The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Welcome to 'The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann' forum 🌹

Please log in, or register to view all the forums as some of them are 'members only', then settle in and help us get to the truth about what really happened to Madeleine Beth McCann.

When you register please do NOT use your email address for a username because everyone will be able to see it!

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Mm11

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Regist10

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

View previous topic View next topic Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Tony Bennett on 14.05.18 23:24

Richard D Hall's latest crime investigation is out on DVD, available for sale at this link:

http://www.richplanet.net/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=287

I have seen it, all 2.5 hours, and offer my review below.

This is Richard's official intro to this film:

"Following on from the success of his Madeleine McCann investigative films, Richard D. Hall turns his attention to the 1999 assassination of Jill Dando. There are many theories about why she was murdered. This film looks at all of them and brings comprehensive evidence to light, which was not considered by the official investigation. Richard D. Hall firmly believes the hunt for the killer was deliberately steered, by British Intelligence, away from the true perpetrators. If the state becomes involved in a crime, then the police, who are run by the state, will never be allowed to solve it. Prepare to open your mind and discover the truth behind one of the UK's most prominent unsolved murders".

MY REVIEW

I can't give the plot away but I can say that the first half of this film puts together a number of pieces of information relating to the killing of Jill Dando which, in his usual manner, Richard has researched in depth, with visits to actual locations, interviews with relevant individuals, and ending up with a convincing alternative explanation for Jill Dando's murder which no-one hitherto has even thought possible.

All I will say is that it is related to dramatic events in the lead-up to the day Jill was assassinated in cold blood.

One of the main interests in the case, which has been discussed before on CMOMM, is the eerie series of parallels between the disappearance of Madeleine McCann and the murder of Jill Dando. These Richard highlights in his film.

To mention some:

DANDO: BBC reporter Clarence Mitchell first at the scene
McCANN: Head of the Media Monitoring Unit Clarence Mitchell PR representative for the McCanns for 11 years

======

DANDO: DCSupt Hamish Campbell was the Met Police Officer who ran the wholly discredited, wrongful prosecution of Barry Bulsara/George for Jill's murder
McCANN: DCSupt Hamish Campbell in 2011 devised the remit for Operation Grange which was to "only investigate an abduction scenario " (recently criticised by Colin Sutton) 

=====

DANDO: Phantom suspect/perpetrator: Barry Bulsara/George
McCANN: Phantom suspect abductors: Tannerman, Sagresman, Smithman, Monsterman...and dozens of others

=====

(DANDO:
(McCANN:   Deliberate media spin and suppression of facts in both cases
=====

(DANDO:
(McCANN:    Significant involvement of state security services in both cases.


Before watching, I rather doubted that Richard could come up with a valid alternative to the two main rival theories so far about why Jill Dando was murdered, namely (a) it was ordered by career criminal Kenneth Noye or (b) that she had stumbled on Savile/a paedophile ring at the BBC. 

But I think he has succeeded in establishing a credible alternative scenario. 

motive for the killing is supplied - and a motive for what he suggests was the ‘fitting-up’ of Barry Bulsara/George who, it will be recalled, spent an amazing 8 years in jail for a crime he most certainly did not commit. A Court of Appeal hearing eventually freed him. 

Richard plays parts of the last Crimewatch Jill Dando ever fronted and points out clues to Jill Dando's murder within those clips.

Fascinating research as usual    




.

____________________

Dr Martin Roberts: "The evidence is that these are the pjyamas Madeleine wore on holiday in Praia da Luz. They were photographed and the photo handed to a press agency, who released it on 8 May, as the search for Madeleine continued. The McCanns held up these same pyjamas at two press conferences on 5 & 7June 2007. How could Madeleine have been abducted?"

Amelie Mcann (aged 2): "Maddie's jammies!".  

Tony Bennett
Tony Bennett
Researcher

Posts : 15497
Join date : 2009-11-25
Age : 71
Location : Shropshire

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Marco on 15.05.18 22:38

I noticed Hamish being appointed by grange at the time and the hairs on the back of my neck went up after watching the Dando op unfold. Can't wait to see another RDH film.
Marco
Marco

Posts : 44
Join date : 2018-05-11

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Philo Beddoe on 11.06.18 1:17

I watched this today and I found it extremely interesting, particularly the reaction of Mr Hatcher on the Crimewatch episode next to Jill.  As Tony has previously mentioned I too saw many similarities in the narrative direction from the 'establishment' to Madeleine's government cover up and I've always thought Nick Ross was hiding something about Jill's murder.  I'd be interested in seeing what Nick Ross's views are on Madeleine's disappearance given his suspicion of guilt regarding Barry George taking into account his statement "I thought the evidence against him was very compelling indeed as long as you think of evidence not in the way an English court thinks of evidence - an overwhelming mass of circumstantial evidence - evidence of things/arrows pointed at his guilt".  If ever a statement summed up the case of parental involvement in Madeleine's disappearance, that was very near the top.
Philo Beddoe
Philo Beddoe

Posts : 94
Join date : 2017-05-10

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by JRP on 13.06.18 9:56

I went to see Richard at the Liverpool leg of his tour, and purchased the Kill Jill DVD.

It takes a route I hadn't known about, and while I can't disagree with his reasoning and research, there are one or two points which bother me.

The main point I have is this.
Jill Dando had moved out of her house and gone to live with her boyfriend. She visited her own house occasionally which I believe was up for sale. 
How did the killer know she would be there that day, and at that particular time? 

Jill Dando's job as a presenter on Crimewatch included reading out messages which were phoned in to the show. Jill wasn't presenting her own theory, she was reading a message from a viewer.
Is that a reason to have her shot on her own doorstep?
avatar
JRP

Posts : 601
Join date : 2016-03-07
Age : 61
Location : UK

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Amy Dean on 13.06.18 10:33

I have always wondered how anyone knew that Jill would be at her house at that particular time and on that day when she rarely ever went there.
Amy Dean
Amy Dean

Posts : 332
Join date : 2014-11-13
Location : Wherever I hang my hat

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by BlueBag on 13.06.18 12:02

@JRP wrote:Jill Dando's job as a presenter on Crimewatch included reading out messages which were phoned in to the show. Jill wasn't presenting her own theory, she was reading a message from a viewer.
Is that a reason to have her shot on her own doorstep?
I watched the video.

I think the reasoning is that she was aware of information not allowed (suppressed) to be transmitted that indicated the Police were aware of the bomber or someone (intelligence) was surveilling him.

Also.. I think... that Jill slipped in the binoculars message herself... the video mentions the eye rub just before she does it.

The video suggests that Jill messed with the wrong people and she possibly became a "national security" risk.
BlueBag
BlueBag

Posts : 4990
Join date : 2014-06-06

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by polyenne on 13.06.18 13:46

If it was indeed a "professional" hit, then I'm in no doubt that they would not have been lying in wait hoping she might show up, she would have been followed such that, at an opportune time (if one can call it that), the gunman strikes.

On her doorstep in the middle of the day with no-one around was evidently the perfect time and, assuming she had driven to Gowan Avenue, the gunman too would have been in a car, probably with an accomplice, and was driven away immediately. Thus the man in a suit running away was likely another red herring.
avatar
polyenne

Posts : 963
Join date : 2017-03-31

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by polyenne on 13.06.18 13:47

PS, Barry George it was most certainly NOT
avatar
polyenne

Posts : 963
Join date : 2017-03-31

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by JimbobJones on 13.06.18 15:21

. . . . how many OTHER innocent people might those bad cops have sent to jail? It seems to be their Modus Operandi.
avatar
JimbobJones

Posts : 195
Join date : 2016-05-05

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by nomendelta on 15.06.18 11:36

I found this very compelling - I don't know for sure if he's hit the nail on the head but he's certainly done enough to point out the serious anomalies in the investigation.

Point of interest. The Nail Bomber is spotted on CCTV wearing a white baseball cap. The "perpetrator" of the Jo Cox murder (another source of an excellent video by Hall) was wearing a white baseball cap with stories stating the murderer wore a black cap when he struck then changed it to white then back to black again...
avatar
nomendelta

Posts : 336
Join date : 2011-05-20

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Richard D Hall

Post by willowthewisp on 15.06.18 14:55

@nomendelta wrote:I found this very compelling - I don't know for sure if he's hit the nail on the head but he's certainly done enough to point out the serious anomalies in the investigation.

Point of interest. The Nail Bomber is spotted on CCTV wearing a white baseball cap. The "perpetrator" of the Jo Cox murder (another source of an excellent video by Hall) was wearing a white baseball cap with stories stating the murderer wore a black cap when he struck then changed it to white then back to black again...
Perhaps that is a coded message,(White hat in preparation,Black Hat,target hit) you will have Textusa theory of Government Black,White Caps,but alas,White is associated to innocence,Black is associated to Death!

It does seem rather "Odd" that the person(Tommy) was seen wearing a white cap in the CCTV,but it isn't clear that it is Tommy Mair?
It puts a person on the same street as the Murdered victim at an approximate time,but Mr Mair is followed and awaits in a Cul-de-Sac for Twenty minutes,to where he is arrested wearing a now "Black Cap"?
Yet people are not informed of "Forensic evidence from the victim" not visible on clothes when arrested,but apparently shot full on,then stabbed multiple times,sorry but too much of a coincidence,not to have any samples of the victims blood,if you where the perpetrator of the murder ?
willowthewisp
willowthewisp

Posts : 3277
Join date : 2015-05-07

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Mainline on 29.03.19 9:34

Hamish Campbell: 'Case will never be solved'

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-47742654

The detective who led the inquiry into Jill Dando's murder has told the BBC her case will never be solved.
Hamish Campbell told a documentary to mark 20 years since the newsreader's shooting: "Do I think somebody will come back to court? Probably not, no."
His team arrested Barry George in 2000, one year after Dando, 37, was killed on her doorstep in Fulham, west London.
Mr George was convicted of murder and spent eight years in jail, before being acquitted at a retrial and released.
In the second trial, the jury accepted that one particle of gunshot residue found in the pocket of a coat police retrieved from Mr George's house was insufficient to place him at the scene of the murder.
It had been the key forensic evidence relied on by detectives.

Ms Dando was a popular presenter of programmes such as the Six O'Clock News, Breakfast News, Crimewatch and Holiday.
The BBC has said "previously unseen archive and photographs" will feature in the documentary, alongside interviews with Jill's colleagues, friends and family members.
The film reveals the decision-making behind the scenes of the murder inquiry.
Mr Campbell told the programme that senior officers were pressing him on the likelihood of the case being resolved.
"Sometimes I felt we were a day away from solving it and other times, I thought 'no, we're a long way away'," he said.
  Image caption  Mr Campbell tells the BBC about the difficulties in investigating "stranger homicides"  
More than 2,000 people had been named as potential suspects.
"Some actions to trace and eliminate one person might take a day. One action might take two weeks," Mr Campbell said.
"But there's thousands of them and that's the issue of managing stranger homicides."
The film will also show how BBC director general Tony Hall, then the corporation's head of news, was targeted with three telephone threats in the weeks after Ms Dando's murder.
"I listened to the voice of one of them, which said basically, I was next," he told the programme.
Lord Hall said he had "no idea" if the threat was real.
"There are often copycat things that happen after these sorts of events, and the police took it seriously."
The Murder of Jill Dando will be shown on BBC One at 21:00 BST on Tuesday 2 April.
Mainline
Mainline

Posts : 106
Join date : 2018-10-01

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by willowthewisp on 30.03.19 14:39

Hi Mainline, thanks for your article above.

I would state due to the amount of time resources spent on Child Abuse going back over Fifty-Sixty yrs or More by the Establishment to keep it from being exposed as to a reason why Miss Jill Dando was Murdered on her door step.

Now we have Boris and "Spaffing it up the Wall" £60 Million spent on old child abuse cases, £53 Million on Garden Bridge eh Boris!

Add into the facts of what Miss Dando had revealed to her BBC Bosses on or about a "Cigar" reptile about to be exposed and his connections to MI5/6,Mossad, IRA could be the perpetrators of the Murder?

Hamish Campbell, Barry George the new Guyfawkes, Gunpowder residue, then throw in the Madeleine McCann case he worked on with DCI Andy Redwood, "Creche Dad", Crime Watch October 14, 2013, DCI Simon Foy, BBC Panorama,Richard Bilton, Fabrication Fodder!
willowthewisp
willowthewisp

Posts : 3277
Join date : 2015-05-07

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by kaz on 30.03.19 16:20

Actually another similarity with the MMC case was the ( accidental ? ) trashing of the crime scene degrading it for subsequent  forensic work . 
There were THREE doctors present at the Jill Dando crime scene all of whom insisted on trying to resuscitate her even though she was quite obviously already dead.
avatar
kaz

Posts : 497
Join date : 2014-08-18

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Amy Dean on 31.03.19 3:15

I don't think I've heard about there being three doctors at the scene. As far as I'm aware, she was taken to hospital still alive and declared dead there. 

Do you mean paramedics perhaps? They would obviously have done what they could to help her.
Amy Dean
Amy Dean

Posts : 332
Join date : 2014-11-13
Location : Wherever I hang my hat

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by kaz on 31.03.19 14:30

@Amy Dean wrote:I don't think I've heard about there being three doctors at the scene. As far as I'm aware, she was taken to hospital still alive and declared dead there. 

Do you mean paramedics perhaps? They would obviously have done what they could to help her.
DCI Hamish Campbell stated there were 3 doctors in attendance at the crime scene and  were attempting to resuscitate Dando even though she was obviously dead.  This was stated as being part of the '' mistakes made'' . The article was in the Telegraph earlier this week.
avatar
kaz

Posts : 497
Join date : 2014-08-18

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by Amy Dean on 31.03.19 15:32

Amy Dean
Amy Dean

Posts : 332
Join date : 2014-11-13
Location : Wherever I hang my hat

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by kaz on 31.03.19 15:55

I've just had my nose in the litter bin to find this paper:

Telegraph 29th March ; PEOPLE WERE JUST SPOUTING RIDICULOUS THEORIES.

Direct quotes  from DCI Hamish Campbell in quotation marks.
The high profile nature of the case ,he says , meant the volume of information to be dealt with became '' almost insurmountable''. He also believes the emergency services ' decision to attempt to resuscitate Dando when she was '' clearly dead'' at the scene may have contaminated or destroyed forensic evidence.
'' There were three doctors . Any one of them could have declared her dead'' he says. '' That would have stopped any further activity ''.


I'll try and get the whole article up on site if I can because I have also noticed that these observations of his seem to be missing from on line versions.
avatar
kaz

Posts : 497
Join date : 2014-08-18

Back to top Go down

A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando Empty Re: A review of 'KILL JILL', the latest DVD investigation by Richard D Hall, on the murder of Jill Dando

Post by willowthewisp on 31.03.19 16:20

@kaz wrote:
I've just had my nose in the litter bin to find this paper:

Telegraph 29th March ; PEOPLE WERE JUST SPOUTING RIDICULOUS THEORIES.

Direct quotes  from DCI Hamish Campbell in quotation marks.
The high profile nature of the case ,he says , meant the volume of information to be dealt with became '' almost insurmountable''. He also believes the emergency services ' decision to attempt to resuscitate Dando when she was '' clearly dead'' at the scene may have contaminated or destroyed forensic evidence.
'' There were three doctors . Any one of them could have declared her dead'' he says. '' That would have stopped any further activity ''.


I'll try and get the whole article up on site if I can because I have also noticed that these observations of his seem to be missing from on line versions.
Ever crossed anyone's mind, DCI Hamish Campbell covering his own backside of negligence of a "Crime Scene" if your the Lead Investigator, Not like MSM have criticised former Portugal PJ Detective Mr Goncalo Amaral, Miss Sandra Felguieras, Netflix 8 episodes of Madeleine McCann disappearance, DNA/LCI evidence is it?

The UK Courts released Mr George after Eight years of a served Prison sentence, based on "One Fleck" of Gunpowder Residue found on his coat found by Forensic Officers by Metropolitan Police Service,DCI Hamish Campbell's Team?

Also Remember South Yorkshire Police Officers, Forensic Work on Ben Needham, "Speck of Blood Toy Car, Bens" that turned out to be Not proved as Ben's Blood, when compared to Family DNA!

Right now, top of the Agenda,discredit DNA/LCI as inconclusive to belong to Madeleine McCann, New DNA/LCI pattern testing procedures, that a former "Forensic FSS" from Birmingham may have had tested since 2012, Seven years ago, Operation Grange knew about, kept quiet about?

Yes, the same Team that "Contaminated the samples from Portugal" 15:19, 17:20 inconclusive evidence, yet Leicestershire Police Officers stated, we have charged people with this level of DNA/LCI in UK!

Twelve years later Zilch?
willowthewisp
willowthewisp

Posts : 3277
Join date : 2015-05-07

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum