Irish witness - does this make Jane Tanner a Liar?
Page 2 of 2 • Share
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Re: Irish witness - does this make Jane Tanner a Liar?
sar wrote:so tannerman was allegedly important to their "scenario" but has been rendered obsolete by sy. "....things change.."
Tannerman was VITAL to their scenario
Without a sighting of a person carrying a child there is precisely NOTHING
No entry, no exit, no forensics, nothing on the long list of things there should be if a crime had been committed.
Which is why Smithman is now VITAL.
Vital in the sense that they cannot allow him to be found and identified as a father carrying his child
They must be terrified that Redwood is going to announce that they have traced, interviewed and eliminated him
Even more terrified if Redwood announces that Smithman did not even exist.
Re: Irish witness - does this make Jane Tanner a Liar?
PeterMac wrote:sar wrote:so tannerman was allegedly important to their "scenario" but has been rendered obsolete by sy. "....things change.."
Tannerman was VITAL to their scenario
Without a sighting of a person carrying a child there is precisely NOTHING
No entry, no exit, no forensics, nothing on the long list of things there should be if a crime had been committed.
Which is why Smithman is now VITAL.
Vital in the sense that they cannot allow him to be found and identified as a father carrying his child
They must be terrified that Redwood is going to announce that they have traced, interviewed and eliminated him
Even more terrified if Redwood announces that Smithman did not even exist.
So where does this leave Andy Redwood's unnamed 'Tannerman' shown on Crimewatch?
roy rovers- Posts : 473
Activity : 538
Likes received : 51
Join date : 2012-03-04
Re: Irish witness - does this make Jane Tanner a Liar?
I didn't know where to post this so will post it here.
2008
Jane Tanner is not credible: she identifies and recognizes different people. She starts with Murat, later on someone else is mentioned, according to the drawing done by a witness, and she already says that is the person, completely different from Robert Murat.
Jane Tanner’s testimony drove the abduction theory.
In order to advance into that direction, it would be necessary to give her credit: there was no other indicium of the abduction. And the issue of the bedroom window, where Maddie and her siblings slept, is vital. It leads to simulation. This means, whether or not it was open when Jane says that she saw the man carrying the child. The little girl’s mother, Kate, is the only person that mentions the open window.
Does that undo the abduction theory?
There lies the solution. To be closed or not, is a strong indicium for simulation. And why does one simulate abduction, rather than simply saying that the child has disappeared? She could have opened the door and left…
http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2008/07/interview-with-gonalo-amaral-cadaver.html?m=1
2008
Jane Tanner is not credible: she identifies and recognizes different people. She starts with Murat, later on someone else is mentioned, according to the drawing done by a witness, and she already says that is the person, completely different from Robert Murat.
Jane Tanner’s testimony drove the abduction theory.
In order to advance into that direction, it would be necessary to give her credit: there was no other indicium of the abduction. And the issue of the bedroom window, where Maddie and her siblings slept, is vital. It leads to simulation. This means, whether or not it was open when Jane says that she saw the man carrying the child. The little girl’s mother, Kate, is the only person that mentions the open window.
Does that undo the abduction theory?
There lies the solution. To be closed or not, is a strong indicium for simulation. And why does one simulate abduction, rather than simply saying that the child has disappeared? She could have opened the door and left…
http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2008/07/interview-with-gonalo-amaral-cadaver.html?m=1
cloak'ndagger- Posts : 118
Activity : 133
Likes received : 3
Join date : 2014-08-06
Re: Irish witness - does this make Jane Tanner a Liar?
How curious if this Irish teenager had snuck out from Estrela da Luz for a smoke...
Was anything else ever brought up about her?
Was anything else ever brought up about her?
Guest- Guest
Page 2 of 2 • 1, 2
Similar topics
» OnlyInAmerica blog: Jane Tanner Liar, Gerry McCann Liar, They Are All Liars
» Jane Tanner Liar?
» McCann Gallery: Jane Tanner Liar
» Dogs/DNA and Irish Family witness testimony questions.
» Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?
» Jane Tanner Liar?
» McCann Gallery: Jane Tanner Liar
» Dogs/DNA and Irish Family witness testimony questions.
» Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?
Page 2 of 2
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum