The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™
Hi,

A very warm welcome to The Complete Mystery of Madeleine McCann™ forum.

Please log in, or register to view all the forums, then settle in and start chatting with us!

Enjoy your day,

Jill Havern
Forum owner

Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Page 2 of 5 Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next

View previous topic View next topic Go down

as posted elsewhere by me....

Post by russiandoll on 14.10.11 11:06

I never lie because I dont fear anyone. You only lie when you are afraid. [ John Gotti.]


No man has a good enough memory to make a successful liar [Abraham Lincoln]

With lies you may get ahead in the world- but you can never go back [ Russian proverb].

russiandoll

Posts : 3942
Reputation : 7
Join date : 2011-09-11

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Me on 14.10.11 12:37

@steevo1962 wrote:
Kate sort of saying ‘Oh bet he’s put the footy on’, because I think there
was a football match that night and she sort of said ‘Oh I think he’s probably’, erm,
you know, ‘got side tracked and put the telly on and catch up on the score’, so he
was gone a bit longer than normal

Could this be when the accident actually happened?

Also regarding the check done by Jane Tanner, I believe the others including JT entered their flats via the front door which was on the main street where the alleged abductor came from. If she went that way, wouldn't she have noticed the shutter and window "wide open" as Kate described on finding them in her check?

The PJ know that they are lying, mis-leading whatever one wants to call it?

We know and I'm sure many supporters quietly feel uneasy that they have been duped by their knee-jerk emotions into supporting both financially and spiritually a charade of events which only hindered rather than helped in the search for poor wee Madeleine!

Yes, that's something that has cropped up before. Jane Tanner, Matt and Russell in their subsequent visits ( i think both of them went past but it may have been one of them) all walked past the front door of the McCann apartment but none of them noticed the shutter and window open. Ok!

Yet when Kate went and discovered Maddie missing the door whoosed because the window was open. Why didn't that happen when Gerry did his check?

Why did it only happen when Kate checked?

The only plausible explanation can be that the window wasn't open at the point of Gerry being in the apartment. So then we are supposed to believe that when Gerry left and was talking to Jez the abductor opened the shutter and window (with no-one hearing him and leaving no evidence) and climbed out / passed out Maddie whilt Gerry wa sin the next street!

Then we have to accept the absurdity of the abductor walking across the very road that Gerry & Jez are talking on and the road that the parents and their friends walked up and down all the time, when an abductor would surely have not taken that risk and would, one suspects, have walked the other way out of sight and using the cover of the complex wall.

Added to this we have the superhuman eyesight of Tanner, who from a distance in low light conditions can identify the type and colour of pyjamas the child was wearing.

That reconstruction is a disgrace, and has no credibility because they have essentially tried to tie up Tanner's sighting with the Smith's sighting as being the same person. Yet Martin Smith's statement, in the files, states that he thought it was Gerry with 60-80% accuracy.

____________________
What is certain is that since the start of the investigation there were  incongruent and even contradictory situations concerning the witness statements; the telephone records of calls that were made and received on mobile phones that belonged to the couple and to the group of friends that were on holidays with them; the movements of people right after the disappearance of the little girl was noticed, concerning the state in which the bedroom from where the child disappeared from was found (closed window? open window? partially open window?) etc., and the mystery would only become even thicker due to the clues that were left by the already mentioned sniffer dogs. - The Words of a JUDGE in relation to the McCanns

Me

Posts : 683
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2011-05-22

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by jd on 06.01.12 18:52

@dragonfly wrote:Does anyone know what Jane meant at 1.45 in video regarding football comment, When Jane and Gerry are disagreeing where they are standing , Jane says something like 'I would of said to you Kate had been moaning about you being gone along time watching the football? Gerry then cuts her off and Jane then really smiles , Watching football I thought they were all together having tapas , can someone fill me in ? Thanks


Oh he does totally cut her off doesn't't he!!! And remember we have the Moyes who were 2 floors up at that very time on their balcony saying how so very quiet it was

____________________
Who pulled the strings?...THE SYMINGTONS..And the Scottish connections...Look no further if you dare

jd

Posts : 4152
Reputation : 11
Join date : 2011-07-22

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Guest on 28.09.12 13:31

@jd wrote:
@dragonfly wrote:Does anyone know what Jane meant at 1.45 in video regarding football comment, When Jane and Gerry are disagreeing where they are standing , Jane says something like 'I would of said to you Kate had been moaning about you being gone along time watching the football? Gerry then cuts her off and Jane then really smiles , Watching football I thought they were all together having tapas , can someone fill me in ? Thanks


Oh he does totally cut her off doesn't't he!!! And remember we have the Moyes who were 2 floors up at that very time on their balcony saying how so very quiet it was

wow that is a very odd reaction from Gerry there! He defently want to get the attention away from what Jane just said there...And why the smile from Jane there aswell, the whole scene had a weird tone to it..

(TY Jean for linking to this thread, had forgotten all about it..)

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Nina on 28.09.12 14:07

So blooming obvious, and no-one picked it up and not mentioned again. So if Gerry was gone for long enough for Kate to think he was watching the football it was longer than a. the getting there to check the children, b. check the children c. maybe visit the toilet d. return to the bar. So longer than five minutes then. And not just a quick check of the football but actually watching it so quite some time then.
Does/could this link with the thread of the query digging of a grave in RM's garden.

Edited to add..... just read the SB thread and some posters were also querying whether there could be a link with the timings of SB.

____________________
Not one more cent from me.

Nina

Posts : 2627
Reputation : 215
Join date : 2011-06-16

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Ollie on 28.09.12 15:45

The camera doesn't look into the bedroom, I would of thought that as this is where Madeleine was allegedly snatched from the bedroom would have been filmed, but I think they know that it was too dark to see anything in there from the distance MO says he looked, confirming that either MO didn't do a check or if he did he wouldn't of been able to see anything anyway. You can see the bedroom door in another shot and it is pitch black in the room. This so called reconstruction was carefully choregraphed IMO.

Ollie

Posts : 262
Reputation : 6
Join date : 2011-05-22

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by dragonfly on 28.09.12 20:27

@Nina wrote:So blooming obvious, and no-one picked it up and not mentioned again. So if Gerry was gone for long enough for Kate to think he was watching the football it was longer than a. the getting there to check the children, b. check the children c. maybe visit the toilet d. return to the bar. So longer than five minutes then. And not just a quick check of the football but actually watching it so quite some time then.
Does/could this link with the thread of the query digging of a grave in RM's garden.

Edited to add..... just read the SB thread and some posters were also querying whether there could be a link with the timings of SB.
Im trying to go through the statements as from 8.30 it a mess everything is all contradictions starting from dinner I will concentrate on GM and JT movements
Russell O'Brien's interview on 04 May 2007
He recalls that Matthew Oldfield left the restaurant at shortly after 21h00 to check the children. He is no longer sure who went out first, but five minutes later, Gerry McCann and his own partner, Jane, went out, almost at the same time, to check the children. He thinks that Gerry must have gone out first because Jane saw him chatting with a person on holiday at the complex, a certain Jez. He thinks that Jane only checked their apartment, being worried about E**e. Then Gerry came back at around 21h25/21h30 and they started to eat the main course.
Jane's freudian 'I was carrying across the body

____________________


dragonfly

Posts : 318
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2011-03-01

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Ribisl on 29.09.12 9:35

@dragonfly It is a complete mess, isn't it? I am not so sure if Jane actually says 'I 'was carrying...?' though. It's almost as if she muffles the subject through her own lack of conviction ie 'he' is but a figment of her imagination.

The so called reconstruction is so utterly incredible and is clearly their effort to plant more lies in the media, at the same time muddling the fact they have consistently refused to return to the scene to do an official reconstruction as bid by the PJ.

The positioning of Jane and Gerry is very telling. In his statements Jeremy Wilkins says he was walking up the street when he saw Gerry came out of the gate and he (JW) therefore crossed the road to have a chat which only lasted 3-5 minutes. He even says Gerry had his back to the building ie looking out onto the street. So why does Gerry say he was on the other side of the road and facing the wall? Because he'd already said he never saw Jane nor the abductor and that is the only position he could possibly stand and claim both top and bottom of the street were outside his peripheral vision, without contradicting Jane's important sighting. And Jane is so obviously lying because there is no way she could have avoided being seen by Wilkins if she was where she says she was. Her tears must be from the stress and remorse from lying rather than for the imaginary abduction of Madeleine.

____________________
There is a taint of death, a flavour of mortality in lies... Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad

Ribisl

Posts : 807
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2012-02-04

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Ribisl on 03.10.12 18:58

I find it very strange that Jane's statement is not corroborated by Gerry if she was lying for the McCanns' benefit.

The image of the 'abductor' as witnessed by Jane has been bugging me lately. Agreed it's not normal to carry a child with outstretched arms, but what if he was carrying a dead one? You wouldn't necessarily hold a dead child close to you, especially if it's not your own. So could it have been Murat carrying dead Madeleine back to his house to hide?

____________________
There is a taint of death, a flavour of mortality in lies... Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad

Ribisl

Posts : 807
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2012-02-04

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by tigger on 03.10.12 19:06

@Ribisl wrote:I find it very strange that Jane's statement is not corroborated by Gerry if she was lying for the McCanns' benefit.

The image of the 'abductor' as witnessed by Jane has been bugging me lately. Agreed it's not normal to carry a child with outstretched arms, but what if he was carrying a dead one? You wouldn't necessarily hold a dead child close to you, especially if it's not your own. So could it have been Murat carrying dead Madeleine back to his house to hide?

Considering the clothes (fleece, jeans) found in a bag near the airport, (see November timeline) I have always thought that Jane described herself as carrying the child. In the video where she talks about this, she does say 'I' when demonstrating how she would carry a child normally. Either that or she had seen someone carrying the body like that. It was neither Murat nor Gerry imo. their clothes were free of cadaver odour. It cannot have been done in a public place, because it is such a strange way to carry a child, so it may have been the way someone did take her up from a bed or the floor. But she must have been moved from the apartment in a bag of sorts, I'd think.

____________________
Lasciate ogni speranza, voi ch'entrate.

tigger

Posts : 8112
Reputation : 24
Join date : 2011-07-20

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Guest on 03.10.12 19:11

@russiandoll wrote:this entire reconstruction is so insulting to the intelligence of most people, who did these idiots think they were dealing with in portimao.... inspector clouseau? and why is the man carrying the girl in the smith sighting section of this video depicted as having her in his arms and not upright and over his shoulder as clearly stated ? the very way of carrying her that made Mr Smith think it was Gerry when he saw him on tv getting off the plane in the UK carying his son this way, upright, arm dangling down, childs head on shoulder !
this so called reconstruction has clearly been made to dishonestly reinforce the story that it is the same man JT allegedly saw. It is not as described by Mr Smith . How on earth did Mc Canns and co manage to circulate this second sighting when it is not as told by the person who actually saw the man and child?
Did any reasonable person actually believe a man carrying out such a heinous crime would traipse around the place for such a long time? A sleeping toddler is some weight and erm would he not erm risk being erm seen ?

sorry but I have to say this and I hope you dont think I am disrespecting young Maddie, I am merely disrespecting her parents and their friends. There is more chance that Maddie is giving Willy Wonka his 2 pence worth at his chocolate factory, is with Peter Pan and Tinkerbell, or at the north pole in a new role as one of santas elves than her disappearance happened the way they tell it.
I have a sneaking feeling the police are playing a very patient waiting game. I think they are sitting on some evidence and that thank goodness the truth is eventually going to come out.

SY will not let PJ down.

I trust.

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Guest on 03.10.12 22:27

@Portia wrote:[...]
SY will not let PJ down.
I trust.
***
That's all I needed to hear to have a good night's sleep :-)

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by jd on 04.10.12 1:13

gerry mccann since day 1 (without any facts or knowledge) has only pushed 3 things: 1) Abduction... 2) Discredit the PJ..... 3) Push Physics and Mediums

Andy Redwood is 2 things 1) A brilliant detective in his own right...... 2) Employed purely to tow the Government line (which I know from actual fact of the Jill Dando case)

In the review so far and from what he has said, Andy Redwood has said 1) Abduction (as if it happened in the UK) and 2) Totally supported Physics and Mediums...2 of the 3 gerry mccann pushed theories, and not said anything about any other theory despite the very over whelming facts

This says very clearly to me he is employed purely to tow the Government line and to support gerry mccann theories despite anything, and in the end to defunct the case....But I hope he is in reality being the Andy Redwood number 1) the brilliant detective...Only time will tell




____________________
Who pulled the strings?...THE SYMINGTONS..And the Scottish connections...Look no further if you dare

jd

Posts : 4152
Reputation : 11
Join date : 2011-07-22

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Ribisl on 04.10.12 10:19

@tigger wrote:
@Ribisl wrote:I find it very strange that Jane's statement is not corroborated by Gerry if she was lying for the McCanns' benefit.

The image of the 'abductor' as witnessed by Jane has been bugging me lately. Agreed it's not normal to carry a child with outstretched arms, but what if he was carrying a dead one? You wouldn't necessarily hold a dead child close to you, especially if it's not your own. So could it have been Murat carrying dead Madeleine back to his house to hide?

Considering the clothes (fleece, jeans) found in a bag near the airport, (see November timeline) I have always thought that Jane described herself as carrying the child. In the video where she talks about this, she does say 'I' when demonstrating how she would carry a child normally. Either that or she had seen someone carrying the body like that. It was neither Murat nor Gerry imo. their clothes were free of cadaver odour. It cannot have been done in a public place, because it is such a strange way to carry a child, so it may have been the way someone did take her up from a bed or the floor. But she must have been moved from the apartment in a bag of sorts, I'd think.
I don't think a woman could carry a child that size in that position for long, so I think it was a man. Because Gerry appears to be doing everything to discredit her sighting and it is totally uncorroborated, I am now beginning to think this in fact could have been true amongst so many lies.

____________________
There is a taint of death, a flavour of mortality in lies... Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad

Ribisl

Posts : 807
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2012-02-04

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Guest on 14.10.13 13:59

Bumping this old topic up as the football match query has resurfaced.

See http://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8014-may-07-a-football-fest

Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Woofer on 15.10.13 16:57

I thought Textusa or someone had done a write-up of this, but I can`t find it.

Several people have doubts about where GM was at 9.30 - 10pm, so it might be worth looking again at Tapas Bar workers, other diners etc. statements.

It seems, from 2 statements I`ve looked at so far (just the Tapas workers that were there) that the furore started well before 10.pm - more like 9.20. and the Tapas 9 had all vacated the table (except for Diane) at about 9.40.

Arlindo Epifanio Goncalves Fernandes Peleja - Executive Chef
 He records that the past Thursday, 3rd of May, he left the central kitchen with the objective of going to the Tapas restaurant in order to determine that everything was functioning smoothly;
. When he arrived there, by vehicle, at around 21:10, he remembers that next to the Tapas reception, he saw a vehicle, dark blue in colour, with Portuguese license plates. Although he cannot be definite, he believes it was a Fiesta or Focus. The deponent furthers that is was not a small car, and for this reason it could very well have been a Focus and not a Fiesta. He tells that he does not remember any sticker indicating that it was
a rental car. Inside the vehicle he saw no one.
. After parking his vehicle, he entered through the reception of that restaurant, in the left hand direction, toward the side opposite the pool, and passed by the esplanade. He remembers having seen in that esplanade, one table, occupied by three couples, without children, and all of them adults. On the esplanade, he encountered no one else.
. A few minutes later, when it was around 21H20, he heard some clamour, which made him leave toward the restaurant, a few meters away, and was then informed that a child had disappeared. Given the importance of this, believed that he should be in the surroundings. At that moment, he did not leave the area of the restaurant, and did not have the opportunity to check if the vehicle mentioned before was situated in the same location;
. Later, at around 21:40, he left the restaurant passing through the same esplanade where moments before, he had seen the same table occupied by the three couples, empty, who had left in the meanwhile various items, principally clothing. He was told by his colleagues that the child who had disappeared was a child of one of those couples;
. When he left, he noticed that the dark blue vehicle was no longer in its location (previously noted) and does not know of the existence or any connection between the presence of that vehicle and the disappearance of the child;
. Ending, states that during the days that preceded the facts, he did not notice any element/individual/fact that would have merited his attention;
. And nothing more said, having read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it; 
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ARLINDO-PELEGA.htm



Ricardo Alexandre da Luz Oliveira - Tapas Restaurant Waiter
"Dinner would end at about 21.45, a few minutes later the witness looked at the table and saw that there was nobody there and one of his colleagues told them that all the guests had left the table in a hurry. In any case, he remembers having heard shouts from the direction of Madeleine's parents' apartment."

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RICARDO-A-D-L-OLIVEIRA.htm


Jeronimo Tomas Rodrigues Salcedas - Barman/Waiter
"At that time, at about 22.20 - 22.30 he noticed that there was only one person sitting at the group's table, the oldest of them and he asked her jokingly whether they had left her alone."

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/J-T-R-Salcedas.htm


Is this the same person as above ? ~

JERONIMO RODRIGUES SALCEDAS - Occupation: Fitness Instructor
"On the night Madeleine disappeared, everything appeared normal. I remember that when I took notice of the disappearance, I had been in the restaurant speaking with my two colleagues?Ze and Ricardo who were on break. I returned to the restaurant and noticed that the table of nine was empty with the exception of the older woman. I went over to the table and joked with her: ?They've left you alone?? She responded more of less with these words: ?No, they went to see if the little girl was there.? I responded that I hoped they would find her somewhere in the apartment. At saying this, I saw the man. Who I knew later to be Madeleines father, running to the pool and to the childrens play area in the Tapas zone as if looking for someone. It immediately hit me that after talking to the older woman, that the little girl had not been found. I offered to alert the workers at the Milenium Restaurant and the man agreed. He then left again running to continue searching. I believe that this was between 21H30 and 22H00 but do not remember with certainty.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JERONIMO-SALCEDAS.htm

Woofer

Posts : 3390
Reputation : 12
Join date : 2012-02-06

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by ultimaThule on 15.10.13 17:16

Now that a revised and much shortened timeline has been established, what will become of these pesky indpendent witness statements which were made by those who had no axe to grind?   

It seems unlikely the pink one will be able to spin them out of existence big grin

ultimaThule

Posts : 3355
Reputation : 2
Join date : 2013-09-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Woofer on 15.10.13 17:48

Mike Sperrey and his wife were dining that night from 8pm but the PJ have never released their witness statements.  Wonder why?

Woofer

Posts : 3390
Reputation : 12
Join date : 2012-02-06

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by ultimaThule on 15.10.13 18:30

@Woofer wrote:Mike Sperrey and his wife were dining that night from 8pm but the PJ have never released their witness statements.  Wonder why?
Who is Mike Sperrey? Can he/his wife be found on mccannfiles?

ultimaThule

Posts : 3355
Reputation : 2
Join date : 2013-09-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by MRNOODLES on 15.10.13 19:11

@ultimaThule wrote:
@Woofer wrote:Mike Sperrey and his wife were dining that night from 8pm but the PJ have never released their witness statements.  Wonder why?
Who is Mike Sperrey? Can he/his wife be found on mccannfiles?
His name is mentioned ref Rasta Man.  But statements not released.

MRNOODLES

Posts : 637
Reputation : 200
Join date : 2013-07-04

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by stumpyhorlicks on 16.10.13 0:34

@ultimaThule wrote:Now that a revised and much shortened timeline has been established, what will become of these pesky indpendent witness statements which were made by those who had no axe to grind?   

It seems unlikely the pink one will be able to spin them out of existence big grin
Also dining at the next table to the Mccanns, were Stephen Carpenter and family, according to their statement they left the tapas 9:15/30 and walked by the back of 5A whereupon S.Carpenters wife says she heard someone calling 'Madeleine, Madeleine'...One wonders why these statements are seemingly  being ignored...and of course the dogs! new

stumpyhorlicks

Posts : 4
Reputation : 0
Join date : 2013-09-17

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by unchained melody on 16.10.13 0:41

It's information like this that really makes you think what the hell was going on that night!

unchained melody

Posts : 161
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2013-10-16

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Curioser on 16.10.13 1:25

Yes to all of the above. Plus Goncalo said in a video somewhere that he's not sure it was ROB who came back and had his dinner reheated. He seemed to be saying it could have been Gerry. It would have been difficult for the waiters to tell them apart. One tipsy customer or another? Meh.

I reckon the 9.20 is probably correct and they genuinely didn't know where she was (or some of them didn't anyway) at that time. They thought she'd wandered off and were really looking for her. Later they found her behind the couch where she had been before they even left for dinner.

____________________
I have no direct knowledge of the case. I'm just reading the files. It's all speculation. Don't sue me!

Curioser

Posts : 166
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2013-05-20

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by Curioser on 16.10.13 1:43

@ultimaThule wrote:
@Woofer wrote:Mike Sperrey and his wife were dining that night from 8pm but the PJ have never released their witness statements.  Wonder why?
Who is Mike Sperrey? Can he/his wife be found on mccannfiles?
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PASSPORT_ID_PHOTOS.htm

About a third of the way down under the heading GUEST RASTA HAIR. Nothing like rasta hair imho but one of the staff identified him as Sperry.

____________________
I have no direct knowledge of the case. I'm just reading the files. It's all speculation. Don't sue me!

Curioser

Posts : 166
Reputation : 1
Join date : 2013-05-20

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Where was Gerry 9,30 - 10.00pm?

Post by ultimaThule on 16.10.13 6:58

Cheers, MrNoodles and Curioser thanks 

With all due respect to Mr S, IMO his crowning glory is more akin to 'pasta' than 'rasta' hair laughat

welcome2stumpyhorlicks I'm newbie-ish too and I hope you find this forum as interesting as I do.

ultimaThule

Posts : 3355
Reputation : 2
Join date : 2013-09-18

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Page 2 of 5 Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum