'Smithman' and the dogs
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: British Police / Government Interference :: Smithman: Crimewatch Reconstruction and the appeal for new info / suspects
Page 1 of 1 • Share
'Smithman' and the dogs
I've been trying to sort out the various permutations of the possible results of the 'Crimewatch' appeal, and I can't seem to get away from the feeling that in the end, it will all come down to the dogs. This is how I've been trying to sort it out:
'Smithman' is a suspect and Andy Redwood will either
a) identify him and arrest him
b)identify and eliminate him( as he did 'Jane Tannerman')
c)not be able to identify him
Look at it this way
a) Mr Totally-New- Suspect is arrested and accused.
Whoa! his defence lawyer says- Let's point the finger elsewhere-What about the evidence of Eddie and Keela? 'Unreliable' you say?
Okay, and what about the evidence of the sniffer dogs who followed a trail to the car park area? 'Unreliable' too? Was normal procedure followed?
b)Mr Totally-Believable-Only -just remembered -it -was -me after-six-years -of media-saturation-New-Suspect comes forward and is eliminated.
Back to zero.What other leads are there? See a) above
c) Despite a huge campaign covering all relevant countries,- Portugal Britain, Portugal Netherlands, Portugal, Germany, Portugal Ireland, no-one is identified. Time to go back to zero. See a) above
Of course there is another possibility. 'Smithman' is identified but he is not a totally new suspect. In which case Whoops! What shall we say about the 'evidence' of British dogs? Are those dogs reliable or unreliable? But on the other hand, the trail followed by the sniffer dogs , leading in a different direction,suggesting a different perpetrator could that be reliable, as it points away from the 'Smithman ' sighting?
Whoever gets arrested, the 'evidence' of the dogs is bound to come up.
Surely we can have it both ways, can't we? The dogs are both reliable and unreliable? Catch 22?
IMO
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1042254/Aerial-photo-shows-sniffer-dog-trail-following-Madeleines-scent-took-nearby-car-park.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2458369/Could-Madeleine-McCann-Crimewatch-reconstruction-end-distasteful-slurs-Kate-Gerry.html
'Smithman' is a suspect and Andy Redwood will either
a) identify him and arrest him
b)identify and eliminate him( as he did 'Jane Tannerman')
c)not be able to identify him
Look at it this way
a) Mr Totally-New- Suspect is arrested and accused.
Whoa! his defence lawyer says- Let's point the finger elsewhere-What about the evidence of Eddie and Keela? 'Unreliable' you say?
Okay, and what about the evidence of the sniffer dogs who followed a trail to the car park area? 'Unreliable' too? Was normal procedure followed?
b)Mr Totally-Believable-Only -just remembered -it -was -me after-six-years -of media-saturation-New-Suspect comes forward and is eliminated.
Back to zero.What other leads are there? See a) above
c) Despite a huge campaign covering all relevant countries,
Of course there is another possibility. 'Smithman' is identified but he is not a totally new suspect. In which case Whoops! What shall we say about the 'evidence' of British dogs? Are those dogs reliable or unreliable? But on the other hand, the trail followed by the sniffer dogs , leading in a different direction,suggesting a different perpetrator could that be reliable, as it points away from the 'Smithman ' sighting?
Whoever gets arrested, the 'evidence' of the dogs is bound to come up.
Surely we can have it both ways, can't we? The dogs are both reliable and unreliable? Catch 22?
IMO
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1042254/Aerial-photo-shows-sniffer-dog-trail-following-Madeleines-scent-took-nearby-car-park.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2458369/Could-Madeleine-McCann-Crimewatch-reconstruction-end-distasteful-slurs-Kate-Gerry.html
worriedmum- Posts : 2062
Activity : 2819
Likes received : 583
Join date : 2012-01-17
Similar topics
» SMITHMAN 8 - The Nine Phases of Smithman - How the Smiths became part of the McCann Team in January 2008
» SMITHMAN 7: What is the actual evidence that makes people think that ‘Smithman’ was Gerry McCann?
» SMITHMAN 9 - Is Goncalo Amaral sticking to his original conclusions re Smithman?
» SMITHMAN 6: Smithman re-evaluated in the light of Richard Hall's film 'THE PHANTOMS' - The discussion on FB 'Madeleine McCann - Abduction or Scam'
» SMITHMAN 2 - What can account for the 17 remarkable similarities between Tannerman and Smithman?
» SMITHMAN 7: What is the actual evidence that makes people think that ‘Smithman’ was Gerry McCann?
» SMITHMAN 9 - Is Goncalo Amaral sticking to his original conclusions re Smithman?
» SMITHMAN 6: Smithman re-evaluated in the light of Richard Hall's film 'THE PHANTOMS' - The discussion on FB 'Madeleine McCann - Abduction or Scam'
» SMITHMAN 2 - What can account for the 17 remarkable similarities between Tannerman and Smithman?
The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ :: British Police / Government Interference :: Smithman: Crimewatch Reconstruction and the appeal for new info / suspects
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum