Re: Discussion thread for Bernt's SECOND interview with James English

by **AnneCGuedes** 12.12.24 21:48

Jill Havern wrote:Bernt obtained Joana's permission to use her translation, which she gladly gave.

Joana told you ? How is she ?

by **Jill Havern** 12.12.24 21:51

She's as lovely as ever. A real sweetheart.

by **Jill Havern** 12.12.24 21:53

She also said this:

Sending you a big heartfelt hug and bravo for your admirable persistance

Beijinhos to all and the very best to the friends in the forum

by pinkgladioli 12.12.24 21:58

Jill Havern wrote:
pinkgladioli wrote:
Jill Havern wrote:
Liz Eagles wrote:How many heavy duty black bin bags are to be found in a holiday apartment?
For a family of 5 staying for a week, with many neighbouring friends, maybe the cleaner put a whole new roll of bags in the kitchen cupboard.

I don't think she was in bin bags alone - more like a suit bag inside a bin bag possibly - especially as he was carrying her over his shoulder with both hands...surely she'd have just fallen out the bottom of bin bags if he didn't have one hand underneath to support her.
Suit bag is deffo extremely plausible
It's an awful thought though isn't it?
It wasn't the best of holidays to be fair.

Hmmmm....

Yes it is horrible, I just hope it’s one step closer to the end of it

by **CaKeLoveR** 12.12.24 22:16

There was a snarky comment directed at us in the podcast big grin

. I don't think we'll lose any sleep over it.

by **AnneCGuedes** 12.12.24 22:18

Jill Havern wrote:
It's an awful thought though isn't it?

What kind of sudden impulse is it to wrap the still-warm body of your little daughter, the victim of a domestic accident, in a plastic garbage bag? I'd rather speak of an insane impulse.

by **Jill Havern** 12.12.24 22:23

CaKeLoveR wrote:There was a snarky comment directed at us in the podcast . I don't think we'll lose any sleep over it.

Really? I must have missed that...do tell.

by pinkgladioli 12.12.24 22:26

CaKeLoveR wrote:There was a snarky comment directed at us in the podcast . I don't think we'll lose any sleep over it.

? I can’t recall anything untoward’s being said

by **Jill Havern** 12.12.24 22:27

AnneCGuedes wrote:
Jill Havern wrote:
It's an awful thought though isn't it?

What kind of sudden impulse is it to wrap the still-warm body of your little daughter, the victim of a domestic accident, in a plastic garbage bag? I'd rather speak of an insane impulse.

It was Gerry who used the term 'sudden impulse' to describe the 'disappearance' of Maddie by the fairytale 'abductor'...Bernt just used it too.

by crusader 12.12.24 22:28

I saw a comment saying something about the Jill Havern forum .

The Jill Haven forum are expecting some bombshells with this one, but I'm much harder than them to please.

by **AnneCGuedes** 12.12.24 22:34

Jill Havern wrote:It was Gerry who used the term 'sudden impulse' to describe the 'disappearance' of Maddie by the fairytale 'abductor'...Bernt just used it too.

It was Jim Gamble who used the term "sudden impulse" when dictating to G what he should write in his blog to attract the kidnapper.
I don't think JG had that kind of bad choice in his mind.

by **CaKeLoveR** 12.12.24 22:35

That's it, Crusader.

by **Jill Havern** 12.12.24 22:36

AnneCGuedes wrote:
Jill Havern wrote:It was Gerry who used the term 'sudden impulse' to describe the 'disappearance' of Maddie by the fairytale 'abductor'...Bernt just used it too.

It was Jim Gamble who used the term "sudden impulse" when dictating to G what he should write in his blog to attract the kidnapper.
I don't think JG had that kind of bad choice in his mind.

Oh ok, I stand corrected thumbsup

by pinkgladioli 12.12.24 22:38

AnneCGuedes wrote:
Jill Havern wrote:It was Gerry who used the term 'sudden impulse' to describe the 'disappearance' of Maddie by the fairytale 'abductor'...Bernt just used it too.

It was Jim Gamble who used the term "sudden impulse" when dictating to G what he should write in his blog to attract the kidnapper.
I don't think JG had that kind of bad choice in his mind.

You’ve mentioned this before, personally I dont think it matters Bernt took it from Gerry’s blog

by **AnneCGuedes** 12.12.24 22:47

pinkgladioli wrote:You’ve mentioned this before, personally I dont think it matters Bernt took it from Gerry’s blog

BS uses this expression as if G produced it. He didn't, he copied what JG dictated. I think it matters.

by Jojo1 12.12.24 23:18

Well I found it all very intriguing. Well done Bernt.
I was kind of hoping for a sneak peak of some hill footage but I totally get why he cannot show this yet for legal reasons.
Did anyone notice the board behind CM in the video of him speaking.....
" COMMSCON "
It made me chuckle. Con indeed.
I hadn't noticed it before tonight.

by Liz Eagles 13.12.24 5:25

So here we are (which is none the wiser) no material witness and a bin bag theory to support a timeline theory.

by **PeterMac** 13.12.24 6:52

Gerry is SEEN carrying a child sized bundle in a bin liner at 2am in the direction of the cemetery
on the day Madeleine will be reported missing 20 hours later . . .

And this forum is arguing about the TITLE OF A BOOK ! ! ! !

Seriously ?

by **Ladyinred** 13.12.24 6:57

Well, it is a discussion thread!

by pinkgladioli 13.12.24 7:09

PeterMac wrote:Gerry is SEEN carrying a child sized bundle in a bin liner at 2am in the direction of the cemetery
on the day Madeleine will be reported missing 20 hours later . . .

And this forum is arguing about the TITLE OF A BOOK ! ! ! !

Seriously ?

Not only carrying a child size bundle in a bin liner at 2am, it brought the so called last photo into focus, especially when this witness seen what sounds like Gerry and 3 children at the pool the previous Sunday

by **PeterMac** 13.12.24 7:18

Ladyinred wrote:Well, it is a discussion thread!

Perhaps we should have another thread titled
Irrelevant Trivia

by **Ladyinred** 13.12.24 7:20

There are lots of those

by **Bluebagthepirate** 13.12.24 7:29

PeterMac wrote:
Ladyinred wrote:Well, it is a discussion thread!

Perhaps we should have another thread titled
Irrelevant Trivia

Or Molehill nit-picking.

by **CaKeLoveR** 13.12.24 10:07

It's ironic that we have discussed Gerry McCann walking around carrying his deceased daughter, and here we are again.

by **Jill Havern** 13.12.24 10:10

CaKeLoveR wrote:It's ironic that we have discussed Gerry McCann walking around carrying his deceased daughter, and here we are again.

Except this time he's GerryMcCannwithabinbagthenightbeforeMan and not Smithman.

by **CaKeLoveR** 13.12.24 10:46

It was much mocked, though .

by Justice for Maddie 13.12.24 10:48

CaKeLoveR wrote:It's ironic that we have discussed Gerry McCann walking around carrying his deceased daughter, and here we are again.

Yes, and the most shocking part is that he carried her in a trash bag. Just horrible.

by **Bluebagthepirate** 13.12.24 10:52

Jill Havern wrote:
CaKeLoveR wrote:It's ironic that we have discussed Gerry McCann walking around carrying his deceased daughter, and here we are again.
Except this time he's GerryMcCannwithabinbagthenightbeforeMan and not Smithman.

Precisely.

by **Nina** 13.12.24 11:02

Bernt mentioned that the window was open and blinds up and the door being open as Gerry walked along the walkway to the car park. No sound though so where was Kate during this time if it was silent. No mention of sound.
If her child's body was being carried away regardless of the circumstances how could she remain silent?

by **Nina** 13.12.24 11:03

Justice for Maddie wrote:
CaKeLoveR wrote:It's ironic that we have discussed Gerry McCann walking around carrying his deceased daughter, and here we are again.

Yes, and the most shocking part is that he carried her in a trash bag. Just horrible.

Yes but practical.

Latest topics