How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Page 1 of 1 • Share
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
shouldn't the LATER information be INCLUDED for completeness?
jmbd- Posts : 557
Activity : 588
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2010-02-04
A credibility problem for Jane Tanner
Thank you.jmbd wrote:Shouldn't the LATER information be INCLUDED for completeness?
You have just admitted that Jane Tanner DID identify Murat initially but by the time the Rogatory interviews came round, she claimed she hadn't identified him.
Maybe you should go and tell 'figaro'.
P.S. You wrote: "Shouldn't the LATER information be INCLUDED for completeness?"
We make reference to this later in our full article. I have only dislcosed a small part of it. From Jane Tanner's point of view, including the later information, as you suggest - namely that she was completely and utterly wrong in idenitifying Murat as the man she said she saw at 9.15pm on Thursday 3 May - doesn't do much for her credibility.
Does it?
Tony Bennett- Researcher
- Posts : 16906
Activity : 24770
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 76
Location : Shropshire
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Its not doing much for your credibility. I and others have checked all files and there is NOTHING in them to say that Jane identified Murat.
If you are so sure you are right please supply a link and I will happily apologise.
If you are so sure you are right please supply a link and I will happily apologise.
figaro- Posts : 61
Activity : 65
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2010-02-02
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Tony, shouldn't you FIRST disclose the source of your claim she's identified him in May?
I've asked for it on several occasions now, still got no reply. Perhaps because it isn't in the released DVD files? So what's your source? I suspect it's Amaral's book.
ETA snap Figaro
I've asked for it on several occasions now, still got no reply. Perhaps because it isn't in the released DVD files? So what's your source? I suspect it's Amaral's book.
ETA snap Figaro
Cath- Posts : 597
Activity : 626
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2009-12-22
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Well if it is from amarals book that means he will have Duarte on his case doesnt it INYX
figaro- Posts : 61
Activity : 65
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2010-02-02
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Only if it's libellous I guess, figaro. Or harms the search for Madeleine.
Cath- Posts : 597
Activity : 626
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2009-12-22
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Well as the files clearly state the she didnt think Murat was the Abductor I guess it falls under that category.
Tony maybe its time for a re think on that article?
Tony maybe its time for a re think on that article?
figaro- Posts : 61
Activity : 65
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2010-02-02
Re: How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
Oh, didn't Carter Ruck also represent the Tapas7 in their libel suit against the newspapers?
Cath- Posts : 597
Activity : 626
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2009-12-22
Similar topics
» How Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the chief suspect
» Especially for 'figaro', 'Inyx' and others who don't think Jane Tanner identified Murat on 13 May 2007
» Clarence Mitchell's guile and cunning as he tries to deny that Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the abductor
» Clarence Mitchell's guile and cunning as he tries to deny that Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the abductor
» The Tale of Jane Tanner: Robert Murat the phantom abductor
» Especially for 'figaro', 'Inyx' and others who don't think Jane Tanner identified Murat on 13 May 2007
» Clarence Mitchell's guile and cunning as he tries to deny that Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the abductor
» Clarence Mitchell's guile and cunning as he tries to deny that Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat as the abductor
» The Tale of Jane Tanner: Robert Murat the phantom abductor
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum