How many questions answered? - 4 SO FAR
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Books on the Madeleine McCann case :: Kate McCann's book, Prosecution Exhibit 1: 'madeleine'
Page 1 of 1 • Share
How many questions answered? - 4 SO FAR
By my reckoning, the following four out of our 163 Questions have been answered in the serialisations so far, either in part of full, but not by any means satisfactorily:
9. What was the precise state of the apartment as Dr Kate McCann entered it at around 10.00pm on 3 May 2007: What was the state of Madeleine’s bed and bedding? Where exactly was ‘Cuddle Cat? How far was the bedroom door open when the McCanns entered it? Were the windows and shutters open or closed? Were the doors to the apartment left open or locked?
46. What is the reason that the McCanns refused to pay for the evening baby-sitting service that was available for Mark Warners holiday guests?
98. Does Dr Gerald McCann still stand by his claim that the evidence of the cadaver dogs is ‘notoriously unreliable’?
100. As you may be aware, on British police advice, the Portuguese Police asked top dog handler Martin Grime to bring his springer spaniels, Eddie and Keela, to Praia da Luz. Eddie is trained to detect the scent of human corpses; Keela is trained to detect the presence of human blood. Eddie had never given a false alert in around 200 previous outings. He alerted to the odour of a human corpse in these locations: four different places in the McCanns’ apartment, two of Dr Kate McCann’s clothes, one of their children’s T-shirts, on the pink soft toy, ‘Cuddle Cat’, and in two places in the Renault Scenic that the McCanns hired. Eddie did not alert to a corpse scent anywhere else in Praia da Luz. Keela detected blood at some of these places. How do the McCanns best explain the ‘alerts’ of these two highly trained springer spaniels? (In 2008, Portuguese TV interviewer Sandra Felgueira asked Dr Gerald McCann: “How can you explain the scent of cadaver found by the British dogs?” Dr McCann answered, and we quote verbatim: “Ask the dogs, Sandra”).
Have any others been answered yet?
9. What was the precise state of the apartment as Dr Kate McCann entered it at around 10.00pm on 3 May 2007: What was the state of Madeleine’s bed and bedding? Where exactly was ‘Cuddle Cat? How far was the bedroom door open when the McCanns entered it? Were the windows and shutters open or closed? Were the doors to the apartment left open or locked?
46. What is the reason that the McCanns refused to pay for the evening baby-sitting service that was available for Mark Warners holiday guests?
98. Does Dr Gerald McCann still stand by his claim that the evidence of the cadaver dogs is ‘notoriously unreliable’?
100. As you may be aware, on British police advice, the Portuguese Police asked top dog handler Martin Grime to bring his springer spaniels, Eddie and Keela, to Praia da Luz. Eddie is trained to detect the scent of human corpses; Keela is trained to detect the presence of human blood. Eddie had never given a false alert in around 200 previous outings. He alerted to the odour of a human corpse in these locations: four different places in the McCanns’ apartment, two of Dr Kate McCann’s clothes, one of their children’s T-shirts, on the pink soft toy, ‘Cuddle Cat’, and in two places in the Renault Scenic that the McCanns hired. Eddie did not alert to a corpse scent anywhere else in Praia da Luz. Keela detected blood at some of these places. How do the McCanns best explain the ‘alerts’ of these two highly trained springer spaniels? (In 2008, Portuguese TV interviewer Sandra Felgueira asked Dr Gerald McCann: “How can you explain the scent of cadaver found by the British dogs?” Dr McCann answered, and we quote verbatim: “Ask the dogs, Sandra”).
Have any others been answered yet?
Tony Bennett- Researcher
- Posts : 16906
Activity : 24770
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 76
Location : Shropshire
Re: How many questions answered? - 4 SO FAR
I can't bring myself to read Kate's [serialisation - ed. Admin] so is there any chance you can post up the answers she'd made to the 4 questions?
Many, many thanks.
Many, many thanks.
Wyatt Burp- Posts : 5
Activity : 5
Likes received : 0
Join date : 2011-05-09
Re: How many questions answered? - 4 SO FAR
Here is a short summary of the answers Dr Kate McCann has now given on the record:Wyatt Burp wrote:I can't bring myself to read Kate's [serialisation] so is there any chance you can post up the answers she'd made to the 4 questions? Many, many thanks.
9. What was the precise state of the apartment as Dr Kate McCann entered it at around 10.00pm on 3 May 2007: What was the state of Madeleine’s bed and bedding? Where exactly was ‘Cuddle Cat? How far was the bedroom door open when the McCanns entered it? Were the windows and shutters open or closed? Were the doors to the apartment left open or locked?
DR KATE MCCANN'S ANSWER: The children's door was wider open than before, the shutter was up, the window was open causing the door to clam shut, Madeleine was not there, the cover on the bed was folded over into a triangle shape, Cuddle Cat was lying on the top of the bed. And, er, that's about it.
46. What is the reason that the McCanns refused to pay for the evening baby-sitting service that was available for Mark Warners holiday guests?
DR KATE MCCANN'S ANSWER: We didn't want 'strangers' looking after our children, and in any case our half-hour checking system was better.
98. Does Dr Gerald McCann still stand by his claim that the evidence of the cadaver dogs is ‘notoriously unreliable’?
DR KATE MCCANN'S ANSWER: Yes.
100. As you may be aware, on British police advice, the Portuguese Police asked top dog handler Martin Grime to bring his springer spaniels, Eddie and Keela, to Praia da Luz. Eddie is trained to detect the scent of human corpses; Keela is trained to detect the presence of human blood. Eddie had never given a false alert in around 200 previous outings. He alerted to the odour of a human corpse in these locations: four different places in the McCanns’ apartment, two of Dr Kate McCann’s clothes, one of their children’s T-shirts, on the pink soft toy, ‘Cuddle Cat’, and in two places in the Renault Scenic that the McCanns hired. Eddie did not alert to a corpse scent anywhere else in Praia da Luz. Keela detected blood at some of these places. How do the McCanns best explain the ‘alerts’ of these two highly trained springer spaniels? (In 2008, Portuguese TV interviewer Sandra Felgueira asked Dr Gerald McCann: “How can you explain the scent of cadaver found by the British dogs?” Dr McCann answered, and we quote verbatim: “Ask the dogs, Sandra”).
DR KATE MCCANN'S ANSWER: The dogs reacted to the unprofessional Martin Grime who basically led the dogs to alert wherever he was interested himself; in other words, the dogs were merely seeking to please their owner and were not really alerting to anything.
I trust that that is a fair summary of what we have so far. If anyone thinks that Dr Kate McCann has answered or attempted to answer any of the remaining 159 questions we asked, please let me know.
I
Tony Bennett- Researcher
- Posts : 16906
Activity : 24770
Likes received : 3749
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 76
Location : Shropshire
Similar topics
» Robert Murat's links with Oasis Club, Norwich
» Stevo to David Kirwan and David Kirwan to Stevo 27 Sep 2009
» JATYK - 100 replies on the topic of that letter to Carter-Ruck - but not one dealing with all the inconsistencies
» Answers to 4 FOI Questions - the rest were not answered
» Madeleine 10 years on: ANOTHER 48 QUESTIONS that need to be answered!
» Stevo to David Kirwan and David Kirwan to Stevo 27 Sep 2009
» JATYK - 100 replies on the topic of that letter to Carter-Ruck - but not one dealing with all the inconsistencies
» Answers to 4 FOI Questions - the rest were not answered
» Madeleine 10 years on: ANOTHER 48 QUESTIONS that need to be answered!
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: Books on the Madeleine McCann case :: Kate McCann's book, Prosecution Exhibit 1: 'madeleine'
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum