mitchell interviewed by Expresso September 2007

Q: It was enough that you called certain people so that Kate and Gerry were granted an audience with the Pope.

A: And I am a Protestant! When I was in the Algarve on behalf of the Foreign Office I kept in touch with the British Embassies, the Vatican's inclusive. Through Cormac Murphy O’Connor, Archbishop of Westminster, I knew that Maddie's disappearance had not gone un-noticed by the Vatican. He suggested that we asked for an audience with the Pope. It was I that wrote that email, since Gerry and Kate did not want any special treatment.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by fossey 10.06.14 22:00

Woofer wrote:@ JackieL - "The next day PE left the country - is there anything sinister in that?  Not in my opinion - why? cos that's what rich people do....would you hang around when there was a tragedy like that unfolding before your eyes, involving people you didn't know, when you were supposed to be on holiday?  If you could get the hell out of there, wouldn't you? "

When did he realise there was a tragedy unfolding though ? Obviously well before the early evening of the 3rd because he had told another couple who were dining near him that he was leaving the next day. (Can`t remember the couple`s name but its in their statement).   Which means he got the tip-off during Thursday 3rd, or even before that.
P.E said he had photo's of his boys on the day of M's disappearance. With M in the background.

They never saw the light of day.

Strange.
avatar
fossey

Posts : 293
Activity : 304
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2014-06-07

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 22:04

Gollum wrote:
I recall she skulked off under a cloud but she managed to stay the course didn't she, taking over from Mitchell in June 2007 and not leaving their side until they returned to England in September 2007 and Mitchell was back in the driving seat.  Having said that, she was only another pawn in the game wasn't she?

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Not so sure. In the beginning, maybe, but she certainly left a few question marks over her commitment to the McCause by the end. Needs further exploration, this, imo.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Silver Shuffle 10.06.14 22:04

who is PE?
avatar
Silver Shuffle

Posts : 99
Activity : 103
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2013-10-24

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 22:05

AndyB wrote:
CynicAl wrote:We are NOT entitled, even as taxpayers, to read every word of an interview, every detail of an investigation or to know every fact.
No we're not but perhaps we should be. The Portuguese are, or at least their criminal justice system provides for it.

ETA

CynicAl wrote:I kid you not, if Mitchell had compromised himself in PDL it would not be a short queue of government figures who'd happily flush the toad, rather than move hell and high water to protect him. We're talking about the unlawful death of a child here in the highest profile case in decades - even if those high level politicos were cold enough to not care and get involved anyway, they're not stupid enough to know the risks of becoming an accessory and conspiring to pervert the course of justice and the scandal of being exposed. There is nothing that can be plausibly put on the table which puts forward anything which is worth that kind of risk
I can think of one thing.

Don't forget the course of justice continues to be perverted by senior people in the case of the former Conservative cabinet minister accused of paedophilia and rape so its not as far fetched as you make out

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Precisely AndyB, naivety in the extreme to believe otherwise.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by fossey 10.06.14 22:09

Silver Shuffle wrote:who is PE?
Philip Edmonds.

Have a read of this.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
avatar
fossey

Posts : 293
Activity : 304
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2014-06-07

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by Guest 10.06.14 22:14

BlueBag wrote:
MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?
Gerry McCann allegedly met up with Clarence Mitchell for the first time when he visited England three weeks after Maddie's disappearance.  Iirc the circumstance leading to the first encounter differ according to which report you listen to but whatever, Gerry returned to Portugal with Mitchell in his luggage.  Close enough?
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by MaybeMaybenot 10.06.14 22:26

fossey wrote:
Silver Shuffle wrote:who is PE?
Philip Edmonds.

Have a read of this.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Hmmm....Seems to be a very strong Jewish connection. Kates Father, Miliband, Oppenheimer, Jez Wilkins, Philip Green. How many more ????
Now they do and will protect
avatar
MaybeMaybenot

Posts : 70
Activity : 74
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-06-06

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by JackieL 10.06.14 22:27

fossey wrote:
Silver Shuffle wrote:who is PE?
Philip Edmonds.

Have a read of this.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Mr Philip Martin Edmonds is the nephew of Margaret Hodge -high ranking Labour figure and one of the richest women in the country.


PE and his three boys were out in PdL for the week the McCanns were there, but not his wife Reina. We know from Portuguese police files that PE cut short his holiday and flew out of Portugal to Switzerland on Friday 4th May 2007.


When Tony Bennett wrote to PE asking him about events surrounding his departure from PdL he got the following reply:


Dear Mr Bennett,

I am in receipt of your letter of 22 July regarding Madeleine McCann. I am sure you would appreciate that it would not be appropriate for me to comment too much, as we do not know each other, and I have no idea what your connection to the case is. However, I would also not want further conspiracy theories to fester by simply ignoring your letter. 

Therefore, I can confirm that whatever information I had (including some photos of my sons taken on the day Madeleine disappeared, which showed her in the background) was passed both to the police and to the McCanns at the time. Having been in Portugal at the time of Madeleine’s disappearance and seen all of the events first hand, there is not one shred of doubt in my mind that the events as reported were correct. 

In fact one of the most terrible parts of this tragedy is that there are people out there who are questioning this, just adding further to the nightmare that the McCann family have suffered. I cannot imagine anything crueller. 


I’m afraid I won’t enter into further correspondence on this matter with you.

Yours sincerely,

Philip Edmonds
avatar
JackieL

Posts : 222
Activity : 236
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2013-02-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by missmar1 10.06.14 22:30

Gollum wrote:
BlueBag wrote:
MissDaisy wrote:
BlueBag wrote:I'm not having this.

Why did the Government think a media manipulator was required as a priority?

He was there next day!
Was he there the next day? I thought Sheree Dodd was the first person sent by the Government.

Oh yeah.. that's right.


First to arrive in Portugal was a former Mirror journalist and long-term government spokesperson called Sheree Dodd. In an unprecedented move, the Government took over news-handling on behalf of the McCann..

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]


Then they sent Clarence.

My memory of Government priorities is fading after 7 years.

Because what the McCanns really needed was a Government media person.

Clarence turned up.. when?
Gerry McCann allegedly met up with Clarence Mitchell for the first time when he visited England three weeks after Maddie's disappearance.  Iirc the circumstance leading to the first encounter differ according to which report you listen to but whatever, Gerry returned to Portugal with Mitchell in his luggage.  Close enough?

And when they all arrived back home - there was Mitchel standing side by side with the Mccann's at their garden gate publicly vouching his 100 %  belief in their innocence even though he hadn't even met them before their daughter went missing .
avatar
missmar1

Posts : 253
Activity : 253
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2014-05-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by JackieL 10.06.14 22:33

Sometimes it's shocking to read the old news reports still knocking around on cached copies of the old Mirror Forum.  It took my breath away just re-reading this from the Observer - gotta be late May 2007:





"Gordon Brown has personally intervened in the search for missing four-year-old Madeleine McCann after her parents became frustrated by the lack of progress in the police investigation.
After a series of telephone conversations with Madeleine's father, Gerry McCann in recent days, the Chancellor requested assistance from the Foreign Office and the Home Office. He asked that pressure be brought to bear on the Portuguese authorities to allow more information about the inquiry to be made public.
Gerry and his wife, Kate, have been desperate for a description of a man seen carrying what appears to have been a child on 3 May to be made public, but Portuguese police refused for three weeks because of the country's laws, which forbid the details of an investigation being released.The Observer understands that Brown gave the McCanns an assurance he would do 'anything he can' to help. The British embassy duly applied pressure on the Portuguese authorities to find more flexibility in their secrecy laws. British ambassador John Buck visited the Algarve last Thursday. A day later Portuguese police made a U-turn and issued a detailed description of the man, said to be white, 35 to 40, 5ft 10in and of medium build, with hair longer around the neck, wearing a dark jacket, light beige trousers and dark shoes.
Asked whether Brown had influenced the decision, Clarence Mitchell, a Foreign Office spokesman for the McCann family in the Algarve, said: 'Draw your own conclusions.' He said in a statement: 'I can confirm that telephone conversations have taken place between Gerry McCann and Chancellor Gordon Brown. During them, Mr Brown offered both Gerry and Kate his full support in their efforts to find Madeleine, although details of the conversations will remain private.'
Although they have praised the efforts being made to find their daughter, the McCanns were said to be increasingly frustrated in recent days at delays and communication problems. The family have met lawyers in the Algarve and threatened legal action to push for the information to be released because of the exceptional circumstances.
The Observer can confirm that a top law firm in London had been asked late last week to seek legal avenues through which the McCanns could be kept up to date on the latest developments in the investigations.

It also emerged yesterday that The Prince of Wales and Duchess of Cornwall had been following the case 'closely and with deep concern'."


WTF?????????
avatar
JackieL

Posts : 222
Activity : 236
Likes received : 14
Join date : 2013-02-19

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by PeterMac 10.06.14 22:34

Gollum wrote:
Gerry McCann allegedly met up with Clarence Mitchell for the first time when he visited England three weeks after Maddie's disappearance.  Iirc the circumstance leading to the first encounter differ according to which report you listen to but whatever, Gerry returned to Portugal with Mitchell in his luggage. 
And the other thing in their luggage was the Last Photo, which Mitchell disseminated the following day, in a blundering and now all too familiar way which drew immediate attention to the likelihood of its being WRONG -
the one which the world now knows knows to be a forgery.

(For newbies, it was NOT taken at lunchtime on 3rd May.
It can only have been taken on the Sunday 30th April)

(Added for the benefit of C-R - Probably !)
PeterMac
PeterMac
Investigator

Posts : 13984
Activity : 16988
Likes received : 2076
Join date : 2010-12-06

http://whatreallyhappenedtomadeleinemccann.blogspot.co.uk/

Back to top Go down

Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks - Page 12 Empty Re: Latest interview with Dr Amaral - copied from Joana Morais - with thanks

Post by lj 10.06.14 22:34

aiyoyo wrote:
lj wrote:About the drug trafficking: I thought all drugs were legal in Portugal. Why would there be trafficking?

All drugs are legal in Portugal?  uhmmm...can't be right.


Legal might not be the right term, decriminalized.


[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

____________________
"And if Madeleine had hurt herself inside the apartment, why would that be our fault?"  Gerry

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
lj
lj

Posts : 3329
Activity : 3590
Likes received : 208
Join date : 2009-12-01

Back to top Go down

Page 12 of 27 Previous  1 ... 7 ... 11, 12, 13 ... 19 ... 27  Next

View previous topic View next topic Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum